SOME DOUBTS -SLB Episode - UAE

Sorry ,we are 1 week behind.

today saw the SLB episode

2-3 doubts.

while SLB was talking and giving suggestions abt the songs the contestants have to sing where was Hema(even Sharib was there).

How Vinit got 10 from all mentors (Zee tv fixed) even he had missed sur 2-3 times (it was very clear)and dint sing the song very good to get that points(no offense - he's a good singer)

why HR is giving topi only to vinit even Paresh is there in his gharana and also the smile in his face when vinit sings(when others sing he's got a dead pan expression)

Originally posted by: music_masti

How Vinit got 10 from all mentors (Zee tv fixed) even he had missed sur 2-3 times (it was very clear)and dint sing the song very good to get that points(no offense - he's a good singer)

why HR is giving topi only to vinit even Paresh is there in his gharana and also the smile in his face when vinit sings(when others sing he's got a dead pan expression)

so u want to start it all over again?? i am ready...

Originally posted by: music_masti

why HR is giving topi only to vinit even Paresh is there in his gharana and also the smile in his face when vinit sings(when others sing he's got a dead pan expression)

i was also wondering the same........he had no expressions when everybody was singing...looks like he is still carrying last week's fight(vinit's track).......

yea where was Hema??? was he sick or something as shaan did mention something abt that...???

i have no idea whats going on with zee.

I think this show has not been fair to the contestants. They are not voted according to their merits but according to other factors.

It is a sham all the way and I dont know what to expect next. People whom we think are good gets thrown out and the ones not expected to continue in the show gets good ratings.

No matter how much we complain, I dont think anybody is listening. I hope they will not even think of Saregamapa Challenge 2006. It will be a repeat of 2005.

dont start again.....

time has past sharib has lost...

i dont think you are a professional to notice the exct sur tal so plz we dont have right to comment that there sur was out etc... if you are professional then you can or else let the show go on as it is going on...

i dun think u gotta b a profesisonal to cooment on sur or taal. i think one should hav the knowledge about these things to talk about them. though nor an expert i kno a lil bit about this stuff so i cud make out that vinit was not perfect n certainly din deserve thos 10's. may b the judges did tht cuz it doesn'tmatter as adesh said. if thts the case then evry1 shud get a perfect.

Vinit deserved perfect TEN, and he GOT!

Sharib was there I though ... I think he sang Parda hai Parda ...

As AS mentioned, Hema was down with fever that week (maybe tensed about the result after he missed the track) ...

its kinda intriguing he got another SPB song to sing again in LP round ...

Originally posted by: music_masti

Sorry ,we are 1 week behind.

today saw the SLB episode

2-3 doubts.

while SLB was talking and giving suggestions abt the songs the contestants have to sing where was Hema(even Sharib was there).

How Vinit got 10 from all mentors (Zee tv fixed) even he had missed sur 2-3 times (it was very clear)and dint sing the song very good to get that points(no offense - he's a good singer)

why HR is giving topi only to vinit even Paresh is there in his gharana and also the smile in his face when vinit sings(when others sing he's got a dead pan expression)