Crazy Theory-Neither Edward NOR Jacob!!

u know what guys..i have been thinking...

all us twilighters are just debating over whether bella shud end up with Jacob or Edward...its either of them this we all are sure of..

I have a crazy theory (and i believe this would be the Morally Right ending as well) that she wud end up with neither of them...now before i continue..let me declare ...that i am a CRAZY EDWARD FAN....Edward rules my heart!! and i want bella edward together for eternity...jake or no jake... ( jake fans plz dont be offended & do continue reading since jake is a kewl guys i do like him😊)

now...as for mytheory...lemme first give u guys sum proofs as to what makes me think that she wud endup with neither of them...and in essence i mean both the guys hav a chance of dieing at the end...all u twilighters i know this will be a big depressing idea for u guys but v GOTTA prepare ourselves if meyer's thinkignsumthign liek this...now here is the proof for my theory that both Ed and jake mite die:

Edward in twiligth (while carryign bella to the baseball game) angrily said how : "I swear u will be the death of me"...this makes me REALLY suspicious of meyer... eddward has gotten himself into lots of trouble over bella before..so her being a possible cause of his death..i think this is quiet a reasonable possibility. Jacob has not YET imprinted on bella however meyer did not answer when sum1 asked if a werewolf can imprint on a vampire..this can be a possible hint to us the readers that there might be sumthign liek this happeneing infuture..and lets face it..it wud be a GREAT twist to the story...so after bella changed into a vampire..ofcoruse she wud be sum1 totally new..and jacob mite IMPRINT on her then.. Edward once told bella in twilight..when she asked if sum1 (im not sure of whom maybe it was james she said or just any1) but she asked edward whether its only to him that she appeals this way (fav brand of heroine😛) or did she appeal to any1 else also? to this edward replied that if she had appealed to ANY1 else liek she had appeals to him..then there wud be a fight right there & then until sum1 dies...
1. bella is the link that connects jacob and edward..how ever bella is ALSO the only obstacle in their way that keeps them from havign a go at one another..they both can do ANYTHIGN for bella..so any slight misunderstanding and they'll not even take a second before pounding each other..and once werewolf and vampire get into a fight..as strong as edward and jacob..v haf all the reason to believe ONE OF THEM WUD DIE..in this case both can die in a fight..

thus..what my points summarize is..maybe...when bella turns into a vampire jacob wud imprint on her and this wud basically mean a fight b/w edward & jacob right there and then...in which both r so strong that both hav the possibility of dieing..

OR

it cud be that jacob meant wht he said "i wud rather u were dead than turn into a vampire"... maybe he wud RATHER her dead..which is y he mite want to kill her..😕cuz he mite knwo that after she chanegd she mite kill many others and they wud hav to kill her eventually..😕 thsi is nature v r talkign abt he is a werewolf he BELIEVES VAMPIRES R BAD...there is no way he cud every think they r not bad cuz its his nature...

now just a bit more on y morally it wud be right that she ends up with neithe rof them:

y not edward??

he's a vampire..a dead person...no matter how controlable its their nature to kill luv is an important part o flife..BUT..it is not the whole LIFE...u cant giv up ur whole life to be with sum1 u luv..thats like rejecting the most imp gift..i mean...i want edward bella togteher..u all want EB together..but think abt it from a right and wrong POV..is it really RIGHT to give up ur whole life..betray ur parennts infact betray the whole human race by becumign sumthing for whom humans are the prey...just to be with sum1 u luv???😕 with a stone on my heart i hav to say that i cant completely disagree with this point... if she doesnt change into a vampire..then wht she keeps aging and he be there by her side same age as he is now? a 17 year old guy with a 20, later 30, later 50 year old woman? can she live liek that heer whole life? nope
• he be there with her..her whoellife..while she also marries and stuff..naah..that wud be a torture not just to the two of them but a betrayal to whomever she choses as well..

Y NOT JACOB?

if edward does not age...neither does jacob...if edward is not human...well neither is jacob completely human... edward is dangerous..isnt jake dangerous? did sam did wht he did to emily INTENTIONALLY? no...it just ahppend..it can happen with bella too if she chooses jake.. wht when he imprints on sum1..liek he said..there is NO CHOICE once u imprint on sum1..he wud HAV to leave her..she wud hav the same fate as leah..no matter how much jacob luvs her..
• if she wudnt be leading a normal life with edward ...well neither wud she be living a normal life with jake..

now...wht my main point by this whole LONG post...is just that...IF NOT EDWARD...then bella shudnt be with jacob either...😡and if meyer ends her up with jake..that wud so not be right....

now lastly..let me tell u all..that i had to keep a stone on my heart to say all that i just did...cuz trust me..im a crazy edward bella fan..edward rules my heart😳i CANT c him in pain...i WANT to c him happy..i WANT 2 c bella with him as a vampire so that he doesnt hav to be SO careful around her..& after all that i WANT sum1 to prove to him that he wont be taking away bella's soul..cuz if nobody tells him that then he will spend all eternity cursing himself for changing bella..😭i want to c edward happy...& alive!! (well in the vampire terminology that is😆)...

now many ppl said how it wud be so cool if sumhow edward mite turn into a human..nothing wud be better ending than this i know...but the selfish part of me.. (the edward obsessed part of me😆) doesnt really want to c him as anythign other than wht he is now..he is SUCH A HOT ROCKING vampire i dunno if he wud hav the same charm as now..the same DAZZLING SMILE..which makes me dizzy everytime i think abt it😳 so GO TEAM EDWARD!!

however..this post..well i dunno if any1 really did manage to go through my WHOEL LOGN post to reach this point..but if u did..then wht i wanna say after presenting my crazy theory is..

rest assured..if not edward than it wont be jake either😉 - sorry jake fans but i cant say the same thing for u guys😳 if not jake..then still edward has a chance😳
1. just be prepared for the worst...just like how v prepared ourselves for hp..😊

im gonna take leave now u twilighters keep rocking..👏

That is actually a possibility of her ending up with neither of them.. it happened in the OC with Julie not picking Bullet or Frank [Ryan's dad]. And I'm sure it has happened in billion other shows, movies, books, etc.

