Mannat Har Khushi Paane Ki: Episode Discussion Thread - 34 - Page 20

It seems they are drawing parallels with mannat and vikrant post birth truth revealations. When vimal happened, one of the reason for it was mannat choosing Shruti over everyone which is fair enough. After reveal, mannat was truly looking like sonia khanna, ruthless and shrewd, to the point shruti got scared of her.

Similarly vikrant now with his past memories thinks vishakha was wronged by criminals rotu and now he has transformed into aman kumar, vishakha's son. He chose his biological mother over everyone. They are drawing same parallels but at the end it comes to the point that mannat fought against actual bad people and vikrant is siding with actual bad people and fighting against the people who he thinks are bad. This makes me think he is gonna suffer way worse than what mannat suffered. Mannat saw vimal infront of her for sometime, Vikrant will see his family esp Mannat replacing him with dk for a really long time.

Also Mannat with dk has become his massive trigger. Adnan is doing a good job to portray that blind rage of aman. You feel like for a minute it is dawning upon him and then he sees Dk near mannat and all hell breaks loose. Slowly, hiding truth doesnt seem to be an issue for him but mannat choosing dk over him seems to be. He isnt realising that he himself is pushing her towards him and its his way of seeing them makes everything bad.

Originally posted by: Kidult104

It seems they are drawing parallels with mannat and vikrant post birth truth revealations. When vimal happened, one of the reason for it was mannat choosing Shruti over everyone which is fair enough. After reveal, mannat was truly looking like sonia khanna, ruthless and shrewd, to the point shruti got scared of her.

Similarly vikrant now with his past memories thinks vishakha was wronged by criminals rotu and now he has transformed into aman kumar, vishakha's son. He chose his biological mother over everyone. They are drawing same parallels but at the end it comes to the point that mannat fought against actual bad people and vikrant is siding with actual bad people and fighting against the people who he thinks are bad. This makes me think he is gonna suffer way worse than what mannat suffered. Mannat saw vimal infront of her for sometime, Vikrant will see his family esp Mannat replacing him with dk for a really long time.

Also Mannat with dk has become his massive trigger. Adnan is doing a good job to portray that blind rage of aman. You feel like for a minute it is dawning upon him and then he sees Dk near mannat and all hell breaks loose. Slowly, hiding truth doesnt seem to be an issue for him but mannat choosing dk over him seems to be. He isnt realising that he himself is pushing her towards him and its his way of seeing them makes everything bad.

I wonder how their absence is going to affect him. I understand the post leap after he sees all of them as a family unit it will be hard but i just wonder if in all he is doing in his anger he envisioned the impact of his decisions. He took the property to protect Vishakha but still went to check on RoTu in the police colony so the internal war had clearly started on the same day. He made a decision based on Vishakha's manipulations and him expecting RoTu to fight back or cause him and his mother problems. In all he is doing i doubt he thought far ahead that these people would pack up and leave. He was probably preparing for war.

Originally posted by: Kidult104

It seems they are drawing parallels with mannat and vikrant post birth truth revealations. When vimal happened, one of the reason for it was mannat choosing Shruti over everyone which is fair enough. After reveal, mannat was truly looking like sonia khanna, ruthless and shrewd, to the point shruti got scared of her.

Similarly vikrant now with his past memories thinks vishakha was wronged by criminals rotu and now he has transformed into aman kumar, vishakha's son. He chose his biological mother over everyone. They are drawing same parallels but at the end it comes to the point that mannat fought against actual bad people and vikrant is siding with actual bad people and fighting against the people who he thinks are bad. This makes me think he is gonna suffer way worse than what mannat suffered. Mannat saw vimal infront of her for sometime, Vikrant will see his family esp Mannat replacing him with dk for a really long time.

Also Mannat with dk has become his massive trigger. Adnan is doing a good job to portray that blind rage of aman. You feel like for a minute it is dawning upon him and then he sees Dk near mannat and all hell breaks loose. Slowly, hiding truth doesnt seem to be an issue for him but mannat choosing dk over him seems to be. He isnt realising that he himself is pushing her towards him and its his way of seeing them makes everything bad.

