Mannat Har Khushi Paane Ki: Episode Discussion Thread - 41 - Page 111

Originally posted by: nutmeg7

So if DK was not the elder brother, would that have been okay?

Not the manhandling... feelings part yes

Originally posted by: nutmeg7

I don’t believe in this flag system in real life also

What amuses me is that Vikrant girlies will point fingers at “decay” at slightest irritation but will shield their Raja beta for ghor paap also.

Unko jaane do... thats a lost cause

Originally posted by: shiro_shinchan

https://x.com/tulip1917/status/2051510145419489648

Apparently Mannat is also now the culprit of not mollycoddling Raja Babu enough when he was manhandling and being abu$I’ve under the garb of shock and heartbreak. I’m not even gonna go to the $lut-shaming aspect of the track

Its better Mannat had died from cliff.

Dk & Vik would have fought with themselves entire life.

Sab kuch Mannat ko hi karna padega thali sajaake

Lets talk about legality ONLY. Which is mostly formulated on morality, provided there is enough evidence

A child who is born in wedlock, even if the parents divorced, belongs to both parents. Thats the main purpose of a marriage, to bear children legitimately. If one parent hides the child, when the child is born in wedlock then the other parent can definitely move the court.

Even if the couple are in agreement, and in a live-in relationship, the kid now a days is considered legitimate given that the parents stayed together even after the kid is born. New laws are being made around it. Basically, both parents should show commitment towards the child as parents. Same laws of parentage applies as in marriage.

But imagine a guy who makes a girl pregnant and leaves her at wedding altar. If he didnt hear what she said, if he didnt know about the pregnancy cannot be proved in the eyes of law. Judge is not an emotional fool to listen to all these stories. I had mental breakdown because my birth mother is revealed and my foster parents lied so my brain didnt work and in anger I didnt listen. Imagine a judge listening to this. .

Vik's only option is to shut up and wait for acceptance. Which he doesnt have in his character yet, and the writers dont want to give him that.

https://x.com/i/status/2051492097610359105

Today's episode was triggering at so many levels.

• Mannat was almost going to faint seeing the court summons. Neetu & Dk support her. She calls out to Vikrant. DK starts shouting, tells her, Vikrant has done it again. The night before he said something else, and today he comes with court summons.
• Dua and gang are leaving, she drops her pencils, stops to pick them up. mannat sees her, and tells DK to stop because Dua's listening. DK is not able to control his shouting. Dua leaves, but is suspicious. Yeh ladki sachchai ka pata kar hi legi. Am sure she will start snooping.
• DK walks out.
• Mannat realises that neetu is behind all this. She tells neetu that Vikrant always lives upto her expectations. She always feared he would take Dua away, and he is doing just that. Neetu tries to support Vik, tells her that this house is hers, and Dua's. Obviously Mannat is not going to listen. Neetu tells her that Vikrant has enrolled the kids into summer school so that the kids will not be home when they go for the hearing. Oh how caring, Vikrant
• Mannat tells her DK and she have stood together and faced many troubles, and they will fight against this once again together. She says as Dua's mother she 't will anything to keep Dua away from Vikrant. After this, he doesn't deserve to be in Dua's life.
• Yashika & Malla are listening. Malla is calm, tells Yashika, she knew it, Mannat will never leave this place.
• Yashika meets Vik in court, and has a mild confrontation, she asks him if he still loves Mannat. He tells her he has never stopped loving her. Apologises to her. She breaks off the engagement, says they can still be friends, he is very grateful.
• Mannat comes to the OH, to talk to DK. DK is furious, Manit acts well in the sense he looks scary. He accuses her of planning the whole thing. he says again & again, he will not give up Dua. Mannat keeps trying to explain that she will not let it happen. he tells she always says Dua is her daughter, when Dua is their daughter.
• He says he is leaving with Dua. Mannat says she has gone to summer classes; he gets furious, and says she is going alongwith Vikrant's plan. he holds her arm, pulls her and tells her, he doesn't trust her because she still loves Vikrant. he says she always surrenders to Vikrant. Mannat looks ashamed almost. She justifies herself saying she told Neetu they would fight together. And yes, she looks completely scared about losing his support, tells him, what will happen to her if he leaves?? Just then, Dua enters.

It was not a pleasant episode. I hate both the Kumar brothers for putting Mannat through this. I want her to run away with Dua.

Well, Mannat's biggest fault is she is sensitive enough to understand where the other person is coming from.

She kept going back to Vikrant during the wedding because she knew he was operating out of trauma. She understood his POV till he CAed her. Even at the funeral she told him, she understood his anger.

Even now, despite DK behaving so badly, she is fighting for him, and she even tells Vikrant later that he is in pain of losing Dua.

Both the times, she is putting the other person's POV before her own needs and self respect. She should have slapped DK today or at least, pushed him away. And if DK apologises as Vikrant has done many times before, & got away with it, she will forgive DK. Why forgive, at this point, she understands him completely

The Mannat who stood upto everyone during Shalini's case has disappeared.

mujhe pata tha tumhara take sane hi hoga

Originally posted by: scarlett22

Well, Mannat's biggest fault is she is sensitive enough to understand where the other person is coming from.

She kept going back to Vikrant during the wedding because she knew he was operating out of trauma. She understood his POV till he CAed her. Even at the funeral she told him, she understood his anger.

Even now, despite DK behaving so badly, she is fighting for him, and she even tells Vikrant later that he is in pain of losing Dua.

Both the times, she is putting the other person's POV before her own needs and self respect. She should have slapped DK today or at least, pushed him away. And if DK apologises as Vikrant has done many times before, & got away with it, she will forgive DK. Why forgive, at this point, she understands him completely

The Mannat who stood upto everyone during Shalini's case has disappeared.

Scar you cannot expect her to react in split seconds.

I think people feel Mannat is some super human being. She will change her emotions in split second.

Was her reaction also this fast when she started understanding how ARS really is, how Malla was pretentious or how Vikrant is ?

No right ...

Again, this is about ML and FL

If ML can get EBed all the time by the wrong people and get all the sympathy because he is good human being then why not extend the same for Mannat ?

I dont get this blaming her for all the A-Z reasons.

Just few days back I had mentioned that DK's anger issues are coming out now which was not there in these 7 years. It will be a plain suprise for anyone.

Kumar brother's behavioural issue is not Mannat's problem. Its their problem.

If they can't deal then sure both the bros can do their own WWE fight but no more drag Mannat into it.

I had said the same for Vikrant & would say the same again for DK too - that being an emotional wreckage and hurting, shoving Mannat won't do good to him. He needs to mend his ways as well.

Otherwise the days aren't far when he will get slapped by Vikrant...

Fully agree.

What I meant is she is somewhat consistent with the way she understands people and their vulnerabilities. She gives everyone a long rope, not just Vikrant.

BTW I had expected a greyish turn to DK because of Dua. But not this much, I certainly did not expect him to manhandle her