Kyunki Saas Bhi Kabhi Bahu Thi-EDT #16 DT note p25 - Page 72

Originally posted by: The_Best

When I said he abandoned his sick wife, I am talking about his duty as a husband to be loyal to his wife and not go and have sex with his mistress because his wife is sick. I am not talking about paying hospital bills and visiting Nandini once in a while. A husband can support the wife financially, but if they go have sex with someone else then that’s cheating and abandoning the wife. In fact, what Karan did is far worse to cheat when his wife is sick. So yes, Karan did abandon his sick wife to go have affair with his mistress and have a child with her. By doing that, he also committed a crime. Bhoomi doesn’t exist, but Tanya exists and his child with Tanya also exists. Makers haven’t denied about Tanya or the child with her. You can think Tanya may be his legal wife her or teenage lover. You are free to do if that fits your narrative. I am not going to do that. I thought Mihir cheated until makers said something else. If tomorrow they say something else again or deny that, then I will be back to that Mihir cheated and same with Karan

Do you have an argument to say that Nandini went into coma as per S2? if so how did she slipped into coma? Since you want to argue on facts lets get this basic fact settled.

Also do you have argument to deny Karan fathered Parth in his teenage as per S2 canon? if so I would love to listen to this fact too as per S2.

Originally posted by: Me_Harini

Do you have an argument to say that Nandini went into coma as per S2? if so how did she slipped into coma? Since you want to argue on facts lets get this basic fact settled.

Originally posted by: The_Best

She went to coma in S1 and S2 haven’t denied that. We are following S1 from S1 until they say something else or show something else. So same with Nandini. She was in coma when Karan cheated and had a child with his mistress

Ok she went into coma as per S1 as you said and you want to follow just till she went to coma...let me agree on this...what is the reason though for her slipping into coma according to you as per S2 narrative and what is the argument to deny that Karan didn't father Parth in his teenage as per S2?

Originally posted by: Me_Harini

Ok she went into coma as per S1 as you said and you want to follow just till she went to coma...let me agree on this...what is the reason though for her slipping into coma according to you as per S2 narrative and what is the argument to deny that Karan didn't father Parth in his teenage as per S2?

Originally posted by: The_Best

S2 is following S1 story until makers say otherwise. So Nandini went to coma in S1 and that’s what’s fact. Why are you on your own want to change stories for S2 despite makers haven’t mentioned that? Again, you can can do that if that makes you happy and fit in with the narrative you want to go with, but you can’t expect others to go by that

Did I change the story in my previous reply...I asked you valid questions for which you are not answering. I am ready to accept your narrative if you give me exact narrative as per S2. You are mentioning according to S1 nandini went into coma...she went yes but you are not ready to tell me why she went into coma as per S2...and saying I am changing the story...I am not even asking you to accept my narrative while you are not answering valid questions you are starting to blame me saying I am expecting others to go by my narrative...

If you want to argue with me just help me better understand the narrative set by makers as per S2.

How did nandini slipped into coma?

When did Karan father parth as per S2...

These are questions as per S2 ...there are neither any stories nor my narrative but my genuine questions to better understand your narrative of calling karan a cheater.

Forget S2. You can’t even accept that Karan cheated in S1 and keep making excuses for him. I can’t have the same conversation over and over. Fine. Karan is an angel for you. I don’t know why you even want to argue or debate. You can’t expect others to have same opinion as you. Karan is a cheater as per what’s shown in S1. That’s what I am going by. I don’t have the energy to keep on debating and going over and over with this

Originally posted by: Me_Harini

Did I change the story in my previous reply...I asked you valid questions for which you are not answering. I am ready to accept your narrative if you give me exact narrative as per S2. You are mentioning according to S1 nandini went into coma...she went yes but you are not ready to tell me why she went into coma as per S2...and saying I am changing the story...I am not even asking you to accept my narrative while you are not answering valid questions you are starting to blame me saying I am expecting others to go by my narrative...

If you want to argue with me just help me better understand the narrative set by makers as per S2.

How did nandini slipped into coma?

When did Karan father parth as per S2...

These are questions as per S2 ...there are neither any stories nor my narrative but my genuine questions to better understand your narrative of calling karan a cheater.

Originally posted by: The_Best

Why should I answer you based on S2 when everything has already been shown in S1 and you can get your answers there? This season is continuation of S1 except for the parts when they said something else. So they haven’t denied Nandini’s coma and other stories this season. Therefore, you can go back and watch S1 to get your answers rather than asking me over and over

This is selective argument...if I ask abt S1 you wudn't answer...if I ask abt S2 you wudn't answer...if logic is presented as per S2 you are not ready to accept and its such a futile argument ...you are saying this is continuation of S1 but not ready to acknowledge same what is established in S2...If this was continuation of S1... I am just asking a genuine question "How did nandini slipped into coma?" for which you dont have an answer...Karan met Tanya in his early 20's...and he had kid with Tanya after 3 yrs or so as per S1...In S2 he is shown to be in mid 30's...if this is continuation of S1 then him having son from Tanya basically means that kid wud be around 8-10 yrs but he is shown to be a father of a adult 18 yr old kid...you dont have a justification of how can Karan is father of 18 yr old kid while being married to Nandini and cheating her in S2...If you find enough justification as per S2 let me know else this discussion is futile where you are picking narratives as per your convenience and again I will only respond if you can justify how can Karan father a son of 18 yr old son while cheating nandini at 36 else this will be my last response to you.

Originally posted by: annihilation

I HAD to login to check wtf is going on with Kyunki S2 now?! Like Aakashdeep as a (supposed) son to Hiten/Karan and Gauri/Nandani/that new female lady character?! He looked so awful. If they were so desperate to get him back somehow in order to touch upon Tulsi's trauma and encash on that track, they were a dozen ways to do so and make it more sense. I had completely forgotten about Eklavyya and I don't even remember how he was Ansh's son and with whom back in the later seasons of kyunki. Don't even remember him dying too at Tulsi's hand.

Laana hi tha toh ussi character ko revamp kar dete that he survived somehow, went into hiding, built a new life and is back now. This Riyansh/Rio is now Ansh's son too, woh bhi pata nahi Nandini se aur someone else altogether or this new female character whose name I can't seem to recall. Again, I repeat, at least some good deaging technology should have been used in order to sell this nonsense.

Originally posted by: Me_Harini

This is selective argument...if I ask abt S1 you wudn't answer...if I ask abt S2 you wudn't answer...if logic is presented as per S2 you are not ready to accept and its such a futile argument ...you are saying this is continuation of S1 but not ready to acknowledge same what is established in S2...If this was continuation of S1... I am just asking a genuine question "How did nandini slipped into coma?" for which you dont have an answer...Karan met Tanya in his early 20's...and he had kid with Tanya after 3 yrs or so as per S1...In S2 he is shown to be mid 30's having son from Tanya which basically means that kid wud be around 8-10 yrs but he is shown to be a father of a adult 18 yr old kid...you dont have a justification of how can Karan father 18 yr old kid while being married to Nandini and cheating her in S2...If you find enough justification as per S2 let me know else this discussion is futile where you are picking narratives as per your convenience and again I will only respond if you can justify how can Karan father a son of 18 yr old son while cheating nandini at 36 else this will be my last response to you.