Swara Bhaskar's insensitive remarks on Jauhar scene from Padmavat- Page 16

Swara Bhaskar = Scum

Originally posted by: Clochette

Okay... last try... "reformer" is a term associated with the person of Mohammed by historians and I align with this opinion... so it is n o t a bias but based on what this man did at his lifetime on the socio-political level. India also has famous people given the term "reformer" (e.g. Raja Ram Mohan Roy and Dr. B. R. Ambedkar). Also, Mohammad is n o t a god but seen by Muslims as a prophet. In Islam , the god is Allah... and Muslims only pray to Allah as far as I know, not to Mohammad.I

As for Swara... no, I don't support her... would you read more of my posts in this thread you would know that I don't like her, and certainly not her focus on "vagina" when it comes to Jauhar. Writing about patriarchy doesn't make me a supporter of Swara.

Your underlined statement is absolutely correct. What is not correct, is what you wrote just before... I myself only criticized the way Bhansali presented Jauhar (which indeed supported a romaticized impression about Jauhar, imo).

Please don't keep drawing me into these discussions. God. Prophet. Historians. Good attempt but won’t work. . AI isn't something that will change my views as a true historian and you changing context ignoring holy wars. Crusades.and so on. This out of context references just like the whole movie that I am now sure you haven't even seen doesn't give you the last word or final word.

I have seen in the other thread where you inserted freedom of speech of my country in a topic on Amir and wangchuk. It's a clear pattern. Gitmo proved that there is no arguing and reforming religious zealots. Enhanced interrogations failed to overcome this. So I do not wish to discuss this further. AI is artificial intelligence. It does not make long essays reality but rather illustrates a lot of ignorance without any contex logic reason or actual studies in history. Hence disconnect with actual historians like me.

What kind of historian you may be, I just ask myself - obviously not knowing much about what "reformer" meant... but okay... as I already wrote, it was a last try. You clearly made up your mind about me

Originally posted by: snatch

Swara Bhaskar = Scum

There are worse words that come to mind but that one also fits the bill