Mannat Har Khushi Paane Ki: Episode Discussion Thread - 41 - Page 127

Originally posted by: Ecstatic.rafa

I’m a silent visitor on X as well, and I do agree that some people unnecessarily defend Vikrant’s blunder. But I don’t fully agree with you because the majority do understand Mannat’s pain and trauma. Also, I understand that in ITV, male leads are often made to compromise for the sake of dragging the story, but according to me, the leads should be the last ones to compromise. P.S. You are only listing Mannat’s POV, which is absolutely true — no girl deserves such trauma. But that day wasn’t easy for Vikrant either,he got biggest shock of his life and that day eveyone was dhokhebaaz for him. His biggest mistake was falling into Vishakha and Malla’s trap and character assassination.

Toh why doesn't he try to change this aspect of him & use his brain.Even today during court case today he kept on thinking what Yashika said to him as if Dua & Mannat are some objects to be played like a tug of war btw him & DK.

He had accepted in front of Neetu that he should have listened to their version & tried to understand & they were just trying to protect him from getting hurt.

When he knows that Mannat was innocent & it was actually Neetu who is the catalyst of all issues then why such easy forgiveness to his mother & not to Mannat. After she had to come back to SM did Vikrant even once aplogize to her separately. He only apologized when he got to know about Dua.

Since u said i am listing only Mannat’s pov pls go thru all the threads, read all the points & then you can come back.

Also if majority really understood Mannat's pain then till date no one would have blamed her for being abandoned by Vikrant publicly even after knowing largely it was RoTu's fault and Vishaka's scheming.

It doesn't matter whatever the situation is, no guy or girl has the right to abandon the partner in the marriage hall like this & also its not like Vikrant came back to her to complete the remaining pheras again. It was Mannat who had come back. He made her run to fetch for proofs in that heavy lehenga as well. Also, by the time he actually came back that too at funeral things were already over for her. She had lost everything... what if post all these Mannat had suffered a miscarriage ?

I am also 100 % sure if today Mannat had abandoned Vikrant at marriage hall after knowing ARS is real mom & Shruti isn't then she would have been blamed, bashed left & right throughout the year.

Originally posted by: sadiltl

You still havent answered my main question. Will you let Vik have custody, even shared if he is the way he is now? After ARS reveal? The way he cant judge people, tomorrow he will let Dua with ARS's look alike if she comes as nanny and shows paper "proofs". Vik is in that position. yes or no? Read my comments in blue.

I should keep tagging you since you are raising the same points I have raised earlier

I did reply to you on the custody part... today and previously... I dont see the logic of it on why need to fight it in court or why Vik needs solo custody when he can file for a joint one!!!!

But thats not something I can answer because I am not the writer/ producer or onscreen judge 🤦‍♀️

The only reason I see is all this ... the secret marriage, Duas legitimacy, social wedding which was broken, DM fake marriage are all questionable stuff... and now that its open in court... they no longer remain relevant if the custody decides in favour of one of the leads... so this is a like a culmination of all that stupidity 🙄.

And like I said today... if they ever plan to make DK fully negative... Vik would need this 'proof' to protect Dua and Mannat 🤦‍♀️

To isme kya kar sakte hai????

Is it in our hands... are we claiming it Oscar worthy????

Also who decides on good and bad writing... its subjective isnt it??? What matters is the perception and interpretation...

As long as it fits the storyline and overall narrative with closing of all loopholes I would say its good writing....

Its 400+ episodes now... and yet there is no end in sight... some would call it good writing in ITV terms 🤣

Originally posted by: Moor278

To isme kya kar sakte hai????

Is it in our hands... are we claiming it Oscar worthy????

I dont understand what you mean

Oh I don’t know but I felt extreme judgement on my opinions from my ghum friends past few days. My posts nor comments were well received rather I felt a lot of judgement repeatedly 😀 so I thought you guys are enjoying the writing which kind of confused me 😳 seriously . But that’s ok. No one is correct here. It is all subjective

Originally posted by: sadiltl

Oh I don’t know but I felt extreme judgement on my opinions from my ghum friends past few days. My posts nor comments were well received rather I felt a lot of judgement repeatedly 😀 so I thought you guys are enjoying the writing which kind of confused me 😳 seriously . But that’s ok. No one is correct here. It is all subjective

I will respond on this on DM

Originally posted by: Mona_HappyLife

Kya ajeeb zabardasti hai bhai..

Jab chaho nikal do life se, jab chahe tamasha bnao, jab chahi wapas haq jatao but you have to listen to me & I wont..

Mai nai sudhrega.....bass...

That day people on the X were like why Mannat is lying, why is she not bringing up full past, why should she when both mother and son themselves are happily burrying it without much efforts? Also I don't know if people read the custody notice or not, but Vikrant has straight up lied in that stating Dua is manipulated against him by his client, her mental health isn't well with Mannat, basically painted Mannat DK as incompetent parents while he will be better. Why that woman won't stoop low then? Mannat said it right na, if Vikrant can oust his parents of many years within a blink of an eye and worse is, won't look for them for years, what gurantee he won't do it with her and her child? She heavily paid the price for this mother son duo, why would daughter should do that as well?

Originally posted by: Kidult104

That day people on the X were like why Mannat is lying, why is she not bringing up full past, why should she when both mother and son themselves are happily burrying it without much efforts? Also I don't know if people read the custody notice or not, but Vikrant has straight up lied in that stating Dua is manipulated against him by his client, her mental health isn't well with Mannat, basically painted Mannat DK as incompetent parents while he will be better. Why that woman won't stoop low then? Mannat said it right na, if Vikrant can oust his parents of many years within a blink of an eye and worse is, won't look for them for years, what gurantee he won't do it with her and her child? She heavily paid the price for this mother son duo, why would daughter should do that as well?

What the ??

I could not read the entire document, just could read "parental alienation"

Bhai waahh !

And the audacity of Neetu & Vikrant to act all surprised today and she asking him to not worry about Mannat not bringing the past mistakes.

Waooo... great..slow claps...

I don't think majority of the people event noticed what was written in the document.

They have anyways been directly blaminh Mannat for speaking ill about Vikrant when the bts came out...lol...

I actually felt bad for Vikrant today while watching the episode. AdSha both did their parts well..but this document thing is straight up mud slinging, 1st you do CA with your own bro preleap simply on the basis of a picture presented to you & now you also raise questions post leap on Mannat's ability to be a good mother or not.

🙄🙄😪😪

Originally posted by: Kidult104

That day people on the X were like why Mannat is lying, why is she not bringing up full past, why should she when both mother and son themselves are happily burrying it without much efforts? Also I don't know if people read the custody notice or not, but Vikrant has straight up lied in that stating Dua is manipulated against him by his client, her mental health isn't well with Mannat, basically painted Mannat DK as incompetent parents while he will be better. Why that woman won't stoop low then? Mannat said it right na, if Vikrant can oust his parents of many years within a blink of an eye and worse is, won't look for them for years, what gurantee he won't do it with her and her child? She heavily paid the price for this mother son duo, why would daughter should do that as well?

Makers could have shown the document paper properly.

No one has even read whats written in it and adding to that apparently people in X think today's episode is one sided (i.e. Mannat)

🤡

Originally posted by: Moor278

And I do agree with you ki it is as simple as correcting the birth certificate

Which is a legal process BTW 🤣🤣🤣

Birth certificate change hoga because that is not their OG plot