Mannat Har Khushi Paane Ki: Episode Discussion Thread - 22 - Page 29

Originally posted by: shiro_shinchan

https://youtu.be/E_ghmifHBtU?feature=shared

Seems like Mannat the one woman army will be the ones to save herself

If she saves herself there and then so why was Shruti being shoved by Neetu? Is that for something else?

Daddy dearest as new investor:

https://youtu.be/Zo9vbY-4_hw?si=pQrW4GgEkIMF9edw

Originally posted by: Bettyscar

Here is me trying to be rational After someone breaks our hearts we try to distance ourselves from them.

I think the words Mannat spoke when Vikrant confessed his love broke him. He never thought he could have been that wrong about her. The evidence speaks for itself with the business that she got. Like Mannat said, he is still stuck where she left him. ARS plan was foolproof just that she didn't count on Mannat pulling that share transfer plan.

Given she broke his heart and basically sold his love why does he need to prove Mannat's innocence. Prove it for who? The problem with the kaands that Malla creates, they also create problems for other people. As much as Mannat is going to go to jail, this is also bad for Mezbaani and also affects Vikrant's dream. He already has no peace at home because the person who broke his heart is now also living under the same roof as him. He is married to someone he does not love paying for a "sin" he committed. Now his business will be affected again like it did during the bobby saga. He is basically losing everything as well so why should he also not focus on his pain and loss as well.

Mannat expressed her love but what does it change really. He is a married man now. He just wants to focus on his own healing. It's going to take a lot for him to understand that Mannat loves him and for it to sink in. Maybe only when she shows him Malla's true face.

I am talking about his overall persona.

Like mOor said above, he was pissed off with Malla but took out his anger on Mannat.

I am not even considering Bobby case as it was for the 1st time it was related to his family and his relation with Mannat was evolving so I understand believing a 3rd person isn't easy..

But whenever a small or big argument has happened within SM, the entire blame has been on Mannat & literally no one has been there to take her side, she had even highlighted this very point to Vikrant when he was drunk.

The girl didnt even get time fo grieve post Sunita's death, everyone just started l shouting at her for no fault of hers.

Vikrant ka pain if understandable then Mannat’s pain should also be understandable.

Baaki thanks to makers for ruining the character sketch. There has to be a basic check & balance between ML & FL but itv is bad at this.

Originally posted by: Bettyscar

Here is me trying to be rational After someone breaks our hearts we try to distance ourselves from them.

I think the words Mannat spoke when Vikrant confessed his love broke him. He never thought he could have been that wrong about her. The evidence speaks for itself with the business that she got. Like Mannat said, he is still stuck where she left him. ARS plan was foolproof just that she didn't count on Mannat pulling that share transfer plan.

Given she broke his heart and basically sold his love why does he need to prove Mannat's innocence. Prove it for who? The problem with the kaands that Malla creates, they also create problems for other people. As much as Mannat is going to go to jail, this is also bad for Mezbaani and also affects Vikrant's dream. He already has no peace at home because the person who broke his heart is now also living under the same roof as him. He is married to someone he does not love paying for a "sin" he committed. Now his business will be affected again like it did during the bobby saga. He is basically losing everything as well so why should he also not focus on his pain and loss as well.

Mannat expressed her love but what does it change really. He is a married man now. He just wants to focus on his own healing. It's going to take a lot for him to understand that Mannat loves him and for it to sink in. Maybe only when she shows him Malla's true face.

Originally posted by: Deepa11q

so so beautifully explained!!!

Just adding the below parts:

Vikrant’s character is deeply human and that’s what makes him so compelling. He’s someone who trusts, gets hurt, breaks down, and takes time to heal. He’s not the kind of person who can flip a switch and suddenly fix everything. Like Addy said, right now he’s weighed down by a storm of emotions betrayal, rejection, confusion and because of that, he’s not in a place to fully understand why things are falling apart. But instinctively, he knows something isn’t right… and he will get to the bottom of it. If we talk about earlier storylines, like the Bobby track it’s not easy for anyone to accept that someone from their own family could be capable of something so horrifying. Be it murder, abuse no one wants to believe that. And when it comes to the fact that his mother was secretly drugging him again, no one can easily digest that. Who questions their own mother like that? These are complex, deeply human reactions.

