Mannat Har Khushi Paane Ki: Episode Discussion Thread - 38 - Page 68

Episode Discussions

Created

Last reply

Replies

910

Views

33k

Users

25

Likes

4.2k

Frequent Posters

ChaoticTangles thumbnail
Explorer Thumbnail
Posted: 2 days ago

Originally posted by: Kidult104

Here I am with my another, "I told you so" post. I so knew dk will fall for Mannat and it was expected. If you ask me? Idm. 7 years is a long time, Mannat is a lovely girl and they are living under one roof, raising a kid together, managing the entire house. People didnt hear DK's dialogue well where he said he clearly knows his limits, he knows what mannat wants and he sees respect in her eyes for him and he is content to be her friend. Idk whats gonna happen in the future but if Mannat feels comfortable enough with him and he himself has never crossed any line then i dont think they should be judged or shamed. Its natural and i do wanna see how they are gonna handle this angle.

Mannat nicely called out Neetu and I feel she actually let out alot of stuff which she clearly holding back for all these years. Now I have seen so much commotion saying Mannat said alot of nasty stuff about Vikrant. Okay, so if people dont mind male lead being bitter in itv, then why do people squirmed when female lead does? Mind you, Mannat has all possible valid reasons from her pov.


People do underestimate her traumatic past saying she neglects her mistakes, completely forget how many times she begged forgiveness, how many times she was a crying mess infront of Vikrant. That day she kept her self respect at the back seat, she was even ready to be in the hate marriage because she thought she will explain him everything. Tell me, the man who you loved so much makes your fears come true by leaving you at the altar, doesnt trust you again, physcially pushes you multiple times, makes you run through the lanes in yiur wedding attire for proofs, still CAs you multiple times, calls you names and meanest stuff, compares you with his molester ex, snatches everything from you, his parents and throws everyone out, denies your child as his, implies its his brother's and the lastly, divorces you for the secret marriage he himself initiated, while your mother's pyre is burning. Her mother died while she was returning from his home while convincing him for marriage. She was waiting for him till last moment during funeral. If all this doesnt make Mannat hardened then idk, she should be a robot then. Things dont end here, post leap, she got to see Vikrant's same behaviour, be it his rage, 0 trust on her and stupid gaslighting. He traumatized Dua by saying im gonna send your parents to jail, sent his men behind her, he acted like some crazed man during ice case, started bringing out his personal vendetta against Mannat and all this together made mannat so bitter against him. I keep saying, Mannat took the worst brunt of Vikrant's destruction.

Some are saying past episodes are boring but they are important to show why she feels DK has been a saviour in her life. I have said it already, when thrown out, Mannat was traumatized and pregnant, neetu was in shock and ronnie was bound with neetu. All were homeless and penniless. It was DK who stepped up. Did he have to? Nope. Still he did. He must be the only breadwinner of the family for some time. I'm not a mother but I can say that pregnancy, delivery and post delivery are some crucial times in woman's life. Where Mannat wanted Shruti and Vikrant to be there, Ronnie and Dk stepped up. They supported her. Even in later fbs one can see mannat was little overwhelmed infront of a doctor due to post partum while it was DK who was well aware of Dua. I do feel some more fbs are yet to come, esp dehradun indore connection, but for past few days makers are establishing why and how dcp became such an integral part of Mannat's life. Dua is Mannat's jeene ki wajah and she was able to sustain her due to ronnie and DK, otherwise Mannat wouldnt have survived. If even after this people think Mannat is stupid for her jaap and her bitterness, then idk.

Basically, for Mannat, Vikrant loved her but didnt value her much, she was replacable for him. Now she has rebuilt herself after much time and she doesnt wanna go through the destruction which Vikrant always brings. Just like how Vikrant speaks shitty things due to his usual impulsive rage and trauma, same Mannat says bitter stuff due to her stained past and her trauma of rejection.

