Judges too Nice?

Page

Next Last

neelam

@Neelu.RoX

Inactive

Posted: 17 years ago

Don't you guys feel the judges are way to nice! I mean they havent critisized 1 person since the judging begun. I mean HELLO?Its your job!

I feel like the contestants find more faults in the others performance than the judges do. For example: Baktiyaar and Jennifer bit last week, and Karishma saying Amit didnt lip sync. the judges never even mentioned.

Maybe its just me, but what do you guys think?

Quote

Frequent Posters

293418

Suspended

Posted: 17 years ago

Yeah, that is true. But I kinda like how the show is not overly dramatic if you know what I mean. I think they will get harsher eventually. Right now it is a bit too amiable for its own good, I suppose.

Quote

Looks like you are new here. Register for free, learn and contribute.

@Kobe_Bryant

Navigator

Posted: 17 years ago

hell no and today when Amit got out. i was pissed as hell at them b/c it was totally miss judge by them. we all know Amit was the best against that Bidai girl(dont' know her name).
even my parents got mad b/c they judge him so wrong.

i hated them b/c of judge wrong Amit on Khalas round.

UNFAIR

Quote

Megha

@mango-frost

Stunner

+ 2

Posted: 17 years ago

i agree....the judges are soft with their comments....but i think their judging isnt that bad....i just dont noe how they judge cuz their comments dont impress me much....but their marks are pretty fair...i guess i agree with their judgements....itz just their comments towards the performance which are weird lol

Originally posted by: kalhonahogames
hell no and today when Amit got out. i was pissed as hell at them b/c it was totally miss judge by them. we all know Amit was the best against that Bidai girl(dont' know her name).
even my parents got mad b/c they judge him so wrong.

i hated them b/c of judge wrong Amit on Khalas round.

UNFAIR

no actually if u watch cafefully.....amit didnt perform too well.....he didnt complete all his steps...he just did them from the top and didnt finish them off well...he had many gaps in between for no reason...like while going from one step to another..he wud pause and just look lost...

his beginng was very weak as well....at first i thut it was interesting...but it was tooooooo longg...i was like okay come out and show some dance now...but he kept going on with his dialogues...

he was full on energy tho, which is commendable....but technically he wasnt that great....he was also very stiff...in bhangra u gotta move like crazy and shud have alot of twists, turns and bends, especially bending of the knees.....which i didnt see much of....he did some good steps, like the helicopter one...but it wasnt enuff.....and his song was nagada baja.....NOT ONCE did he baja the nagada...even an imaginary one...he had the stick and the crisscross thing (which was actually good)....but thas not a nagada loll

ashita was awesome on the other hand....her body movement was fabulous...her expressions were mindblowing....she didnt leave any gaps in between while going from one step to another....if she did, it went along with the choreography, for example wen she walked over to the girls to sit on the table thingy....and her song was about a dholi...she played a dhol in the begining....and even afterwards she did many steps showing taht she's playing a dhol....she added not just bhangra steps in...but also some gidda movements in there.....she totally deserved to be safe...

amit was good....but ashita outdid him...it was pretty fair....

Quote

yipee

@yipee

Sparkler

+ 2

Posted: 17 years ago

i completely agree with u srk_lover...

Quote

@Kobe_Bryant

Navigator

Posted: 17 years ago

srk_lover

i guess it's just different point of view from different person.

Quote

Tamana

@afghanitam

Inactive

Posted: 17 years ago

Originally posted by: kalhonahogames
srk_lover

i guess it's just different point of view from different person.

I totally agree here .. everyone have different point of view .. i think that the judges don't think it's an important thing to sing while dancing .. the see how they dance, how their steps are and how is the energy and so on .. and I too think it's not important to sing .. but that's my opinion ..

Quote

amber

@xXdEejAyXx

Rocker

+ 4

Posted: 17 years ago

ya but its good dat dey r treating all contestants soo good

Quote

qtgurl

@qtgurl

Explorer

Posted: 17 years ago

i like the judges
they r not mean wit ppl n thats the best thiing abt them

Quote

ahad

@ahada

Voyager

Posted: 17 years ago

#10

i think the gudges are fair. even though i don't like that girl who competed with amit but i think she performed way much batter then amit. if you see the steps and energy you will agree with me.

Quote

1 2

Judges too Nice?

Related Topics

Explore Topics