But despite all of this the pain, the doubt, the rage Vikrant never stops protecting Mannat. His anger is never just directed at her. When he loses control, it’s at the situation, at himself, at the betrayal. But even in those moments, her safety is always his top priority. And that says everything about his character.

Originally posted by: Deepa11q

so so beautifully explained!!!

Just adding the below parts:

Vikrant’s character is deeply human and that’s what makes him so compelling. He’s someone who trusts, gets hurt, breaks down, and takes time to heal. He’s not the kind of person who can flip a switch and suddenly fix everything. Like Addy said, right now he’s weighed down by a storm of emotions betrayal, rejection, confusion and because of that, he’s not in a place to fully understand why things are falling apart. But instinctively, he knows something isn’t right… and he will get to the bottom of it. If we talk about earlier storylines, like the Bobby track it’s not easy for anyone to accept that someone from their own family could be capable of something so horrifying. Be it murder, abuse no one wants to believe that. And when it comes to the fact that his mother was secretly drugging him again, no one can easily digest that. Who questions their own mother like that? These are complex, deeply human reactions.

But despite all of this the pain, the doubt, the rage Vikrant never stops protecting Mannat. His anger is never just directed at her. When he loses control, it’s at the situation, at himself, at the betrayal. But even in those moments, her safety is always his top priority. And that says everything about his character.

There have been many times where anger has been directed at her due to others.

Once in a while is fine but when it becomes repetitive it becomes a problem. I believe a part of it is routed in classism too which he inherited from SM members. If Mannat from the beginning was of equal status as him, then the equation & his behavior towards her would have been different. He would think few times before shouting at her. The no of times he has shouted at Malla is way way lesser than at Mannat which is also because Malla is a part of his family. But that was still acceptable to the point when he had not completely fallen in love with her but post the realization phase, there should have been a subtle change.

I am ranting today bcz i got pissed off completely when he started shouting at her in the kitchen in front of everyone & was clenching his jaw. He knows that Shruti is still in recovery phase & bcz of that might have gone back to SM still he felt that she was lying.

Originally posted by: Mona_HappyLife

There have been many times where anger has been directed at her due to others.

Once in a while is fine but when it becomes repetitive it becomes a problem. I believe a part of it is routed in classism too which he inherited from SM members. If Mannat from the beginning was of equal status as him, then the equation & his behavior towards her would have been different. He would think few times before shouting at her. The no of times he has shouted at Malla is way way lesser than at Mannat which is also because Malla is a part of his family. But that was still acceptable to the point when he had not completely fallen in love with her but post the realization phase, there should have been a subtle change.

I am ranting today bcz i got pissed off completely when he started shouting at her in the kitchen in front of everyone & was clenching his jaw. He knows that Shruti is still in recovery phase & bcz of that might have gone back to SM still he felt that she was lying.

its okay when you dont want to understand someone from their pov. Cant force it.
Hope you get it to be able to enjoy the show from everyone's perspectives and not just one character's which is the obvious one :).

Originally posted by: Deepa11q

its okay when you dont want to understand someone from their pov. Cant force it.
Hope you get it to be able to enjoy the show from everyone's perspectives and not just one character's which is the obvious one :).

I already mentioned that am understanding both their povs but am just pissed off to see his behavior today. He his completely messed up right now, understandable but everytime taking out his anger on Mannat is not going to solve his problems.

Makers don't even allow him some space or time to think clearly.

Shaadi se pehle hi aisa hai, if they don't resolve the issues with each other then post marriage it will escalate more.

Originally posted by: Mona_HappyLife

I already mentioned that am understanding both their povs but am just pissed off to see his behavior today. He his completely messed up right now, understandable but everytime taking out his anger on Mannat is not going to solve his problems.

Makers don't even allow him some space or time to think clearly.

Shaadi se pehle hi aisa hai, if they don't resolve the issues with each other then post marriage it will escalate more.

Bold: I think this interview answers you on this part to some extent. In terms of him shouting today that is. When it comes to work Vikrant has always been like that. I think overally his behaviour has been frustrating to us as viewers that it can be hard to judge each event in isolation. It's like oooh there he goes again.

https://youtu.be/zwTH8prmNGQ?si=wpqnRBRFch7mS2OS