Bold: I think he owes the support to mannat and fam..because it was partly because of him that things turned out that way ,had he arrested vishaka on right time, then she wouldn't have been able to create that destruction.. But from his pov it's his mother, so it's not easy for him to punish his mother and felt that she needs second chance and gave her that... But that led to troubles in mannat's life, so he hold obligation to support them, but yes I do accept he could escape that responsibility, but didn't escape and stepped up to fulfill his obligation... smiley27

Edited by ChaoticTangles - 2 days ago
Shazia_h thumbnail
Visit Streak 180 Thumbnail Visit Streak 90 Thumbnail + 3

Team Vikrant

Posted: 2 days ago

Originally posted by: Rdigest

Betty, pre-leap also he was shown only attached to Mannat, he never went to Vikrant to even get a glimpse of him, or just casual conversation considering he was sacrificing his life and leaving Vikrant forever. Some of us questioned this at that time aswell, as to why he is not attached to his brother whom he has been searching for years, but always in Mannat's room , infact if you recall even wedding gift he gave it to Mannat only and Vikrant's walks in.

Now, I am even bitter about all his post leap scenes where he is doing everything under the garb of friendship. Now it makes sense when he said he will never let Dua meet Vikrant aswell.

The writers intentionally create these scenes… which at the time seem innocuous and actually a very beautiful relationship. They did the same with Malla when she was initially Mannat’s bestie and went against her mum to help Mannat, then out of the blue flipped her character. Then we begin to question past scenes, dialogues and come up with theories on her true motives and character all along 🤣

Same with DK, those bedroom scenes were obviously to create doubt in Vik’s mind to back the first round of MU created by Vish and her photograph. At the time those M/DK interactions may have been completely innocent from DK’s pov but with what’s just been revealed about DK having feelings for Mannat, we will now doubt any and all his part and future actions and intentions. That’s writers laying their foundations well!

Please excuse me for having been quiet for a few days on here and jumping in on your comment….. been very tied up but followed of the very lively and interesting debates going on 🤣 and thank you for holding onto Vik’s corner so well🥹 ❤️

Rdigest thumbnail
Hogwarts Championship 2025 Thumbnail Fashion Feud Participant Thumbnail + 9
Posted: 2 days ago

Originally posted by: Shazia_h

The writers intentionally create these scenes… which at the time seem innocuous and actually a very beautiful relationship. They did the same with Malla when she was initially Mannat’s bestie and went against her mum to help Mannat, then out of the blue flipped her character. Then we begin to question past scenes, dialogues and come up with theories on her true motives and character all along 🤣

Same with DK, those bedroom scenes were obviously to create doubt in Vik’s mind to back the first round of MU created by Vish and her photograph. At the time those M/DK interactions may have been completely innocent from DK’s pov but with what’s just been revealed about DK having feelings for Mannat, we will now doubt any and all his part and future actions and intentions. That’s writers laying their foundations well!

Please excuse me for having been quiet for a few days on here and jumping in on your comment….. been very tied up but followed of the very lively and interesting debates going on 🤣 and thank you for holding onto Vik’s corner so well🥹 ❤️

Exactly and here there is reasonable doubt isn't it?. Do you remember we wondered why he wasn't attached to his brother at all for whom he was scarficing his life for ? Wouldn't a person who claims to have searched for his dear brother for 25+ years wants to spend some time with him before leaving forever and make some memories ?

Also, I can't go back and watch wedding episodes but if my memory serves correct, Vikrant didn't even get any flashbacks of DK in Mannat's room or the hug in Mannat's room when Vish accused Mannat of affair or when she showed him the picture. He just held his head and started prancing around.

Shazia_h thumbnail
Visit Streak 180 Thumbnail Visit Streak 90 Thumbnail + 3

Team Vikrant

Posted: 2 days ago

Originally posted by: Rdigest

Exactly and here there is reasonable doubt isn't it?. Do you remember we wondered why he wasn't attached to his brother at all for whom he was scarficing his life for ? Wouldn't a person who claims to have searched for his dear brother for 25+ years wants to spend some time with him before leaving forever and make some memories ?

Also, I can't go back and watch wedding episodes but if my memory serves correct, Vikrant didn't even get any flashbacks of DK in Mannat's room or the hug in Mannat's room when Vish accused Mannat of affair or when she showed him the picture. He just held his head and started prancing around.

