in defence of asma

lot has been written abt asma's singing n manners.

Originally posted by: chichipopo

lot has been written abt asma's singing n manners.

i m from oman myself n can tell u one thing she is not rude for sure. here some of them do know hindi but in the same manner as asma - they spk broken for them tu n tum r the words they address without havin the least idea of a word called aap. there is no offence meant or disrespect. they just get the msg across. if u spk english too a you is a you n not tu, tum or aap.

she seems an excited kid not used to such an exposure n most omanis love hindi movies wheter they understand or not. she must be one of those movie buffs so all starry eyed when she meets so many stars whom she may never even have dreamt to see - let alone at such close qters so fumbles with her lang. whaterver littel she know.s

as for singing - well, little knowldege n she rightly claimed mugging helps

in fact i would give kudos to her for her attempts n doing a good job of it.

tho she may not be of a standard of vaishali, yashita etc. at least as so many others have pointed out - the lang is alien to her n considerign that factor she is ok.

her nasal voice - well, dont u all remember salma agha????? the paki singer.

ofcourse, v all no she wont win - n she too knows it - but dont tear her to bits so much

spkign of besura - well qazi has won so - either it is the judges' choice or people's choice.

Originally posted by: chichipopo

lot has been written abt asma's singing n manners.

i m from oman myself n can tell u one thing she is not rude for sure. here some of them do know hindi but in the same manner as asma - they spk broken for them tu n tum r the words they address without havin the least idea of a word called aap. there is no offence meant or disrespect. they just get the msg across. if u spk english too a you is a you n not tu, tum or aap.

she seems an excited kid not used to such an exposure n most omanis love hindi movies wheter they understand or not. she must be one of those movie buffs so all starry eyed when she meets so many stars whom she may never even have dreamt to see - let alone at such close qters so fumbles with her lang. whaterver littel she know.s

as for singing - well, little knowldege n she rightly claimed mugging helps

in fact i would give kudos to her for her attempts n doing a good job of it.

tho she may not be of a standard of vaishali, yashita etc. at least as so many others have pointed out - the lang is alien to her n considerign that factor she is ok.

her nasal voice - well, dont u all remember salma agha????? the paki singer.

ofcourse, v all no she wont win - n she too knows it - but dont tear her to bits so much

spkign of besura - well qazi has won so - either it is the judges' choice or people's choice.

Originally posted by: anjalibc

I fully agree with you. She is very sweet and innoncent child like. I love her and vote her. SHE HAS IMPROVED A LOT IN HER SINGING TOO. YES KUDOS TO HER FOR THAT AND FACING ALL STRANGERS AND SINGING IN A LANGUAGE SHE DOES NOT UNDERSTANT FULLY IS NOT A EASY TASK. SHE IS A BRAVE AND HARDWORKING GIRL. I WOULD NOT MIND EVEN IF SHE WON .