Mannat Har Khushi Paane Ki: Episode Discussion Thread - 38 - Page 138

Episode Discussions

Created

Last reply

Replies

1.4k

Views

65.2k

Users

33

Likes

6.7k

Frequent Posters

ChaoticTangles thumbnail
Explorer Thumbnail
Posted: a day ago

Originally posted by: Rdigest

Love how you always give the parallels between the lead characters ❤️ . Guess we should be glad the writers write same junk for both characters smiley36

a cheers to equality poster with two mugs of beer

I actually have another parallel too.. but people might misunderstand I am justifying vik... just to be clear I am not,vik is definitely wrong in CA mannat, and he need to redeem big time to get another chance from mannat.. but mannat too CA vik during vik-malla track.. she said "aap bhi sab mard ki tarah hai, mannat nahi to malla,malham lagane ke liye"... even if he actually moved on with malla,what's wrong,they broke up the previous right and vik had right to move on with anyone.. if she is upset about how fast he moved on she could have just stopped by saying that his love is shallow.. but her saying this malham, mannat nahi toh malla etc is CA.. Mannat too was pretty upset with this vik-malla thing and said few hurtful words in anger, bitterness and feelings of betryal,but despite feeling she is wrong we felt she deserved another chance because she realized her mistake and redeemed...

Then shouldnt we give same BOD to vik... vik said hurtful things, realised his mistakes in 7 years but now after seeing mannat and dhairya together he went back to the same day, he is still reliving the trauma of same day, so he is saying and repeating a lot of things in bitterness, yes this is no justification for the words he used..i am myself pretty upset with the way he is going overboard,he needs to realise and regret ,redeem a lot.. but microscoping on every mistake of his is just futile even for us..

ChaoticTangles thumbnail
Explorer Thumbnail
Posted: a day ago

Originally posted by: Kidult104

As much as I remember, Gagan was neither thrown out of house nor he was made to feel poor. Mannat never acted as some audacious person or anything. The latest ManVik confrontation didnt sit well with many people because agree or not, Vikrant did come across as a prideful person. I can definitely understand his hurt and he found a way to let it out, but I would have understood if he would've said stuff about Mannat leaving him for his brother or anything. Going on her financial crisis, stopping the business deal in between when he was just the middle man, calling her thagne wali, shameless, gold digger, opportunist what not where each of these tags fits him well. Why doesnt he have an anwer when someone shows him a mirror about his snatching the property and sitting on it? If Mannat would've been gold digger or opportunist, why would she have given up her shares immediately along with ronnie?

My concern is, Vikrant is definitely looking like a rich brat and I dont want that tag on him for long. It will make his redemption shallow. I would've loved if he would've taken only his shares, but he didnt. 7 years and he still doesnt have much of regrets of living off on that money. Thats worrisome. He has a child now who is grown up in a grounded environment. Will he have answers to her that why he lives in richness while her mom and his parents are living in simplicity?

I want the bankruptcy track for Vikrant himself. Except vamps, majority of positive character have gone through that middle class or less money phase except Vikrant, which is why many a times those characters come across more practical than Vikrant. He has genuinely gone of the track and this tainted wealth is definitely one of the reasons. He needs to be cleaned off that richie rich tag for sometime.

Bold: That's what I am saying it's plot loop hole, just like mannat not returning ars property to gagan.. even if gagan was not asked to leave, isn't it mannat's responsibility to give back the property to rightful owner, gagan was seen saying so many times that he doesn't have money, mannat didn't think of giving back his rights at those times??, it's not her charecter graph right??even I know it, mannat would have definitely returned back the property, but it's just plot loop hole that she didn't . . just like that vik would have definitely returned back the property to rotu and felt guilty about the money but they are not addressing this because of poor plot/writing

And I have said vik went overboard with mannat the other day.. but it's not pride, it was bitterness and wanting to trigger her so that she will show her feelings regarding him...it is absolutely wrong no matter the emotions behind it ....but it's not pride....If it was pride or wanting to put her down, he wouldn't have asked to keep an eye on her after she literally blasted him off.. mannat rightfully insulted vik, but any egostic, prideful person who looks down on other person would have not cared about why the person needs money after getting insulted by mannat in most humiliating way.. but vik immediately asked his PA to check out for mannat...

