X-Ray Report Of Today's Episode (20.12.08)

First Previous

Page

Frequent Posters

naik705

@naik705

Beginner

Posted: 16 years ago

#11

YASHITA IS NOT VERSATILE AT ALL........SHE IS ALWAYS SINGS PEPPY AND LOUD SONGS.....PRATBHA IS THE MOST VERSATILE SINGER ON SAREGAMAPA AND ONLY SHE DESERVE TO WIN THIS SHOW......

I LIKE YASHITA BUT IF SHE WAS IN INDIAN IDOL....SHE WOULD WIN DEFINITELY ...CUZ SHE IS INDIAN IDOL TYPE....

GO Pratibha......me and my frnzzzz all love her........

Quote

DizzyBanana21x

@DizzyBanana21x

Voyager

Posted: 16 years ago

#12

shoot, this might be Vaishali's week to go. She is the best. But I don't know. I doubt the channel will eliminate Himesh first.

Quote

Looks like you are new here. Register for free, learn and contribute.

Dabulls23

@Dabulls23

Stunner

+ 2

Posted: 16 years ago

#13

If anyone needs to go is Yashita.....Sorry guys she is degressing each day....Even Vaishali has not been perfectly great this week and she is my most fav within TOP 5

Quote

kuhu.kuhu

@kuhu.kuhu

Sparkler

Posted: 16 years ago

#14

Originally posted by: antar
X-Ray Report Of Today's Episode (20.12.08) - Written Update

X-Ray Results: An Aasma Effect Episode (All the contestants affected by Aasma Virus) 👏

2. Yashita (Dhoom Gharana)

Song: Mein Talli Ho Geyi

Singers: Aanmol Malik & .........

Judges Comments:

All Judges: History

My Comments & deserving marks:

Just watch her, just watch her. What a versatile singer she is. Her performance was fantastic & outstanding. No one deserves more than her to win this contest. She is the best.

To Me: Universal

O.kk I more or less agree with ur other judgements with little bit idhar udhar ...lekin Antarji aap sachmuch fida ho Yashita pe ....U call that universal???😲....I liked her performances despite many people not liking her but today she deserved a hit ..she was flat thruout the song.....

but it's not ur fault ...humare mananiya judges including Shankar must have had some magic potion when Yashita was performing ....they all gave her HISTORY .....

Sorry to offend u ....but I have decided i shall tell the truth and nothing but the truth 😃😃😃

Edited by bruno4 - 16 years ago

Quote

Nidhi

@nidhi2

Inactive

Posted: 16 years ago

#15

Originally posted by: antar

Thank you too. And about Asma's singing, seems to me " A Never Ending Story".
[/QUOTE

I agreee i think its just unfair to other participant who got eliminated...she is now just getting on my nerves...i dunno y dey want her to host wid Aditya...nd her jokes nd all r not even funny nemore !

Quote

Khatarnak

@Khatarnak

Rocker

Posted: 16 years ago

#16

Originally posted by: antar
X-Ray Report Of Today's Episode (20.12.08) - Written Update

I really admire Surgeon Antars dedication to this forum even though I do not agree with some of your views on tonight's performances.

Pratibha, Vaishali, Soumen, and Debo they were all outstanding but Yashita was not upto the mark.

I would love to see both Prathiba and Vaishali in the grand finale, I still believe even these two are not comparable to top 5 of 2007 (they were definitely superior). Thanks

Edited by Khatarnak - 16 years ago

Quote

sanjy

@sanjy

Beginner

Posted: 16 years ago

#17

I think they just made a scape goat of Vaishali by giving her a Super hit which must have been her first ever in the last several episodes. Shaayad usko unhe eliminate karvana hai to give up of a bengali😕

Quote

Antar

@antar

Voyager

Posted: 16 years ago

#18

Originally posted by: bruno4

O.kk I more or less agree with ur other judgements with little bit idhar udhar ...lekin Antarji aap sachmuch fida ho Yashita pe ....U call that universal???😲....I liked her performances despite many people not liking her but today she deserved a hit ..she was flat thruout the song.....

but it's not ur fault ...humare mananiya judges including Shankar must have had some magic potion when Yashita was performing ....they all gave her HISTORY .....

Sorry to offend u ....but I have decided i shall tell the truth and nothing but the truth 😃😃😃

Bruno & Khatarnak,

Basically we always saw her performing rocking type of songs. People always expected from her to perform at that genre only which a singer should never do and that's the reason many people didn't like her this performance, IMHO. A contestant should sing all types of songs and so far to me she is the only one did that mostly. But as you guys said, her this performance was not up to that mark then I must believe also in that. To me the analysis's of you guys can't be wrong. From now I will be more careful before reviewing on any ones performances specially Yashita's one 😊. Thanks a lot guys 😃. Cheers 🥳

Quote

Rani

@April2007

Inactive

Posted: 16 years ago

#19

I don't agree with judges regarding comments given to Vaishali..I went back on my PVR to listen again. The comments were wrong but at the same time I want to add that her song choice was not good.

Soumen had the best song choice. Vaishali should choose her songs well, if she wants to win this competition.

Pratibha used to impress me but her songing is very limited. Yashita and Pratibha are both at same level.

Quote

1 2

X-Ray Report Of Today's Episode (20.12.08) - Page 2

Related Topics

Explore Topics