Mannat Har Khushi Paane Ki: Episode Discussion Thread - 37 - Page 46

Both manvik are flaw . Both have their own strength and weakness.

I don't want to say who is wrong and right. Both are wrong and both are right.

For any relationship trust is important. A relationship with out trust will not last . In same way a relationship starts on bases of lie will not last.

Before leap manvik relationship didn't have trust and mannat want to start relation by hiding truth it's one way of lie.

After 7 years of separation if manvik still want to be relation it should not be because of dua .they should trust each other and never lie.

Hope they both learn lesson in hard way.

Originally posted by: Rdigest

Bold, I don't know if Mannat knows Vikrant as much as she believes she does just like how Vikrant doesnt know Mannat at all.

Mannat didn't realize how detremental hiding such a life changing truth about Vikrant's birth would be🫣, she didn't realize he would be hoping mad at her for supporting Neetu drugging him and RoTu kidnapping him (per his memories RoTu kidnapped him from Vish the mother Teresa).

At the end of the day, neither of them understand eachother else they wouldn't have been separated 😔.

Bold: I used to feel embarassed for Mannat when she would make bold declarations on behalf of Vikrant. First to Neetu when she said she would leave SM with Vikrant and he turned around and supported Neetu. She made a similar declaration against Vishakha

In turn vamps have always had the last laugh in her face.

Mannat decides something in her mind and runs with it. In being protective she never considers if that's the best course of action for whomever she is protecting. Leaving Mumbai was the best decision for her but wasn't for RoTu. Setting aside that RoTu are to blame to a large extent they have made a silent sacrifice by leaving with Mannat. Neetu's health has been deteriorating and there is no way to know if they could have managed to get through to Vikrant once his anger had cooled down. Mannat hasn't seen the silent sacrifice RoTu have been making as well. She just sees how she has taken care of them after Vikrant threw them out.

Dua has both Vikrant and Mannat's genes and I'm sure she will unleash them at right time. If makers don't flip her as she is an itv kid, she will drag all 3 parties, mannat, vikrant and dk nicely.

Dua is definitely gonna bash Mannat and Dk the most, because as for her they are her parents and both of them have rights on eachother. Vikrant's genes will overpower here definitely but I feel, her mannat side will takeover it. When Mannat got to know Shruti's truth, she took time to accept it but she understood why she did what she did and unlike Vikrant, Dua might choose to stick with her mother and foster father. This will be a lesson for Vikrant and a chance of redemption for him. I agree his situation was more toxic but one cant deny that he snatched everything from his parents and threw them out by trusting his evil bio mom. He will get the same treatment from his own child, proving Ronnie's words true and this will give him a chance to win his kid's heart, because Dua will def demand to know the whole backstory about her family.

Do people realise how gullible they are???

Mukta is damn right when she says Vamps and negativity brings the drama...

Currently the vamp of the show disguised as a good man is DK... everyone everywhere rants about him... expects him to take higher ground and absolving Vik of any responsibility or making amends. This is very similar to how Malla was treated... only that people wanted her punished for her crimes.

DK is not for Mannat... he is there for Dua... for Vik to realise where he messed up. Its yet another parallel to the theme of the show ... nature vs nurture.

DK is not supposed to have any growth in his character. He is a sidey. Neither do we need any more scenes on what he thinks 🤔

But Vik needs to.... just because DK Mannat are proxy parents to Dua doesnt mean YV equation is justified.

For that matter YV hone ka jyada chance hai... Y is hell bent on marrying V and V is anyway a volatile person who takes wrong decisions. DK doesnt have romantic intentions for Mannat but the less said the better about what Vik allows Y to do for him.

Give it time and Y would be in focus and the problems would increase for Manvik.

What happenened to people wanting Viks redemption and regret????

Just because Vik shed some tears and is shown pining for Mannat doesnt mean he can be absolved of everything he did pre leap. Neither does Mannat claiming DK as Duas father mean anything.

He hasnt yet realised where he messed up... and he wont till he starts opening his eyes... this is a man who is pally with Malla... who was also equally responsible for the seperation.

Mannat is lying to Dua but she too has been misled. The moment she and RoTu realise Vik was not aware, they will disown DK... phir kya karenge sab????

Why do people forget that for Mannat Vik is not returning and Vik believes Mannat disowned him. This status quo will remain till truths start tumbling out. Audience knows both sides not the characters. They are not supposed to behave the way we want simply because for them a different reality exists.

Ye roj roj rant karke panic kyun hote rehte hai sab????

Well it took you time but you came out of the shadows.

We all knew if we panic and rant on repeat you would come out 🤣🤣🤣🤣

Good to have you back.

I don't like to get into ML vs FL as a rule because if I like a ship, I love both characters.

But I am seeing such a meltdown in X as well. I am truly puzzled. This is a rant post in general. Alll the characters are equally at fault at different points. Why are we not able to see ?

We have seen DK with Mannat, Mannat giving him all rights as Dua's father. She knows Vikrant's anger therefore has blindly believed whatever Dua said. i am still hoping Dua will tell her how he saved her.

That apart, did she ever imagine Vik will not marry her; when she hid the truth? No. Did she imagine Vik would throw his parents without a backward glance at them to see how they are managing? No. Like it or not, Mannat has seen the worst side of Vikrant.

Plus, she has seen him with Yaashika & Yuvi. Y hugged Vik. We as the audience know he was uncomfortable, did she know. Why should she presume he has not moved on??

Yashika was there in Vik's first ever interaction with his daughter. She is there in every significant moment of his life; she controls the domestic situation in his house, sleeps in his room. What more do we want to know her place in his life? Can he replace Mannat with her, not at all, but she has made space in his life!! Why are we ignoring her?? And she is Vikrant's choice.