You know the saying "vinaash kale Vipreeta buddhi" seems to be true in Vikrant's case. So much jealousy, rage for Mannat who married him in secrecy and was begging him to complete the marriage. If he manages to remember she was willing to die with him and also spent a night with him. Most important she was begging for forgiveness and that she made a mistake which he never ever does in front of an audience even when he has made huge mistakes. Kyun karegee yeh sab if she wants to shak up with DK

Originally posted by: Bettyscar

I wonder how their absence is going to affect him. I understand the post leap after he sees all of them as a family unit it will be hard but i just wonder if in all he is doing in his anger he envisioned the impact of his decisions. He took the property to protect Vishakha but still went to check on RoTu in the police colony so the internal war had clearly started on the same day. He made a decision based on Vishakha's manipulations and him expecting RoTu to fight back or cause him and his mother problems. In all he is doing i doubt he thought far ahead that these people would pack up and leave. He was probably preparing for war.

Bold this depends on , Them leaving without "war" as drilled in by Vishakha will this change his perspective as to something is missing in the narrative or if he will he continue to believe Vish and her Vish kahaanee

Originally posted by: Rdigest

Bold this depends on , Them leaving without "war" as drilled in by Vishakha will this change his perspective as to something is missing in the narrative or if he will he continue to believe Vish and her Vish kahaanee

Ummm i'm starting to wonder if we are not grasping at straws and he really did deny being the baby's father in which case my question above doesn't matter. Probably explaains why Shruti was in the house. If it ended like this he really didn't care

https://youtu.be/PmnjlXbAGe4?si=c8vsBXqvHKIfL2Nx

I feel Shruti’s character will end before the leap. Rushad posted a story wearing a white kurta, and I think this incident will take the family to Amritsar and ultimately lead them to cut ties with Vik. Sharing my thoughts on the Vik/Aman equation: If Shruti dies, Vik will eventually discover the full truth about the seashore connection himself. The team will not ignore such a crucial foundation of the story. Pre-leap, Vik is triggered only by the partial memory shown through Vish’s visions. He clearly remembers only the accident. When the remaining memories resurface and he recalls Shruti face clearly, he will no longer need anyone else to validate the truth, he will witness it himself. Mukta will not lose the core essence of the story. Even though Vik told Mannat to give DK the BDB position in her life, she was clearly disgusted in the BTS. This accident has brought Aman back temporarily, but the deeper trigger will eventually bring Vik back. He will learn the full truth about his past: Vik’s real identity, how Ronnie returned to his family, how Vish sold him, and Neetu’s mental condition and struggles. Mukta and the team are very good at drawing parallels. Vik and Aman are fundamentally different personalities. We have seen most of the story through our green flag Vik someone shaped by Rotu’s values of love, respect, and family. Aman, on the other hand, is not a principled man. He operates out of fear and anger, planted by others. Interestingly, all these traits existed in Vik from the beginning; only situations changed, which altered his reactions. The writers are drawing a contrast between DK and Aman. Meeting the right people changes perspectives: this happened with DK. For Vik, however, he was pushed into becoming Aman and ended up choosing Vish over everything. That decision re-triggered his childhood traumas, making him unknowingly side with the wrong people, especially because Vish played the victim of wrongdoings by the rich. He failed to realize that DK changed not because of Mannat but after seeing how principled, value-driven, and grounded Vik’s life had been under Rotu’s upbringing. The leap is necessary for Vik to clearly see the difference between Rotu and Vish. Vish will eventually show her greed and manipulative nature in front of him. Only then will he understand how Rotu always stood by him and how he has now lost that unconditional love.