I do recall the kitchen scene when Vik walked in on Mannat/ DK, and asked what was going on…..Vik laughingly did apologise to them for having thoughts of misunderstanding them and of the previous day when DK took Mannat to dadi’s care home after refusin Vik’s offer. Vik seemed to genuinely put aside any MU concerns, but red flag didn’t occur to DK nor Mannat and DK continued.
In the wedding episodes I don’t think Vik had fbs of the various moments he chanced on DK/M alone. Which is strange….is it laziness from creative team not to select those scenes in Vik’s FBs or Vik deep down not believing Mannat was having an affair.

DK’s connection & attachment to Vik was shown early with those emphatic hugs on but yes his focus changed to concern for Mannat soon after Vish’s truth track began, which is certainly questionable pre-leap.

As Betty said I felt his tears in today’s scene also odd before Mannat brings him coffee😵‍💫. But all in all enough of DK’s detailed emotions, writers seemed to have forgotten who the ml actually is.

Edited by Shazia_h - a day ago
Kidult104 thumbnail
Visit Streak 750 Thumbnail Visit Streak 500 Thumbnail + 5
Posted: a day ago

Originally posted by: Rdigest

Great analysis

Can I ask why do we expect that Vikrant should have forgiven Mannat when she cried and begged? Because from what I understood lying and deceiving Vikrant was a choice Mannat made knowingly that she has to keep doing this for the rest of her life isn't it ? Doesnt Vikrant have the choice to forgive Mannat or not in that moment that too instantly on the same day so much happened?

I will give a parallel scinearo, For the CA Vikrant did , Mannat has a choice to forgive Vikrant or not, isn't it? If Vikrant cries and begs are we expecting Mannat has to forgive him immediately?

When I wrote about Mannat crying and begging for forgiveness, I wrote it in the context of some people saying Mannat acts as if she didnt do any mistakes or did she even apologise properly. I wrote it completely from Mannat's pov as she knowingly did the mistake, now thats another thing that she should have also known that things would escalate to this extent so she should have prepared herself better to take worst falls from Vikrant.

It was completely Vikrant's choice to not forgive them and Mannat, fair enough, it was also his choice to keep the grudge about it so yeah, even Mannat can also keep the grudge about the whole CA thing. After all its a matter of trust.

Rdigest thumbnail
Hogwarts Championship 2025 Thumbnail Fashion Feud Participant Thumbnail + 9
Posted: a day ago

Originally posted by: Kidult104

When I wrote about Mannat crying and begging for forgiveness, I wrote it in the context of some people saying Mannat acts as if she didnt do any mistakes or did she even apologise properly. I wrote it completely from Mannat's pov as she knowingly did the mistake, now thats another thing that she should have also known that things would escalate to this extent so she should have prepared herself better to take worst falls from Vikrant.

It was completely Vikrant's choice to not forgive them and Mannat, fair enough, it was also his choice to keep the grudge about it so yeah, even Mannat can also keep the grudge about the whole CA thing. After all its a matter of trust.

I love your clarity on the characters, their actions and the perspective you presentsmiley31

Moor278 thumbnail
Visit Streak 750 Thumbnail Visit Streak 500 Thumbnail + 9
Posted: a day ago

You are looking at it superficially if you think DK had designs on Mannat pre leap...

DK himself praised to Vish the day she arrived in SM that Mannat is perfect life partner for Vik and loves him so much... in later episodes after the relationship was out he called himself her jeth ..

KC aftermath is where Vish clocked in that she can use DK against Vik by fueling MU for Mannat...


Mannat DK shared a warm relationship when she found out he was Viks brother.. they were secretive and fun around each other (blissfully unaware) and to Viks credit he had observed but did not worry...

Vik did not know DK is his brother and subconsciously perceived him as threat.... the boys didnt get time to process that DK is his brother and couldn't have had an affair with his fiancee...


Post leap the DM relationship has developed into a friendship after years of living together...

