Mannat Har Khushi Paane Ki: Episode Discussion Thread - 38 - Page 81

Originally posted by: jhalak7

How did Vikrant suffered more than Mannat? She took care of his duty...uska maa, papa, Bhai + uska beti. ( hmm uski bhi) 🙄Plus built a business.

They should unite. But punishment toh banta hai for choosing the wrong side and stay tight there. Not moving and doing more wrong by inviting troubles like Yadhika, Yuvi...etc. He invited all the unwashable troubles like these in his own effort. Can't call this suffering.

Welcome to the forum ❤️

Where did I write Vikrant suffered more than Mannat or Mannat suffered more than Vikrant?

Yes, both Vikrant and Mannat deserve punishment for not choosing eachother and trusting others over eachother.

The point I was making with the post was , pre-leap Mannat made a choice by picking RoTu/DK over Vikrant whatever maybe the reason and she shouldn't get the option to make a choice again if it comes to that juncture.

I am a ManVik and ManVik fan only and if any cross marriages are shown I am out.

Originally posted by: Rdigest

I didn't want to write this and might delete later I don't know

If Mannat is ever shown to be confused even after finding out Vikrant was a victim as much as she was a victim, she shouldn't get the option to choose. Vikrant suffered for 7 years, while she has suffered she atleast had Dua, it's better she clarifies this with Vikrant so he gets to make a choice this time. Because, pre-leap whatever maybe the reason Mannat chose DK/RoTu over Vikrant, the choices she made brought them to this juncture, she cannot do the same to Vikrant again.

RD

I somewhat agree with you on this. I didn’t watch SS guy but I am not able to understand Mannat’s stance. Why she will be confused? She loves Vikrant right? I understand her anger the way he behaved but they all were equally responsible for the lie right?

Again I agree that pre leap she chose RoTu and DK over Vikrant. In fact she should’ve been there for him as a partner to deal with the catastrophe of his life. I know this is also a point for argument so I will let it go😜.

Bold- bang on.

This time let Vikrant decide 🤞

Originally posted by: Bettyscar

What life would Mannat be returning to in the DK choice? Before she leaves for Mumbai she is going to sell Dua's kitchen. RoTu it's a no brainer who they would choose. Whatever she decides they would probably have shared custody of Dua with Vikrant.

I can understand her being hesitant to give Vikrant another chance given the trust issues and the heartache that came with the separation but i don't understand the DK angle being a choice further down the line. DK makes sense before things normalize and there is some semblance of a family unit.

Bold - absolutely, if she doesn't want to forgive Vikrant for CA , I am all for Mannat, go for it. But the choice part Naa👎.

Rest I am trying my best to not make a comment since it's 🤢

Originally posted by: Rdigest

I didn't want to write this and might delete later I don't know

If Mannat is ever shown to be confused even after finding out Vikrant was a victim as much as she was a victim, she shouldn't get the option to choose. Vikrant suffered for 7 years, while she has suffered she atleast had Dua, it's better she clarifies this with Vikrant so he gets to make a choice this time. Because, pre-leap whatever maybe the reason Mannat chose DK/RoTu over Vikrant, the choices she made brought them to this juncture, she cannot do the same to Vikrant again.

After Sinha’s wedding in Mumbai, Dua’s escapade and Vik’s attitude since arriving in Indore, I’m only feeling coldness and bitterness from Mannat towards Vikrant. Or perhaps she is repeating her assertion that DK is Dua’s baba and her support, to convince herself that she wants Vik to have no part in her heart and in her and Dua’s life ever.

RD sorry am being dense - what shouldn’t Mannat get the option to choose? Continue to hide Dua’s paternity from Vikrant? You’re saying Mannat should tell him so Vikrant can choose if and how he wants to assert his parental rights??

All makes sense but vamps aren’t going to let them have any decent conversation to clear up their MUs and agree the best way forward for their child’s sake and their own relationship, as sensible divorced couples usually do ☹️ So Vikrant will continue being in his aggressive, vengeful mode and Mannat will feel he’s not suitable and will only bring chaos in Dua’s life. In meantime vamps will reveal paternity and twist the situation so ManVik remain acrimonious.

I agree with Betty, She can choose not forgive Vik for the CA and give him another chance. But once Vikrant gets shared custody of Dua what’s there for Mannat to choose a platonic relationship with DK alone??

Originally posted by: Shazia_h

After Sinha’s wedding in Mumbai, Dua’s escapade and Vik’s attitude since arriving in Indore, I’m only feeling coldness and bitterness from Mannat towards Vikrant. Or perhaps she is repeating her assertion that DK is Dua’s baba and her support, to convince herself that she wants Vik to have no part in her heart and in her and Dua’s life ever.

RD sorry am being dense - what shouldn’t Mannat get the option to choose? Continue to hide Dua’s paternity from Vikrant? You’re saying Mannat should tell him so Vikrant can choose if and how he wants to assert his parental rights??

