Farah = Not judge material

Page

Riya

@Riya.pk

Navigator

Posted: 16 years ago

After nov 8th's episode I'm so fed up with Farah, there is a limit to how much you can say negative things about a contestant but to say "you deserve 3 slaps?" who is she to say that? She is forgetting that it's just a dance show and she is just a judge, not some mughal emporer or something. 😕

She really needs to get a grip and start being professional because her comments make her sound ignorant and stupid.🤢 She is not judging material, because if she was she wouldn't go as far as personally attacking the contestants as if she's some bully.

For example: how she told Reshmi to "carry her own damn shoes" and all, I mean didn't Reshmi already mention to the judges that she has a slip disk problem, so she's not going to break her back by weaing a pair of heals just to make herself "look good". I'm sorry but even though it's a competition Farah shouldn't be so out there to force the contestants to risk their health just to "look good on stage", after all they are on the show to show their dancing talent.

Ughhh she makes me so mad!😡 In conclusion, in my opinion, even though she is a good choreographer and all, I don't think she's anywhere near a "good judge" label.

Edited by riyapk - 16 years ago

Quote

Frequent Posters

Naina

@dhoopkinarey

Voyager

Posted: 16 years ago

I miss Malaika as a judge--she was the perfect combination of critic and praise. I hate all the judges this season--they are way too much into themselves to actually comment on the jodis. Channel shouldn't go to people with big heads like Farah and Karishma; Arjun seems nice though.

Quote

Looks like you are new here. Register for free, learn and contribute.

Darshana

@darshana23

Inactive

+ 3

Posted: 16 years ago

Yes even this is true.....comments she gave sometime is so annoying and insulting.......... If someone is not comfortable in dancing with shoes then thats not going to make big difference.........

I remember Bakhityar pointed out Jeniffer during her first peformance in ZKND that if you are not comfortable in hills while dancing then why are you dancing with hills? Also he mentioned the fact that Mallika herself perform some dances with shoes and not in hills.......

Not wearing shoes in one factor that can reduce ur points but u shouldnt shout on someone to make it happen.........

Quote

AreYaar

@AreYaar

Icon

+ 19

Posted: 16 years ago

The judges just add to an already bad season of NB4....all three of them are really boring.....Farah tries to be all 'masala' with her comments...but I think it just ends up making her look mean and rude.....there just isn't enough material-jodiwise or dancingwise this season to make it all 'masaledaar'.....Arjun obviously is a judge only cuz he's in Farah's good graces currently.....otherwise he just doesn't have the charm or dancing qualifications to be a judge on this show.....his good looks not withstanding. Karisma just looks strangely robotic😕 (no offence intended)....I dunno if this is cuz the jodis/dancing (barring a few maybe) themselves are largely nothing much to write home about....but all of the judges look maha bored, not exactly adding to the appeal of this show.

In the last season, even Isha or David Dhawan weren't really qualified dancewise to be judges...but they managed to have their moments....and Vaibhavi didn't come across as mean as Farah....she was a character in her own right.

If this show even managed to have some good dancing, I think the judges might not be so irritating......but the standard of dancing on this show has sadly really gone down.....Barring one or two performances here and there, the rest of the dancing is either strictly average or just bad. And the in trying to be 'different', the concepts or themes that they've used this season have mainly just been strange and fallen flat.

Just my two cents.