Mannat Har Khushi Paane Ki: Episode Discussion Thread - 41 - Page 113

Originally posted by: Moor278

My take has always been this that DK cant develop feelings for Mannat when they established a brother sister relationship in the show pre leap.

Originally posted by: Moor278

I cannot agree with you today Cool...

Whatever DK was saying was erased by the arm grab he did to Mannat!!!! In that moment he wasnt Duas father but someone who knows Mannat will never choose him if offered a genuine choice!!!!

And no that manhandling is where I draw a line...

Chalo acchha hai vaise... I hope ab rishta comparisons nahi honge!!!

DK is so not the AA today 😡

Ehhh… I am confused after reading your post… I guess I didn’t take that as manhandling .. we know the ML(not just this show quite a few) have done worst yet they are hailed as showing passion for the FL. Yes agree he should have not behaved this way… what made me mad was that he was blaming Mannat for conspiracy with Vik. He was a true supporter of Mannat… Everything else he said like Mannat giving up as soon as she sees Vikrant is true. Every time you can’t just melt because Vik was under the influence.

I loved Mannat’s outburst… she is right in her position. Vikrant could have solved this with a conversation and give some time her!
We expect Vik to be mad ay Mannat for not telling her the truth and when he gets angry it’s justified. Keep aside the equations why is DCP not allowed to show his emotions? Compare them as two human being (male that too) one is allowed to show anger frustration and then get it brushed as he was not given all facts so his anger and outrage is justified. DCP is losing his daughter- the fear is real - he has no stakes in Dua life. No blood relation no attachment to Mannat, I am no way defending him… (mera kuch nahin lagta) …. just putting another perspective here. Btw I for one want DCP ka original character arc he should actually be the one to tell Dua that Vikrant is her father. I want DK to step aside and be the greater person that he is who selflessly helped mannat Ronnie and Neetu…. But yeh hoga nahi kyunki this is itv… abhi toh sirf shuruat hai he is going to do much worse that is the only way to life Vikrant

It took me two episodes to fall for Vikrant I was already melting and hoping they find a way to keep both fathers. Why does one have to leave? Oh well!

Will DCP kidnap Dua or Neetu? Bet lagate hain

Like I responded to Nuts earlier today... if we called out Vik for pushing and shoving Mannat, we can call out DK too...

I didnt like it because its not as if DK doesnt know what Mannat feels for Vik. Yet when he says she chooses him, it doesnt come across as a rhetorical point but a frustration that she wont choose him.

What does vo "hamesha jeet ta hai?"

Are Mannat and Dua some trophies to be claimed????

I don't mind his fear for Dua... but he is also not willing to acknowledge that Vik is Duas biological father...

Khair... he is going to go even more unhinged if Vik gets custody (as per spoilers) 🙄

I want Mannat to see this too as only then she would come out of her indebtedness for him!!!!

They have lived and worked as partners for so long that she doesnt even realize when he takes over and starts deciding for her 🙄

I only want to see Aishwarya ka comeback to screw Mannat and Vikrant’s life.

Anything apart from that is bore for me.

Originally posted by: Daman17

This post is about the legality of custody, not about any character. In Mannat, proper legal aspects were only shown during Shalini’s case after that only mockery of legal, moral systems. Legal battles and morality are barely explored in this show, the writers are mixing pre leap and post leap curries to serve their verdict in khichadi…Mukta is judge and writers are lawyers here… From professional POV, If we look at it legally, Mannat could face more issues than Vik. Forging or changing a birth certificate is a serious offence in India. When parents are separated or not legally married, both have rights, and one parent cannot take away the other’s rights without consent. Changing a name without proper legal process can create serious problems. Also, custody does not depend on marriage. A parent doesn’t need to be married to claim custody. The court mainly focuses on the child’s welfare. For younger children below 8 years the court may not even rely much on their choice as they can be influenced. Overall, this custody track is typical ITV drama where only selective issues are shown. In reality, both sides need strong evidence and past history matters a lot even if case is a fast track one. Without knowing the history how can judge even pass the verdict🤔 minute details mattered. Coming to Vik, makers have deliberately kept him unaware of the truth of child and divorce to help him with his stakes in custody. All the more legal battles doesn’t settle in 1-2 hearings like it happened in ITV😂 let’s see Mukta’s verdict in this case😂😂

At the end of the day we all know, ladh marr ke ek chhat ke neeche he rehna hai according itv school of laws and regulations. Till this day too they all were living together, bolne ke liye outhouse thha but now they all will get official 2 kaudi ke court ka order to live together and do kalesh

Originally posted by: Moor278

Like I responded to Nuts earlier today... if we called out Vik for pushing and shoving Mannat, we can call out DK too...

I didnt like it because its not as if DK doesnt know what Mannat feels for Vik. Yet when he says she chooses him, it doesnt come across as a rhetorical point but a frustration that she wont choose him.

What does vo "hamesha jeet ta hai?"

Are Mannat and Dua some trophies to be claimed????

I don't mind his fear for Dua... but he is also not willing to acknowledge that Vik is Duas biological father...

Khair... he is going to go even more unhinged if Vik gets custody (as per spoilers) 🙄

I want Mannat to see this too as only then she would come out of her indebtedness for him!!!!