All makes sense but vamps aren’t going to let them have any decent conversation to clear up their MUs and agree the best way forward for their child’s sake and their own relationship, as sensible divorced couples usually do ☹️ So Vikrant will continue being in his aggressive, vengeful mode and Mannat will feel he’s not suitable and will only bring chaos in Dua’s life. In meantime vamps will reveal paternity and twist the situation so ManVik remain acrimonious.

I agree with Betty, once Vikrant gets shared custody of Dua what’s there for Mannat to choose a platonic relationship with DK alone??

Oh so you missed Daman's SS update post. This is not about paternity, this is after they clear all MU apparently per SS (this is the same dude who also said Malla will be revealed soon, her lie to Mannat about divorce papers and that Vikrant never rejected the baby), Mannat will be confused between Vikrant or Mr.Sacrifice and whom to choose 😵‍💫

So we are having hypothetical discussions since there is nothing in the episodes

Originally posted by: Rdigest

Oh so you missed Daman's SS update post. This is not about paternity, this is after they clear all MU apparently per SS (this is the same dude who also said Malla will be revealed soon, her lie to Mannat about divorce papers and that Vikrant never rejected the baby), Mannat will be confused between Vikrant or Mr.Sacrifice and whom to choose 😵‍💫

So we are having hypothetical discussions since there is nothing in the episodes

seems I did miss that.

Did SS guy say whether Vikrant was shot of Y? Not just Y but the others too? Without that, Mannat would be choosing pre-leap situation with Vikrant all over again?

But choosing DK means to continue a platonic setup with him, but share custody with Vik? Where on earth is this ManVik journey headed ?! I’m ignoring this SS guy till we get bts 😂

Originally posted by: Shazia_h

seems I did miss that.

Did SS guy say whether Vikrant was shot of Y? Not just Y but the others too? Without that, Mannat would be choosing pre-leap situation with Vikrant all over again?

But choosing DK means to continue a platonic setup with him, but share custody with Vik? Where on earth is this ManVik journey headed ?! I’m ignoring this SS guy till we get bts 😂

Good choice girl, sanity is important

If we lose our mind over SS update we would have celebrated by now with his previous update about Malla's truth coming out

Daman didn't mention anything about Y

Vikrant and Mannat knew EO for say 2 years in which Mannat has to save herself from ARS, save Shalini , Sunitha, Shruti from the various attempts on their life and reputation. Finally she grew guilty of not naving Sunitha and Shruti.

Vikrant enacted and got trapped in the paan masala wedding. the manipulation by ARS.

The big bad wedding when she was abandoned at the altar and had in a ONS resulting in her pregnancy.

SM only altered her life by taking her mother away and giving her motherhood. No understanding and trust for her words and actions. Shes mafe to always look for PROOFS .

When she was abandoned by the love of her life DCP and Ronnie have stood by her for 7 years They trust her unconditionally. They have given her hope and jointly raised DUA. Helped her face challenges by assuming to play the role of her Papa and Duas. So the comfort they have with each other is understandable. It is a middle class life she and DCP have been raised in. They have helped Ronnie adapt to the altered circumstances of being stripped of his wealth and comfort.

DCP has learnt the bitter truth of his mother. Being with Mannat and the Salujas has given him a purpose in life

In Ektaa YHM Dr Ishita would be seated on a white bench whenever upset and she would have conversations primarily with her Jeeju , with her Appa , Akka and Mummyji. I see this Chai pe charcha as the way rhe bond of friendship has been built here.

There have been challenges they have faced together and solved as best as they could so there is a certain ease in the interaction and they hope that they would remain so

Vikrant made vachans that he has never been able to uphold. He made the choice of living in wealth deserting the ones that loved him and thinks that YUvi is his purpose for living but its been a relationship of pampering and succumbing to his demand for things it is not a healthy relationship.

Dua has been anchoring the indore family by her love care and perceptions to protect her family

Not sure what value addition Vikrant can make in her upbringing.

Ohh dear the discussions over here talk about worst situations being offered. Well if there is a route of HDDCS ever I am out of it as well. I had always said I am a Manvik shipper and come what may I will always be a Manvik shipper. If at all they show cross marriages I am done for it. Wasn't Lost enough that I should see this again? I feel miserable to love a pair again this much. But will content myself ever with Adsha bonding. Baki ab kya hi kahoon

Originally posted by: Resham

Ohh dear the discussions over here talk about worst situations being offered. Well if there is a route of HDDCS ever I am out of it as well. I had always said I am a Manvik shipper and come what may I will always be a Manvik shipper. If at all they show cross marriages I am done for it. Wasn't Lost enough that I should see this again? I feel miserable to love a pair again this much. But will content myself ever with Adsha bonding. Baki ab kya hi kahoon

Resham we will all disappear see what I highlighted in my response to Shazia, hypothetical discussions based on rumors, since there is nothing discuss in the show