Just like @ Moor mentioned ,Basically vik wants mannat's reaction and attention, he is purposely triggering her to push her to express her feelings regarding their past, he is not liking mannat's indifferent attitude... so ya it's not vik's pride or brattish attitude, or him wanting to look down on mannat Or her financial status but its his bitterness,anger.. Nevertheless he is wrong and needs to change his approach..

Edited by ChaoticTangles - a day ago
truptishree thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 180 Thumbnail + 3

Team Vikrant

Posted: a day ago

Originally posted by: ChaoticTangles

I actually have another parallel too.. but people might misunderstand I am justifying vik... just to be clear I am not,vik is definitely wrong in CA mannat, and he need to redeem big time to get another chance from mannat.. but mannat too CA vik during vik-malla track.. she said "aap bhi sab mard ki tarah hai, mannat nahi to malla,malham lagane ke liye"... even if he actually moved on with malla,what's wrong,they broke up the previous right and vik had right to move on with anyone.. if she is upset about how fast he moved on she could have just stopped by saying that his love is shallow.. but her saying this malham, mannat nahi toh malla etc is CA.. Mannat too was pretty upset with this vik-malla thing and said few hurtful words in anger, bitterness and feelings of betryal,but despite feeling she is wrong we felt she deserved another chance because she realized her mistake and redeemed...

Then shouldnt we give same BOD to vik... vik said hurtful things, realised his mistakes in 7 years but now after seeing mannat and dhairya together he went back to the same day, he is still reliving the trauma of same day, so he is saying and repeating a lot of things in bitterness, yes this is no justification for the words he used..i am myself pretty upset with the way he is going overboard,he needs to realise and regret ,redeem a lot.. but microscoping on every mistake of his is just futile even for us..

👏👏👏👏👏

Ditto!

Rdigest thumbnail
Hogwarts Championship 2025 Thumbnail Fashion Feud Participant Thumbnail + 9
Posted: a day ago

a cartoon penguin wearing a crown and holding a microphone with the word boom below it

scarlett22 thumbnail
Visit Streak 500 Thumbnail Visit Streak 365 Thumbnail + 6
Posted: a day ago
WittyKittyVixxy thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 90 Thumbnail + 3
Posted: a day ago

Episode is out.

Vikrant & Yuvi….throw the same kind of tantrums.

The tug of war Yuvi scene was really cringe 🤢

Moor278 thumbnail
Visit Streak 750 Thumbnail Visit Streak 500 Thumbnail + 9
Posted: a day ago

I had a thought... they can still make Vik bankrupt or rather poor you know.... saw this in another show... so its an obvious ITV trope.


Malla can ask all the property be transferred in her name in exchange for Yuvi.

If Malla gets exposed for her role in the divorce paper drama, Vik can oust her but she has Yuvi as her trump card. She can ask for property in her name in favour of Vik continuing to stay with Yuvi or her not taking him away from Vik. Vik will do that.

It would be parallel to RoTu signing off their property for their son.


Yuvis birth truth wont be out by then which is how Vik can then claim the property back. 😜

Edited by Moor278 - a day ago
Kidult104 thumbnail
Visit Streak 750 Thumbnail Visit Streak 500 Thumbnail + 5
Posted: a day ago

Originally posted by: ChaoticTangles

Bold: That's what I am saying it's plot loop hole, just like mannat not returning ars property to gagan.. even if gagan was not asked to leave, isn't it mannat's responsibility to give back the property to rightful owner, gagan was seen saying so many times that he doesn't have money, mannat didn't think of giving back his rights at those times??, it's not her charecter graph right??even I know it, mannat would have definitely returned back the property, but it's just plot loop hole that she didn't . . just like that vik would have definitely returned back the property to rotu and felt guilty about the money but they are not addressing this because of poor plot/writing

And I have said vik went overboard with mannat the other day.. but it's not pride, it was bitterness and wanting to trigger her so that she will show her feelings regarding him...it is absolutely wrong no matter the emotions behind it ....but it's not pride....If it was pride or wanting to put her down, he wouldn't have asked to keep an eye on her after she literally blasted him off.. mannat rightfully insulted vik, but any egostic, prideful person who looks down on other person would have not cared about why the person needs money after getting insulted by mannat in most humiliating way.. but vik immediately asked his PA to check out for mannat...