Had DK had wrong intentions there would have been a real marriage like the other show on SP and not fake one... RoTu would have supported too... like Betty pointed out Neetu was also happy with the status quo till Dua met Vik and Neetu got babajis blessings smiley39


Cool.... correct me for pre leap episodes

Vidhi1989 thumbnail
Explorer Thumbnail
Posted: a day ago

I don't find anything wrong with Dhairya loving Mannat.

Rdigest thumbnail
Hogwarts Championship 2025 Thumbnail Fashion Feud Participant Thumbnail + 9
Posted: a day ago

Moor I put "reasonable doubt" in my post smiley36 when I highlighted what I found odd in his visits pre-leap visits to Mannat but no inclination to spend time with Vikrant considering he was sacrificing and leaving his dear brother whom he was searching for years. Wouldn't someone who was dying to get his brother have even an ounce of such inclination?

Edited by Rdigest - a day ago
Padmajaan thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Voice of India 2024 Participant Thumbnail + 5
Posted: a day ago

I honestly don't understand why Mannat and especially DK are put under so much scrutiny whereas Vikrant who clearly has a girlfriend Yashika who he allows to touch him as she wishes, call him baby, goes on vacations and dates with and allows her to sleep in his bed even and vikrant who actually married Malla due to whatever reason even though he was at that time in love apparently with Mannat, gets away scot free for all his deeds. I just don't get it.

Suddenly after all these years he is shown as feeling angsty, missing his mother, missing Mannat even though feeling vindictive, etc., but he still spends all his time with Yashika.

He apparently hasn't tried getting in touch with them for so many years and still seems to hang on to the impression given by Vishakha who he hasn't figured out about till now, about how superficial, unloving and vile she is, forget about all the others surrounding him..

Sorry haven't seen yesterday's episode but only reacting to what I have seen written here but why such double standards???

Just the mere mention of DK liking Mannat seems to have upset everyone as if that were the most unnatural thing that could happen but Vikrant and Yashika are fine??

And Vikrant hasn't changed one bit. Even now he actually believes Mannat could use contaminated water and put small kids' lives in danger unless she furnishes proof. I am sorry but he has had zero character growth in all these years, has gone through 0 introspection. Not saying Mannat was right, she should not have listened to Neetu and should have insisted Rotu tell him the truth because it was their truth to tell not hers. That in any case he wouldn't have believed her even had she announced it is another point because she had no proof right? And like Moor always says, there was an intention behind her silence. She and DK especially were just protecting him. I won't speak of Rotu's intentions because Neetu ='s whitewashing didn;t sit well with me either and Ronnie was her puppet.

And why should Mannat or Vikrant not move on tell me!! Why not????

If they haven't it's only because they both are bitter and Mannat even more embittered than him because she went through one shock after another and has mothered a child! And why should DK not develop feelings for her during so many years of companionship? It's the most natural thing to happen if you ask me. Had this relationship happened, it would have been based on mutual respect, friendship and companionship and not on blind love and passion but why not??

On one side you have DK who fully understands her and on the other you have Vikrant who very clearly has no idea who Mannat truly is!!! Grrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrr

Sorry for the rambling post!

Related Topics

Mannat Har Khushi Paane Ki thumbnail

Posted by: nutmeg7 · 22 days ago

WRITTEN UPDATES AND DAILY DISCUSSION THREAD NO 37 Welcome to Mannat - Har Khushi Paane Ki EDT

Expand ▼
Mannat Har Khushi Paane Ki thumbnail

Posted by: Shemer · 6 months ago

Welcome to BTS Thread of MHKPK...

Expand ▼
Mannat Har Khushi Paane Ki thumbnail

Posted by: purplegirl7 · 1 years ago

Welcome to Chat Corner for Mannat forum We can do gupshup here

Expand ▼
Mannat Har Khushi Paane Ki thumbnail

Posted by: nutmeg7 · 1 years ago

Permission given by Leprechaun

Expand ▼
Mannat Har Khushi Paane Ki thumbnail

Posted by: nutmeg7 · 1 months ago

WRITTEN UPDATES AND DAILY DISCUSSION THREAD NO 36 Welcome to Mannat - Har Khushi Paane Ki EDT

Expand ▼
Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".