Mannat other version discussion thread - Page 40

So Moor, do you think with the show getting 👍🏼 for time being the writers will diverge from the OG storyline ?

You suggested they may swap ARS and Anirudh’s victimhood…… yesterday’s episode suggested ARS was big-time faking …….and Ani’s conviction that she’s lying seem to suggest he is indeed a victim. In that case same way Vikrant is as you mentioned in your last comment.

Women vs Men and their deceits…. so much more interesting if Hindi version shifts the narrative, and hopefully a better ending as Mannat can have a relationship with her father.

Also keep everyone guessing rather than OG outcome.

I am not sure if they'll diverge from OG.. but they most certainly have in ARSs entire character graph.

Arzu could get sympathy because she was not as vile as Aish... also appreciated Cennets good qualities early on even if she didnt accept it openly.

Her being a victim and hating Cennet because of her trauma makes sense ..

Thats totally not the case with Aish... she is a proper criminal with Sunitas blood on her hands and multiple other attempts on Mannat and Shruti and Chawl people... even Vikrant as a collateral.

Her behaviour doesnt get a free pass just because she was assaulted.

Thats why I felt Anirudh is a victim and not Aish. She is pretending to be one.

And the way he is adamant that he didnt do wrong is totally how Viks situation has been.

We still dont know why Aish left him.. but what if its another parallel to Vik... Aish thought he had money... trapped him but didnt get what she wanted and so she left him.

Malla would have done the same thing after Amans truth waa out and he declared penniless.

I see a complete parallel between Ani and Vik.. he is being asked to give proof... same way RS family judged Vik even though he kept repeating he doesnt remember. Vik doesnt have any proof either to prove his innocence.

Originally posted by: Moor278

I am not sure if they'll diverge from OG.. but they most certainly have in ARSs entire character graph.

Arzu could get sympathy because she was not as vile as Aish... also appreciated Cennets good qualities early on even if she didnt accept it openly.

Her being a victim and hating Cennet because of her trauma makes sense ..

Thats totally not the case with Aish... she is a proper criminal with Sunitas blood on her hands and multiple other attempts on Mannat and Shruti and Chawl people... even Vikrant as a collateral.

Her behaviour doesnt get a free pass just because she was assaulted.

Thats why I felt Anirudh is a victim and not Aish. She is pretending to be one.

And the way he is adamant that he didnt do wrong is totally how Viks situation has been.

We still dont know why Aish left him.. but what if its another parallel to Vik... Aish thought he had money... trapped him but didnt get what she wanted and so she left him.

Malla would have done the same thing after Amans truth waa out and he declared penniless.

I see a complete parallel between Ani and Vik.. he is being asked to give proof... same way RS family judged Vik even though he kept repeating he doesnt remember. Vik doesnt have any proof either to prove his innocence.

wow that’s brilliant Moor, these parallels fit so well with hindi version’s ARS character, the overriding theme of proofs and trust and dragging out Vikku’s marriage to tie up the money angle.

If Anirudh’s case turns out same as Vik - well done to the writers and YOU!
Will be a much better twist if they play it out this way….. the OG ending was sad but inevitable for Kaya given his crime, so could be changed here.

Very excited at new track - and sooooo looking forward Adnan’s performance when Aman truth starts unravelling

Originally posted by: Shazia_h

I remember this set of ivs, in one, the male interviewer seemed to have the fancies for Mona and kept hinting Aish & Vikrant should hook up, I think Adnan was quite embarrassed ☺️😂

This iv. It was so awkward to hear 😅

https://youtu.be/ovlGutJAK9g?si=uEoUEQYbgOs7RVT5

Originally posted by: Mona_HappyLife

This iv. It was so awkward to hear 😅

https://youtu.be/ovlGutJAK9g?si=uEoUEQYbgOs7RVT5

OMG rewatching it he’s even more cringe 😂🤣😂 Mona was almost blushing from embarrassment. And she looked stunning and so ‘hot’ as he put it.

Bless Adnan, a true gentleman masha’Allah ❤️

Arzu also warned Melisa repeatedly against her actions... and that Selim doesnt love her...

ARs has not done that... innfact went ahead and contributed to it...

Also in her recent attempts too... theres a red Herring which I am trying to make sense... Aish clearly told Mannat that Malla waa behind the assault attack.. but later on she is stressing that zhe wants shares back...

I am not getting if thats Aishs overconfidence or her next set of trick...

Because if she thinks she can get shares directly from Mannat... Mallas usability is over.

Aish can control Vik by giving him Mannat and getting her share back... Malla doesnt feature anywhere. Though if Malla is married to Vik, ARS has more control.

Depends on how much Vik is adamant about his decision to divorce.

Originally posted by: Moor278

Arzu also warned Melisa repeatedly against her actions... and that Selim doesnt love her...

ARs has not done that... innfact went ahead and contributed to it...

Also in her recent attempts too... theres a red Herring which I am trying to make sense... Aish clearly told Mannat that Malla waa behind the assault attack.. but later on she is stressing that zhe wants shares back...

I am not getting if thats Aishs overconfidence or her next set of trick...

Because if she thinks she can get shares directly from Mannat... Mallas usability is over.

Aish can control Vik by giving him Mannat and getting her share back... Malla doesnt feature anywhere. Though if Malla is married to Vik, ARS has more control.

Depends on how much Vik is adamant about his decision to divorce.

Yes Arzu from when she heard Melissa slept with Selim, slapped her and didn’t believe her….. and not just told her Selim doesn’t love her, but how important love was in a marriage and not to sell herself short. Agree, completely opposite to ARS.

Arzu was driven by wanting to keep her secret buried and hatred for Kaya. ARS’s driver is securing her future wealth.

I see your point - it is puzzling why ARS actually told Mannat, what she has to gain, other than part of winning Mannat’s sympathy and trust, at the scene or if it comes out later on? That’s a bit weak though for such a big admission on Malla.

ARS’s acting has clearly won Mannat and Vikrant over and I think Mannu is naive enough to hand back the shares. ARS wants security in controlling Vik’s wealth too. And as you say, she can control him via Malla, but not if Vik is married to Mannat……. Malla is becoming such a loose cannon and ARS must realise she can’t help hold their marriage together much longer so her plan B is Mannat, but playing one sister off the other? Still don’t understand what she’s up to.

Another thing, Vikrant realised ARS had forced Mannat to go away in return for the liver donation….. why then would ARS give her shares? As without knowing the reason, the GD is still implied ? I may have missed something in yesterday’s dialogues.

Good point... as you say this might be a trick to gain Mannats trust, because Mannat definitely noticed that even if she has not thought about it.

Another good point is she knows she cant control Vik through Malla.. so maybe Mannat as the pawn...

As for Vik, he did say in kitchen that there's something amiss... that he hasn't got yet... but boy is just happy that it was because she was in a moral dilemma... not because she didnt want to have a relationship with him.. 😆

Originally posted by: Moor278

As for Vik, he did say in kitchen that there's something amiss... that he hasn't got yet... but boy is just happy that it was because she was in a moral dilemma... not because she didnt want to have a relationship with him.. 😆

thank you for clarifying … awwww that’s Vikki all over ❤️ does she love me or not 😂

Love his soppy character where Mannat is concerned , but fiery for everyone.

Originally posted by: Shazia_h

thank you for clarifying … awwww that’s Vikki all over ❤️ does she love me or not 😂

Love his soppy character where Mannat is concerned , but fiery for everyone.

V : she loves me , she loves me not !