They have lived and worked as partners for so long that she doesnt even realize when he takes over and starts deciding for her 🙄

I am in no way defending him or his behavior…. But everyone was telling me this was going to happen… so I am a tad surprised why are you so upset about this! Everyone kept saying DCP will become negative …. If anything I should be the one heart broken for his behavior

This is going to go up another notch warna Vikrant koh kaise justify karenge!

Mannat is probably not reacting because of the 7 years… and knowing him … this whole indebtedness is not making sense to me. DK ne help kiya toh iska matlab yeh thodi hai ki he owns them… puri zindagi thodi aise ehshaan leke ghumegi… what’s the point of helping then. That’s where I want DCP to back off.

Btw mein thak gayi DCP ki baat kartein hue..

switch gears… Mannat and Vikrant

Who is right here? Mannat seh yeh expect kyun that she allows Vikrant to be part just because he was under the influence? For Mannat it’s traumatic nah that she was left alone … granted Vik koh pata nahi tha.. but from her POV she did go to talk to him. Ush chakar mein Shruthi bhi gayi.. Mannat’s outburst is so legit.. Vikrant was asking to be part of Dua’s life and then 360 he is asking for full custody. “Full”… why? He could have talk her nah… joint custody mangta…

Vikrant ka dialogue that he is convinced once he gets Dua, Mannat stays back then give some time and everything will be okay she will come around as time goes…. How illogical is tha?!

Originally posted by: Moor278

DK

No one has a right to behave like this with a woman!!!! Whoever she maybe

Your pain doesn't justify this manhandling

And if Mannat is supporting this... God what a downfall

In other news...

Mannat is highly triggered because of the custody case... this has brought out her worst trauma to life!!!! Of Vik snatching Dua!!!

Neetu escalates the issue in an attempt to pacify Mannat.

DKs outburst makes a little sense but not his behaviour to Mannat!!!

He blames her for still loving Vik and surrendering to him everytime (well this the FD agrees 🫣).. for having planned everything with Vik so that Fua can be taken away from him. 😐

Mannat tries to make him understand but she is meek... very meek 😒

Y proposes friendship and breaks off the relationship from her side... Vik is happy... calls her the best 🤦‍♀️

Most importantly Mannat hasnt forgotten the divorce papers... but she doesnt mention it explicitly kyunki writers ko abhi Malla ko expose karna nahi hai and Y ko ammunition dena hai 🤦‍♀️🤦‍♀️🤦‍♀️🤦‍♀️

Frustrating episode as a viewer for me the verbal violence!!!!

RD... your wish has been granted!!!! 😢

As usual didn’t see the episode. It’s sad I like AdSha, want ManVik together but out of its 1.5 year run, I have easily not watched at least half of the show by now. Lost I only gave up before the hijacking.

Definitely happy I didn’t watch today as comments on X & insta had already alerted me on the meltdown that Decay had. Gonna say something controversial but all 3 Kumars are psychopaths!

What right does Decay have to ask why Mannat still loves Vikrant & melts seeing him? Some are theorising that the 7 year rift was meticulously planned by Decay but Mannat still today didn’t understand what he said today to her. Dua is just a side dish. Mannat is the main course. Had I seen today’s episode I don’t know who I would have beaten more - Neetu,Decay or Vikrant.

Looks pretty certain Decay will abscond with Dua & ask for Mannat in return.

Deva re deva - Mannat, girl kahan phass gayi tu?? Truly a cursed life thanks to the sadistic writers.

”Khwaab Khushi Paane Ki” should have been the title.

Mera Bunty kahan hai? The only one who makes me smile these days!

Originally posted by: Coolmeg

I am in no way defending him or his behavior…. But everyone was telling me this was going to happen… so I am a tad surprised why are you so upset about this! Everyone kept saying DCP will become negative …. If anything I should be the one heart broken for his behavior

This is going to go up another notch warna Vikrant koh kaise justify karenge!

Mannat is probably not reacting because of the 7 years… and knowing him … this whole indebtedness is not making sense to me. DK ne help kiya toh iska matlab yeh thodi hai ki he owns them… puri zindagi thodi aise ehshaan leke ghumegi… what’s the point of helping then. That’s where I want DCP to back off.

Btw mein thak gayi DCP ki baat kartein hue..

switch gears… Mannat and Vikrant

Who is right here? Mannat seh yeh expect kyun that she allows Vikrant to be part just because he was under the influence? For Mannat it’s traumatic nah that she was left alone … granted Vik koh pata nahi tha.. but from her POV she did go to talk to him. Ush chakar mein Shruthi bhi gayi.. Mannat’s outburst is so legit.. Vikrant was asking to be part of Dua’s life and then 360 he is asking for full custody. “Full”… why? He could have talk her nah… joint custody mangta…

Vikrant ka dialogue that he is convinced once he gets Dua, Mannat stays back then give some time and everything will be okay she will come around as time goes…. How illogical is tha?!

Naa naa...sab kuch Mannu ki galti, full 2 A-Z. Thats why morning mei I said it had much better been if she had died (falling from the cliff) that day...

Fir dono Kumar bhai logs ladke marte pure zindagi bhar...

😂

Originally posted by: Mona_HappyLife

Its better Mannat had died from cliff.

Dk & Vik would have fought with themselves entire life.

Sab kuch Mannat ko hi karna padega thali sajaake

I would never want any FL even a fictional character to die for a man.

Ideally she should give a big f*ck you to both Kumar brothers, take her Dua and raise her independently like her Shruti maa did!

The have turned her& Dua in some kind of trophy that they need to win