Mannat Har Khushi Paane Ki: Episode Discussion Thread - 41 - Page 107

Idhar I support Mannat which makes me a huge hypocrite as I hated Akshara for doing the same exact thing

Chalo I saw so many posts which are either supporting vikranth or mannath....

I was so busy as parents are visiting , tho episodes dheka nahi + I don't feel like watching also... lost few days i was rewatching sasural ghenda phool... kithna acha tha yaar, on serious note aaj kal ka shows should really have some positive episodes... ithna negativity is so draining...

In between looks like vikranth himself filed the case... one day he promised happy family and next morning mannath got the notice... I agree he got to know about dk mannath marriage truth but don't know that... she kind of might felt like backstabbing ... that I didn't like ,unless he have some strong reason to not inform to mannath about filing a case ahead... I really didn't that fact... other than that.. I didn't see the episodes... so no idea.. so comments

Originally posted by: Mona_HappyLife

Vikrant should not get full custody. No way.

Even if Mannat's unplanned pregnancy with him or Dua wasn't involved, no one can change the fact that he dumped her publicly at the marriage hall after making all those promises in terrace, marrying her unofficially & ended having consensual s**.

A person who can do the above, can also all of a sudden kick Mannat out again in future..where she will go then ? & most importantly why she should always end up bearing the entire brunt of his impulsiveness, his rash decisions & his usual habit of listening to other's version & not her ?

No one is denying that was he under immense mental pressure after the Aman truth came out but when even after all these Neetu gets all the forgiveness so easily then why not the same for Mannat ?

Why he always keeps on taking such drastic inhumane measure when it comes to her only ? Even after Neetu clearly spelling out to him that DK Mannat were never involved with each other, he still got influenced by her & ended up asking for full custody even after knowing what all Mannat has gone through...Joint custody ke liye bhi apply karta na toh bhi sahi tha....

Kis chiz ka itna nafrat hai I don't understand till date...I don't see such behaviour towards others.

Only tall claims of Love is not going to fix any relationship. He needs to mend his ways first, needs to give assurance to her that he is not going to take any decision to future out of impulsiveness or someone else's influence.

And also if he now really plans to have Mannat back then he needs to clear out to Yashika that he doesn't want to move on with her. He cannot keep both the women in the same house & destroy both their lives (this is as per the fact that Vikrant is not aware of Yashika being a GD, only we viewers know this)..

Everyone's life cannot run as per Maa Beta wants...they cannot really have everything their own way. And if they do that then will again pay for it..

Bold: inexplicable behaviour only towards her. She is better off alone unless he changes.soon.

Writers (I really hope you are lurking here)

Leaving aside DK, just tell me one thing why anyone wants Vik in their lives or their child lives?

He is not YET

1. Reliable

2. Dependable.

3. Sympathetic to middle class insecurities.

4. Empathetic to "parental" feelings.

5. Share any deep bond with anyone, nor with the women in his house, nor with Mannat, nor with DK who he loved till few days back. The way he treats Yashika, his fiance is deplorable (Remember that for Vik, she is not evil...basic common sense as writers)

6. Figured out that Neetu is not a great mother. She is neither a good mom nor a good human being. Vik can love her, but as an adult you should know who she is! We all love our mothers, but as adults we know their weaknesses also. right? Use your own personal experiences. Again basic trait of writers.

Lets say he is traumatized, then it becomes more than a good reason for him to not raise a child. He either shouts or begs. Nothing in between. Which version to trust? He doesnt make a sincere attempt, no patience, no tolerance, no judgement. Why should any woman come back to him. or make him father of her child. Put yourself in Mannat's shoes and THINK. and then write who will Mannat like to be in their lives?

Why cant YOU change him? Uou dont know how to because you are not using brains to THINK. TAtleast observe your own emotions, that might help you write things logically if not realistically. You are just writing the dialogues, lifted from X and social media. Thats why you seem confusing and divisive. Look at the court arguments . It is Mannat and Vik fandom fighting... Thats why the fans keep arguing and analyzing in circles. YOU as a writer have to take the audience through the journey, not taking their analysis and adding it in the story. One episode full of fans' arguments. .

Do you know how you want to take this plot from here? I dont think so you know. Wait for ideas on X and IF to see how people react and then put them in one episode.

I will tell you how to start, go and search online "How to write redemption arcs in a story". The first thing they advice is to "take time". Show the introspection. The best way is to make the character lose everything....so they will stop and think. Get Vik to the roads please. That will be a good starting point. Or get Yuvi's parents if the boy still matters to vik. According to you he lifted Vik from drowning into misery. Use that. If I were to write from here, I will just make Vikrant go to Indore to find a place in Dua's heart. It is bare minimum he can do to show that he can leave everything for her!

I am repeating again and again....Vik is coming out as rich spoilt brat who has no thinking ability nor empathy nor realization. It is not about Adnan or Vikrant, they are writing every character like that except Mannat. With Mannat, they are following basic FL traits common in ITV show, which are usually GOOD and consistent. Not that they are creative here. If you just follow ITV FL template, it will work 90% of the time.

I am really surprised how these people are able to survive in this competitive show business. I think it is just that they have some reputable actors running this show. May be it is just colors thing where they are ok with substandard writing.

PS: My post is only for writers.

Mannat forum ke pages bhi ab same ho gaye hai. Pata nahi chalta kaunsa forum hai. Full déjà vu.

Apna kaam bas 🍿 hai.

Originally posted by: Ajab.Pehchan

Idhar I support Mannat which makes me a huge hypocrite as I hated Akshara for doing the same exact thing

This is so apt for Decay after watching today's BTS🤬

Continued....

One more tactic of writers to normalize things so they can quickly grab sympathy(read next plot). Let's use Ronnie's character which is shown to be wiser and redeemed among the other characters to achieve this.

Make him say that DK and Vik are equal for Dua? How? You didnt show any bilogical pull between them. Which you could have shown...but sorry it is too late. Then you show DK and Dua inseparable which is understandable, logical and true for any child who finds a loving care giver. Now you realized (again from X and IF) that Dua and Vik should bond for the story to progress. So they bond within a month? Lets say suddenly Dua had biological pull or affection due to month long stay with him. Still you cant make her emotional bond with Vik equivalent to DK, who raised her!!

And who did you choose to brainwash this "LIE" as a "FACT" into audiences mind? Ronnie. Because he is now a good guy. Wow. (slow caps).

Now we all should believe, without any feelings, that for Dua, DK and Vik are the same. So lets start the game between the two! How on earth anyone can relate to this?! If you have raised a child, it looks so forced. IMO, to win Dua's heart, Vik might take a life time unless you show DK as abusive parent to her henceforth. I mean you can show that also because you write only toxicity and evil characters who otherwise DO NOT exist in wholesale, except in psychology wards or jail.

I am really enjoying this stupidity.

Originally posted by: Mona_HappyLife

The audacity to blame entirely on Mannat

Lol..

Maa Beta & X lovers all want the world to run as per their whims & fancies

It’s hilarious folks expecting accountability from “Decay” which should have been reserved for the ML

Bhai dono main fark hi kya reh jaayega? Vik’s supposed to be the ML right

I had always wondered how can women irl be so hateful towards another and then I come across such misogynistic tweets

Originally posted by: Mona_HappyLife

The audacity to blame entirely on Mannat

Lol..

Maa Beta & X lovers all want the world to run as per their whims & fancies

Shouldnt they question Shruti too..why she made herself Mannat's maa, when she is her maasi🤔?