right or wrong? - Page 3

Originally posted by: amreen1990

I think one was when Tina was a sardar. He gave 9 instead of 10. And also the time he cut off a mark because he didn't get the concept (the one where Tina was blind) but you're right about him knowing what he was saying. Most of the time he was accurate in his judging. If he was to judge in NB I think he would bring a lot of character to the show. Gosh Sameera was just a dummy judge (no offence to any fans!) but like you said, she just repeated GH's comments....but changed the words around lol. But Hopefully NB4 judges will bring their own personalities into the show 😉

Originally posted by: *Aaliya*

tina a sardar omg i think i missed that epi i think sony didnt have freeview then😡 oh yeah i remember when he did with the deja vu concept but manoj did exactly the same dance in mr and mrs tv and he got the same comments i mean the choreographer didnt change anything😕

i dont think sameera has many fans, i am sorry but she just judged their costumes i mean how is that related to the way they danced😕

yeah i really hope the judges are themselves and give fair and reasonable comments😳

Originally posted by: tvfan1401

Amreen, I voted a plain NOOOOOOOOO to AR....coz he has not proved himself in any field till now......regarding all the directors who were judges, we know that directors can judge the overall scenario and impact ... Farah is for dancing expert, Karishma is for Charm and personality, AR is for what???

Having said that, I also want to say that Sonali Bendre is doing a great job in Indian Idol, so AR can be a surprise too.,....lets wait n watch...

Originally posted by: soulfry

amz i too wanted ganesh hegde to judge along with farah. two choreographers would have been the best choice. karishma can judge chemistry, expressions and glamour(like sam reddy says) and other stuff. i have a feeling arjun will not talk much. ok he might prove me wrong and i hope he surprises us like sonali bendre.