Question: Blood Transfusion from someone else..

Posted: 17 years ago
#1
This is a question for thought, nothing related to real life or anything....
I was asked if I needed a blood transfusion would I take the blood.

My answer was yes I would take the blood.

Then my answer was followed by a second question;

What if the blood was from the person who eats meat/pork/beef etc..(and you dont eat meat, or pork or beef etc..)...

I already have my answer, but wanted to know what yall have to say... Think its pretty easy to answer..Saving someones life is more important regardless of where the blood came from..

In my head I said I would go to India (or find a fam member) but if someone needs blood desperately (i..e within1hr due to emergency accident) they won?t have the time to look for blood from a vegetarian/non beef/prok eater or have the time to fly to India.

What are your thoughts homies?

Edit:
Just spoke to my sister who is becoming a Doctor..
She says the body filters out the blood with the organs, just a thought..But its not like BAM, brand new blood etc..
"During systemic circulation, blood passes through the kidneys. This phase of systemic circulation is known as renal circulation. During this phase, the kidneys filter much of the waste from the blood. Blood also passes through the small intestine during systemic circulation. This phase is known as portal circulation. During this phase, the blood from the small intestine collects in the portal vein which passes through the liver. The liver filters sugars from the blood, storing them for later."
Edited by AsliiGuy - 17 years ago

Created

Last reply

Replies

9

Views

1.4k

Users

7

Frequent Posters

Sabah thumbnail
21st Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail Networker 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 17 years ago
#2
well i think its okay..in my opinion blood is pure and it is alright to take some1 elses blood in such cases
367848 thumbnail
Posted: 17 years ago
#3
Hello Bhaiya, nice topic, to my opinion I am being a pure vegetarian and non alcohol drinker, would say that when people go and donate blood, no one knows who that person is. Blood is checked for every possible diseases, like Aids hiv positive, TB or any blood problem.. But in India we donot know that this is properly done or not. Back street abortions, operations, kidney trasplants and other things, I would not say that it is very safe in india whether or nor not you eat meat or not. Even many diseases these days you get through eating meat like mad cow disease, chicken with chicken flu, and so on. Then again 8 out of 10 hospitals do not carry enough blood to use in case of emergencies. I have so many doctor friends and they say the same as well. Hygiene in the hospital especially pathological depts are not clean enough. You know the best my dear friend.
Posted: 17 years ago
#4

Originally posted by: RAJAYE_HIND

Hello Bhaiya, nice topic, to my opinion I am being a pure vegetarian and non alcohol drinker, would say that when people go and donate blood, no one knows who that person is. Blood is checked for every possible diseases, like Aids hiv positive, TB or any blood problem.. But in India we donot know that this is properly done or not. Back street abortions, operations, kidney trasplants and other things, I would not say that it is very safe in india whether or nor not you eat meat or not. Even many diseases these days you get through eating meat like mad cow disease, chicken with chicken flu, and so on. Then again 8 out of 10 hospitals do not carry enough blood to use in case of emergencies. I have so many doctor friends and they say the same as well. Hygiene in the hospital especially pathological depts are not clean enough. You know the best my dear friend.

good words Bhaiya, i have to agree..Some ppl dont know the other side unless they know ppl who work in hospitals etc.. Good point about 8/10 hospitals not carrying blood etc..
I have sene the machines that filter the blood out for testing (never really for sotring etc..)..Its impressive!
Good discussions and points all.
corvette thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail Engager Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 17 years ago
#5
Nice topic to discuss Asli....
For me Life is very precious - if giving blood helps it - then I'm up for it
I used to donate regularly and beleive very strongly in the concept.
As a healthy individual, it is a small thing to do if it saves lives.
Have a good day!
😡M😡
Posted: 17 years ago
#6

Originally posted by: Madmadgirl

Nice topic to discuss Asli....

For me Life is very precious - if giving blood helps it - then I'm up for it
I used to donate regularly and beleive very strongly in the concept.
As a healthy individual, it is a small thing to do if it saves lives.
Have a good day!
😡M😡

very nice of u to donate like that...I wish i can do it...Im so scared of needles..
ummmmm thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 17 years ago
#7

good question!

i don't know how to answer this one. although i am not a vegetarian, i don't eat pork, so i can understand how getting blood transfusions can conflict with beliefs. however, as others have mentioned, you never know who you are getting blood from when you go to the hospital (unless of course someone you know donates blood to you that moment). in the same sense, when you donate blood, you never know who will end up receiving your blood; for all you know, it could be some gangster who sells drugs and gets caught up in robberies and shootings every weekend.
91118 thumbnail
Posted: 17 years ago
#8
I think life has higher value than any practices or beliefs, so yes, I'm vegetarian, and I'll donate and accept blood (provided the blood group matches, of course!😉)
nitasuni thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 17 years ago
#9

Originally posted by: inavars

I think life has higher value than any practices or beliefs, so yes, I'm vegetarian, and I'll donate and accept blood (provided the blood group matches, of course!😉)

I accepted blood during one surgery, I don't know who is the donor, whether he/she eats non veg, consumes alcohol etc, But it helped to save my life and no difference in my basic behavour or opinion, that is donation of blood is one of the best thing one could do to save a human being.
In India, (Kerala), in my city, there are several wold class hospitals visited by foreigners (not NRI's) for treatment. they are well equiped, neat and well maintained, but they are costly. Now inspite of so many complaints even the Govt, owned hospitals are also somewhat well maintained . There are a lot of qualified, kind and humane doctors and para medical staff. Here we get blood from IMA Blood banks but we have to give back (our representative) the quantity of blood we received. After some complaints the blood is very very strictly tested for deseases.
Posted: 17 years ago
#10

Originally posted by: nitasuni

I accepted blood during one surgery, I don't know who is the donor, whether he/she eats non veg, consumes alcohol etc, But it helped to save my life and no difference in my basic behavour or opinion, that is donation of blood is one of the best thing one could do to save a human being.
In India, (Kerala), in my city, there are several wold class hospitals visited by foreigners (not NRI's) for treatment. they are well equiped, neat and well maintained, but they are costly. Now inspite of so many complaints even the Govt, owned hospitals are also somewhat well maintained . There are a lot of qualified, kind and humane doctors and para medical staff. Here we get blood from IMA Blood banks but we have to give back (our representative) the quantity of blood we received. After some complaints the blood is very very strictly tested for deseases.

Great comments every1..I agree, its a gift from someone, and it helps your well being..I think any1 in a life/death situation wouldnt mind...
Thanks for the info all, very nice responses...👏

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".