judging makes no sense

i watched the july 16 episode...n honestly i enjoyed more than half of the performances i loved hiten-nadini's performance, and vishal-dimple's performance, and some others...but it seems that the judging seems utmost ridiculous...why the hell would you look at costumes and glamour is the first question that comes to mind...i meant its a dance-based reality show not fashion/glamour based....the comments made by sameera are unecessary...and ganesh's comments at times arent fully etched out...work on smile/expressions ok....but how was the dance overall...he mentions it sometimes...but fails to judge as a choreographer i believe....vaibhavi merchant did an excellent job in nach baliye...even farah does better....last but not least....mahesh bhatt....what is that guy thinking....i mean just becuz he is a director he knows how to evaluate if someone is passionate or sensous....i mean in his movies how does he portray mention...kissing...sleazy sex scenes...he doesnt portray aesthetically or metaphorically he puts in a literal in the face sense....so the way he judges the chemistry makes no sense whatsoever....he says there was no passion...well how so...?? i found karan-nandini's song pretty sensous...but maybe's thats my opinion...i agree wid gauri when she said that the show's rules and criteria seem unclear because this show's concept is somehow being distorted....i think ekta had a great concept at hand which was ruined by the judges she choose..... Edited by livinglove - 15 years ago

I agree with you. Rather than judging on actual performance and choreography:

^^ lol so true! To be honest, the judges have been quite a dissapointment so far I'm esp dissapointed with Mahesh Bhatt. He may be a successful film director but I don't think he can tell the difference between passion and vulgarity. I also feel he has been quite harsh on Karnvir and Tina, in particular today when they had done quite well.

I thought Ganesh would be better but I don't understand the basis of his judgements. Sameera has been ok, nothing special, but  is judging the way she had said she will judge. Overall, not really impressed with the trio!🙂 Edited by aaliya007 - 15 years ago

k i agree wth tha 3 of u cause Ganesh i thought at 1st waz k but nw after cin 2dayz epi im rely depressed cause al they did waz judge in costume expression etc... but tha dancin ..... but also 2day i thought some couples did less dancin ( 2 me) over all i serously think we neeeeeeeeeeddddddddddd NEW JUGDES!

 

ESP  MAHESH BHUTT CAUSE I THINK HEZ GON  CAUSE I CNT UNDERSTAND HIM 4 HEVENZ SAKE! 

completely agree with all of you and i think they should have been public voting ,how can only 3people judge their chemistry.

the nb judges were way better ofcourse! sajroj khan's critism ment some thing so did malaika's comments very meaningful here so the standrd of the show seems very poor

itsde cheapest show where mahesh bhatt wants to see vulgerity , ganesh want to see vulger facialexpression[rememberwat he said tonandini dat y u were laughing on dhakdhak kerne lagau shud be giving dhak dhak kind of expression] n den sameera she is seing sexy attire//