gawd! were they harsh or wot?

hey guys, all of u who watchd II2 didn't u think Farah and Anu malik were a bit too harsh and rude to the contestants. i mean just the look on the poor guys face esp the one to whom farah gave a banana was too awful, yaar. and its not like anu is that great a singer himself! sonu was a bit more restrained i think.
also did any one notice for the guy whose mom came and pleaded -- their clothes were the same but the judges had managed to get changed!

yeah, i think they were unnecessarily rude to some of the contestants (wearing those ridiculous masks, showing signboards that said ghar jao) anf unnecessarily nice to some, like that guy who was given a second chance. I mena fine, maybe he WAS sick, but its unfair to give second chance only to one person.

The judges should behave consistently with everyone!

yep i agreed wid u...they were harsh to the contestents as they were in II-1..i didn't liked anu's and farha's attitude at all..but yes i liked tht person the most who mimic anu mallik.LOL..he was having a lot of guts."but anu mallik toh naraz ho gaye" 😉 !

I found anu and farah both rude in indian idol 1 auditions as well . i really hated their attitude, i dint think they had respect for human beings at all. i agree there are some people who dont sing well or who dont dress well, but you have to understand the situation in india not every can afford good clothes. They have all come to try their luck and they need to be treated with dignity and respect . no one needs to made fun of like that, specially celebrities. They entertain people notmake fun of them . i live in usa i am really hoping to see that this time anu and farah arent that rude like they were in indian idol 1.

exactly, i mean u can give u'r honest opinion without being so rude. i mean being sarcastic is also ok , but yesterday they were downright mean to the poor contestants.

I didn't like the banana thing that Farah did. They should have a nice way to turn the contestants down.Weather they can sing or not but they surely have lots of hopes and dreams like anyone else, which should be consideres.

Originally posted by: pl-person

I didn't like the banana thing that Farah did. They should have a nice way to turn the contestants down.Weather they can sing or not but they surely have lots of hopes and dreams like anyone else, which should be consideres.

right u r

Originally posted by: niky

I found anu and farah both rude in indian idol 1 auditions as well . i really hated their attitude, i dint think they had respect for human beings at all. i agree there are some people who dont sing well or who dont dress well, but you have to understand the situation in india not every can afford good clothes. They have all come to try their luck and they need to be treated with dignity and respect . no one needs to made fun of like that, specially celebrities. They entertain people notmake fun of them . i live in usa i am really hoping to see that this time anu and farah arent that rude like they were in indian idol 1.

the same kinda of attitude is continued to II-2...sometimes i can see sonu too making fun at the expense of contestants...i am loosing respect for him...farah and anu were never in my good looks....but sonu....hmmm

I found it funny...But seriously if one noes tht he/she cant sing.. why the hell even try ur luck?.. ur wasting ur own time.. as well as others...\
Also, I think tht its necessary to understand the judges position as well...First of all they have been sitting listening to contestants all day long..out of which a lot of ppl cant sing at all.....They must be irritated.. also i think they r told to be funny in the shows... for higher TRP...Also, I dunno if this is sadistic but i enjoy watching the funny contestants.. Its they hu wanna make a fool of themselves// not exactly my fault!..I just enjoy their foolishness

exactly....i mean i was feeling sooooo bad for the poor souls who came with so much hopes and dreams
of course not all these dreams r gona be fulfilled but there is something called 'manners'.....i wud say if the contestants ever behave badly with the judges, then and only then can the judges be given the right to act sarcastically like they did yesterday....tab maza aata 😆 ...but yesterday was just like omgggggggggg wayyyy rude 🤢