I hope neither Edward or Jacob die.. I love Jacob more than Edward.. but I'm neutral or SWITZERLAND with who ends up with Bella.

It's a possibility that someone will die..but who? I think it might be one of the Cullens [not Edward though..]. Wait, if Edward gets killed of in Breaking dawn, then that will probably pump the sales and hype for Midnight Sun.. cause fans will want it son they can 'remember' Edward and learn more about him.

-Navi.

Originally posted by: suuunshiine

That is actually a possibility of her ending up with neither of them.. it happened in the OC with Julie not picking Bullet or Frank [Ryan's dad]. And I'm sure it has happened in billion other shows, movies, books, etc.

I hope neither Edward or Jacob die.. I love Jacob more than Edward.. but I'm neutral or SWITZERLAND with who ends up with Bella.

It's a possibility that someone will die..but who? I think it might be one of the Cullens [not Edward though..]. Wait, if Edward gets killed of in Breaking dawn, then that will probably pump the sales and hype for Midnight Sun.. cause fans will want it son they can 'remember' Edward and learn more about him.

-Navi.

but..edward...dying😭

i luv all the cullens..nun of them shud be killed off...they're all couples..and complete each other..alice is my fav character after edward.. (bella cums after alice)..if anythign happens to her v wud be heart broken..so wud jasper..emmet and rosalie fit together...esme carlisle..carlisle nuthign shud happen to him otherwise who wud be the good vampire to lead other vampires onthe right path?? emmet jasper they'r all kewl guys i luv them both😭if any of the cullens die the cullen family wud lose its charm😭edward is the only one w/o a partner...thus most at risk of getting killed off..but then..his fan following is so huge it wud be a big risk to meyer if she kills him😭😭

btw yea i luv jake too he's immature cute luv it whenhe teases edward😆but i cant watch him with bella still cuz i cant imagien edward suffering😭

i will stab someone if she does not end up with edward

Originally posted by: ~*manai*~

i will stab someone if she does not end up with edward

stab jake😆everything was going smoothly before he entered😆no but then jake fans wud be after u😆

Anyone touches Jake, they'll have me to answer to!!!

And hellooooo!!! It's great to see a HP reader give views on Twilight. I love the way you've put the stuff down there in such a clear debate... Though you clearly like the Bella-Edward pair, you seem to have listed out some excellent points for Jacob too, in the process!

Yes, i agree, the chances that Jacob gets bella are pretty small. However, we can't, as you said, take for granted that this means Edward gets Bella! There are still a lot of things that need to be sorted out, and lot of things that we'll find out in the 4th book!

Excellent stuff you've written there! Hope to see more of your theories! It's when you go creative and think beyond what every other member thinks (Edward loves Bella, bella loves Edward... Oooooooh! , or Jake n Bella, yayyy!)that you actually get into the discussions really...

Keep it up!
-Sam

Originally posted by: Naughty_n_nice

Anyone touches Jake, they'll have me to answer to!!!

And hellooooo!!! It's great to see a HP reader give views on Twilight. I love the way you've put the stuff down there in such a clear debate... Though you clearly like the Bella-Edward pair, you seem to have listed out some excellent points for Jacob too, in the process!

Yes, i agree, the chances that Jacob gets bella are pretty small. However, we can't, as you said, take for granted that this means Edward gets Bella! There are still a lot of things that need to be sorted out, and lot of things that we'll find out in the 4th book!

Excellent stuff you've written there! Hope to see more of your theories! It's when you go creative and think beyond what every other member thinks (Edward loves Bella, bella loves Edward... Oooooooh! , or Jake n Bella, yayyy!)that you actually get into the discussions really...

Keep it up!
-Sam

c..i knew even raising a finger on jake wud earn us 100 more threats😆 u know wht - now that I think of it..team jacob sure isnt that small😕 ofcourse the majority is team edward still (my luv😳)...but still so many ppl like jake it scares me😆

now for the main point: here's another theory u guys might be interested in..actually the credit for this one goes to my friend...but when she told me this one i actually forgot my own theory..hers is so reasonable..

well since my theory wud be TOO tragic..and meyer is a fan of happy endings..this is wht my friend came up with:

since most of bella's dreams are real and cum tru..maybe the dream she had on her 18th bday (her as an old lady with edward in front of the miror) will cum tru...its the only peaceful way to end the story..and she says it wud show tru luv..i feel so too but i still cant get myself to accept this theory..however bella's dreams DO cum tru...and for meyer even this mite be a happy ending...others dont make quiet sense i mean if bella is changed then werewolfs wud attack vampires...chaos!

but i dont wanna see bella grow old and edward still same that wud not be too happy i want them together but not as an old woman and young guy😆& wud she stay liek this whole time or wud she marry jake? (be happy jake fans😆)...but liek i said in my theory..this wud not be right for jake well actually i doubt that...from wht i know of him he wud be too happy to hav bella even if edward sticks there for her whole their lives😆😆😆

Originally posted by: twinklystar_hp

stab jake😆everything was going smoothly before he entered😆no but then jake fans wud be after u😆

lolz i will stab the person nearest to me!😆

that would suck big time if she wont end up with Edward...but heyy atleast she wont be with Jacob either!!!

Aw. Well, interesting post, but I do think it's going to be Jake or Edward..