Just like @ Moor mentioned ,Basically vik wants mannat's reaction and attention, he is purposely triggering her to push her to express her feelings regarding their past, he is not liking mannat's indifferent attitude... so ya it's not vik's pride or brattish attitude, or him wanting to look down on mannat Or her financial status but its his bitterness,anger.. Nevertheless he is wrong and needs to change his approach..

Still I dont think it is justified. Even I understood why he was so bitter and this is his newly found technique to instigate Mannat so that she will react or give him answers, but I would have understood if he would have taunted her about settling down with his brother or something because I think even Mannat wouldnt have been surprised considering her snd dk's married facade. He again acted exactly the way he did during ice kaand, used his weight and that comes from that Saluja tag and wealth. In ice kand everyone let it go because he was shaken due to betrayal still it affected Mannat so much that she turned bitter. Now he was doing the same. He was just a middle man, who is he to decide whether to give money or not? It was a deal between her and sinha. Why did he do that? Because he had power and she had need. Being pompous about money, mocking her, calling her gold digger out of nowhere, all this while sitting on the stolen property without any regret. I dont see that as a loophole, I see that as audacity. I'm not saying to return it to salujas but where is his conscience or guilt? Even a little bit? He has nothing.

Again saying, I dont know how will they pull it off but they better make him value the money by stripping him off from his wealth atleast for some time.

Moor278 thumbnail
Visit Streak 750 Thumbnail Visit Streak 500 Thumbnail + 9
Posted: a day ago

The issue with this is Mannat said all this to Vikrant AFTER seeing Vik and Malla married.

Vik said this to Mannat on their wedding mandap DURING THE WEDDING RITUALS where Mannat was literally the blushing bride eager to get married to him.


Agree on the part that the words were harsh... but the CONTEXT in both cases was vastly different smiley20

Edited by Moor278 - a day ago
FUITV thumbnail
Visit Streak 90 Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 2
Posted: a day ago

Apparently acc to Mr Saluja, Yuvi running away is Mannats fault because if she hadn't shown the video , he wouldn't have scolded Yuvi and Yuvi wouldn't have left.Apparently he hasn't scolded him in 7 years. Like does this even make sense , he was the one insulting mannat and dua all this while near the pool and mannat defended her daughter. Heights!

Please don't come at me saying it's not his real son, but from viks own words Yuvi was his reason for survival.

Related Topics

Mannat Har Khushi Paane Ki thumbnail

Posted by: nutmeg7 · 1 months ago

WRITTEN UPDATES AND DAILY DISCUSSION THREAD NO 37 Welcome to Mannat - Har Khushi Paane Ki EDT

Expand ▼
Mannat Har Khushi Paane Ki thumbnail

Posted by: Shemer · 7 months ago

Welcome to BTS Thread of MHKPK...

Expand ▼
Mannat Har Khushi Paane Ki thumbnail

Posted by: purplegirl7 · 1 years ago

Welcome to Chat Corner for Mannat forum We can do gupshup here

Expand ▼
Mannat Har Khushi Paane Ki thumbnail

Posted by: nutmeg7 · 1 years ago

Permission given by Leprechaun

Expand ▼
Mannat Har Khushi Paane Ki thumbnail

Posted by: nutmeg7 · 1 months ago

WRITTEN UPDATES AND DAILY DISCUSSION THREAD NO 36 Welcome to Mannat - Har Khushi Paane Ki EDT

Expand ▼
Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".