Why Sidharth Malhotra films flop! Solution: Check page 18 post #173 - Page 3

Originally posted by: Rossalinne

Just look at the hint you will find the answer, the film star's I mentioned they have it in them but Sidharth still not achieve it THAT'S THE CURRENT AND ONLY REASON HE IS FLOP, if he does he will have a chance to taste sucess, he should do it fast before it's too late, or he will be too old too do it in films

I have given the hint think about it, what these film stars has done it in their films which Sidharth was not done it yet

Bata bhi do , my brain is dead

Well, I let guess the "true Sid fans"...in my mind there is nothing he should do what others did only to get more financial success.

Originally posted by: mz.gigglez

Bata bhi do , my brain is dead

It's a very simple answer, if you have watched Sidharth Malhotra films and any films of the stars I mentioned in hint you would easily say this is the answer, even I want to reveal but really want you to know, but really want to get the correct answer from any self movie critic or sid fans, I don't want to ruin their fun by revealing it easily

Guess it, if you had watched single film of Sidharth you will automatically know the answer, the thing which is currently missing from his films, of he doesn't do it quickly he will be a gone case and in vvan also if this thing will be missing MARK MY WORDS VVAN WILL BE FLOP TOO!!!

Originally posted by: Clochette

Well, I let guess the "true Sid fans"...in my mind there is nothing he should do what others did only to get more financial success.

Meaning I don't get you properly!!!! Elaborate more please, is it something related to movie story or movie promotion

Originally posted by: CrimeMasterToto

He doesnt have the looks for massy movies though .. very urban. He tried in that one movie marjavaan and seemed so out of place. Plus massy ke liye .. you need a bit of a set fan base in young, male audience. I feel his fan base (whatever there is of it) is mostly females and families. Yeh log massy dekhne nahi ayenge

The only time he was able to crack the male demographic was with Shershah I think, but sadly that was not a theatrical release. And even there, it was his romantic angle which got propped up more than his action avatar. But he should try more such projects - army, police etc.

I think Param Sundari is also the right genre for him - if it was any other non-nepo actress, I feel it would have served him and the movie better because looks like its a well made movie.

Ek villain was kind of massy? and he was total action hero in it. So i don't think that is the reason. he can do massy movies and it will work but it should not be a whatsoever type movie like Ranbir's Besharam. Sid can easily do a well made action movie.

That is what KI means (and so do I) and which wasn't done in most of his movies where - imo - his fortes aren't taken in account:

"What's often described as missing from Siddharth Malhotra's filmography is consistently strong scripting and story quality, which has hindered his commercial success despite his screen presence. While he has shown a willingness to experiment with different roles, the films often fail to connect with audiences due to weak scripts, leading to a career marked by commercial underperformance and a "star vs. the scripts" dynamic. ...

In essence: While Siddharth Malhotra possesses undeniable screen presence and has attempted to diversify his roles, the common thread in his career struggles has been the absence of robust, well-written scripts that could fully showcase his abilities and translate into commercial success."

Originally posted by: iamrebelheart

Ek villain was kind of massy? and he was total action hero in it. So i don't think that is the reason. he can do massy movies and it will work but it should not be a whatsoever type movie like Ranbir's Besharam. Sid can easily do a well made action movie.

If action movies of his would be too good then marjavaan, aiyaary, yodha, indian police force, would be hit, not a varun fan but in badlapur a action movie of his, his action movie was way to perfect then sid

Originally posted by: Rossalinne

Hint: the solution in this film is something Varun, Alia, Kiara, Disha, Ananya, Ranbir, Akshay, Shahid, Rashmika and Tamanna in south but not in hindi films yet and many other stars have it in there films, but Sidharth Malhotra has not achieved yet

What does this mean ?

What have they received that he didnt ?

Originally posted by: Clochette

That is what KI means (and so do I) and which wasn't done in most of his movies where - imo - his fortes aren't taken in account:

"What's often described as missing from Siddharth Malhotra's filmography is consistently strong scripting and story quality, which has hindered his commercial success despite his screen presence. While he has shown a willingness to experiment with different roles, the films often fail to connect with audiences due to weak scripts, leading to a career marked by commercial underperformance and a "star vs. the scripts" dynamic. ...

In essence: While Siddharth Malhotra possesses undeniable screen presence and has attempted to diversify his roles, the common thread in his career struggles has been the absence of robust, well-written scripts that could fully showcase his abilities and translate into commercial success."

Kinda agree this has been his weakness, but as I told earlier, Rajkumar Rao has less privileged than Sid, but still able to find success too

I am happy that you find his weak point, but that's not a answer, ok I will say that you have reached almost 10% of the hint, I mentioned but still nobody has able to guess the hint yet just little more effort and thinking from my hint and how you point his weakness, you would able to find answer

Originally posted by: Maroonporsche

What does this mean ?

What have they received that he didnt ?

If you had watched at least 5 Sidharth Malhotra films you would say easily, what Sidharth Malhotra films doesn't do and what others do to have in their filmography, a major thing is missing