Originally posted by: Daman17

I feel Shruti’s character will end before the leap. Rushad posted a story wearing a white kurta, and I think this incident will take the family to Amritsar and ultimately lead them to cut ties with Vik. Sharing my thoughts on the Vik/Aman equation: If Shruti dies, Vik will eventually discover the full truth about the seashore connection himself. The team will not ignore such a crucial foundation of the story. Pre-leap, Vik is triggered only by the partial memory shown through Vish’s visions. He clearly remembers only the accident. When the remaining memories resurface and he recalls Shruti face clearly, he will no longer need anyone else to validate the truth, he will witness it himself. Mukta will not lose the core essence of the story. Even though Vik told Mannat to give DK the BDB position in her life, she was clearly disgusted in the BTS. This accident has brought Aman back temporarily, but the deeper trigger will eventually bring Vik back. He will learn the full truth about his past: Vik’s real identity, how Ronnie returned to his family, how Vish sold him, and Neetu’s mental condition and struggles. Mukta and the team are very good at drawing parallels. Vik and Aman are fundamentally different personalities. We have seen most of the story through our green flag Vik someone shaped by Rotu’s values of love, respect, and family. Aman, on the other hand, is not a principled man. He operates out of fear and anger, planted by others. Interestingly, all these traits existed in Vik from the beginning; only situations changed, which altered his reactions. The writers are drawing a contrast between DK and Aman. Meeting the right people changes perspectives: this happened with DK. For Vik, however, he was pushed into becoming Aman and ended up choosing Vish over everything. That decision re-triggered his childhood traumas, making him unknowingly side with the wrong people, especially because Vish played the victim of wrongdoings by the rich. He failed to realize that DK changed not because of Mannat but after seeing how principled, value-driven, and grounded Vik’s life had been under Rotu’s upbringing. The leap is necessary for Vik to clearly see the difference between Rotu and Vish. Vish will eventually show her greed and manipulative nature in front of him. Only then will he understand how Rotu always stood by him and how he has now lost that unconditional love.

So when should we anticipate these memories to come back? With the way he is going to leave things pre-leap i worry what state we find him in post leap. I suppose as long as he is not married we should be grateful

Originally posted by: Bettyscar

Ummm i'm starting to wonder if we are not grasping at straws and he really did deny being the baby's father in which case my question above doesn't matter. Probably explaains why Shruti was in the house. If it ended like this he really didn't care

https://youtu.be/PmnjlXbAGe4?si=c8vsBXqvHKIfL2Nx

Think I will grasp at straws a little longer until BTS is released because there is really no story if he really does this post leap.

Originally posted by: Daman17

I feel Shruti’s character will end before the leap. Rushad posted a story wearing a white kurta, and I think this incident will take the family to Amritsar and ultimately lead them to cut ties with Vik. Sharing my thoughts on the Vik/Aman equation: If Shruti dies, Vik will eventually discover the full truth about the seashore connection himself. The team will not ignore such a crucial foundation of the story. Pre-leap, Vik is triggered only by the partial memory shown through Vish’s visions. He clearly remembers only the accident. When the remaining memories resurface and he recalls Shruti face clearly, he will no longer need anyone else to validate the truth, he will witness it himself. Mukta will not lose the core essence of the story. Even though Vik told Mannat to give DK the BDB position in her life, she was clearly disgusted in the BTS. This accident has brought Aman back temporarily, but the deeper trigger will eventually bring Vik back. He will learn the full truth about his past: Vik’s real identity, how Ronnie returned to his family, how Vish sold him, and Neetu’s mental condition and struggles. Mukta and the team are very good at drawing parallels. Vik and Aman are fundamentally different personalities. We have seen most of the story through our green flag Vik someone shaped by Rotu’s values of love, respect, and family. Aman, on the other hand, is not a principled man. He operates out of fear and anger, planted by others. Interestingly, all these traits existed in Vik from the beginning; only situations changed, which altered his reactions. The writers are drawing a contrast between DK and Aman. Meeting the right people changes perspectives: this happened with DK. For Vik, however, he was pushed into becoming Aman and ended up choosing Vish over everything. That decision re-triggered his childhood traumas, making him unknowingly side with the wrong people, especially because Vish played the victim of wrongdoings by the rich. He failed to realize that DK changed not because of Mannat but after seeing how principled, value-driven, and grounded Vik’s life had been under Rotu’s upbringing. The leap is necessary for Vik to clearly see the difference between Rotu and Vish. Vish will eventually show her greed and manipulative nature in front of him. Only then will he understand how Rotu always stood by him and how he has now lost that unconditional love.

Every theory is stating to sound like a fairytale now that this is week 3 of torture and easily there is 1 more week of torture left

Originally posted by: Rdigest

Every theory is stating to sound like a fairytale now that this is week 3 of torture and easily there is 1 more week of torture left

Hope is always the last to die. I forsee us getting the biggest of heartbreaks.