Coming to DK, he has been with Mannat during her worst time. He supported her & helped her get back on her feet. He has been with Mannat through Ritu's ill heath, everything. But DK was never her choice of support. There was no other option at that point in life. To be fair, till now they have a platonic relationship between them. Did she keep Rotu away from Vik? Vik left them with no choice but to depend on DK.

Of course, now her Baba jaap is getting annoying. Their chai pe charcha is getting annoying from a viewing perspective. Point noted, & locked in. Mannat atp, trusts DK over Vikrant.

What I am irritated is not that Dua has not yet told them Vik saved her. But both DK and Mannat have not pulled her up for using Bunty's phone, lying to all of them, and running away! DK knew everything but was not alert. And Mannat is not seeing that he is too casual about these things.

At this point, both Manvik are poised to move to a different phase. Yashika is using Yuvi to get Vik to marry her. He is in a relationship with Yashika where marriage is the next step, let's accept it.

Please tell me even if Vik sees DK, Mannat, he will not say yes to Yaashika's proposal. Someone give me that guarantee! If you say he deserves to move on, then good for him.

He will then face a dilemma when he knows about Dua. Am sure we will continue to blame Mannat, saying Vik deserves to be with Dua. No, he needs to wake up. He has noticed one significant aspect - ARS. This should lead him to be suspicious.

If we are going to blame the writing for Vikrant, let's blame the writing for Mannat too!!

Phew! Rant over.

I think everything that Mannat said when she had a meltdown looked like it was taken directly from our forum!

About how insensitive it was of Vikrant to scare a poor 7 year old by saying repeatedly that he would make sure they land in jail, etc. And also question who was he to judge their parenting, etc. etc.

She was absolutely right seeing how pathetic Yuvi has turned out to be and Vikrant most definitely cannot claim to be great at parenting!!

Have we all forgotten the near perfect execution of the plan to separate Mannat and Vikrant?? And a lot of it was based on Vikrant's anger issues; when he gets angry, he loses his capacity to think straight.

Why don't we observe that Vikrant is surrounded by the same people, who have lied, manipulated, CAed Mannat, and most of all, killed Shruti in a gruesome manner, that noone deserves!!

And they are thriving!

I agree with you moor and Scarlett.

Vikrant after seeing DK and mannat he will say yes to yashika.He is in relationships with her.

When Dua truth will be out then only he may think. Until then it's will be circle only.

Originally posted by: WittyKittyVixxy

Chappal matt phenkna, but you are totally absolving Vikrant of any and everything.

ARS Did this all more for Nalla to get the money, etc. Hatred and oneupmanship over Mannat is just secondary. Killing her sister wasn’t needed. ARS & cobras are the ones who need punishment and Vikrant as well for his complete lack of trust in the very people he supposedly loved the most in the world.

Ok I am now going to hide before other ML fans also throw chappals on me….

Witty

I really wonder do you even read my posts properly or you just say anything because I am ML fan?

I can say the same about you that you are being FL’s blind fan don’t even acknowledge her share of mistakes. At least we ,can’t say about others but at least me and I can say that proudly as his supporters acknowledge his flaws and wants him to repent for his mistakes though he did those some unintentionally, in his anger and wants to see his redemption.

But you never say anything about Mannat or for you she can never do anything wrong ? In fact she is also responsible for this mess.

She should’ve never supported RoTu and DK and told truth to Vikrant. When she had the first hand experience of betrayal from her own mother . Please don’t give me this crap that she wanted to save him from pain. She dealt with that pain and being an adult he should’ve done that. Being a partner she should’ve been there for him to support him in his difficult times.

Tell me honestly is Mannat really that transparent with him?

Till now she always hide the important stuff from him. She told Gagan that ARS is her mom but not to Vikrant. She never told ARS’s Kaands to him. Again don’t bring that saboot card.

Why every time she assumed that he will ask for proof? Despite having proofs against ARS also she never told him the truth.

Trust always goes both ways. It’s not one way where only one person have to show it and other don’t.

In fact ManVik lacks this basic thing in their relationship and that is transparency. It’s not even about trust but it’s about hiding and lying about things.

You only see Mannat’s suffering but why can’t you see Vikrant’s suffering?

At least I have the guts to accept his share of mistakes and wants to see him grovel for it despite him not entirely responsible for it. But i have never seen you doing it.

You just love to comment against whoever comes in support of Vikrant. Like I said everyone did mistakes and suffering for it and the choices they made at that time. I want to see everyone acknowledging their mistakes and mend their ways be it Vikrant or Mannat even RoTu and DK also.

Not just Vikrant but all these people also need to rectify their mistakes regarding Vikrant. Only Vikrant is not at fault they all are.

And I am not at all absolving Vikrant for his mistakes but I will definitely absolve him regarding Dua because he definitely deserves her love and respect as a father and she also deserves it equally. He should pay for his mistakes but at the same time I do want whoever responsible for this mess they should also pay for it and that includes Mannat , RoTu and DK also and even all the vamps🤬

And one more thing though ARS did everything for Malla but you just can’t discard her hatred towards Mannat . Even before knowing truth about Mannat she did try to kill Shruti only because of her hatred towards her kid whom Shruti saved. So yes ARS did everything just to get rid of Mannat and to give her pain and tried to destroy whoever supported her🤬

And one more thing why you only want to clobber Vikrant? Include DK and Mannat also in it. Don’t worry I will get chappals thrown at me and I will join you. In fact Mannat also deserves but I will let her go. More than her it’s DK who deserves it for not doing his duty properly regarding ARS and his good for nothing mom Vish🤬

❤️🤗