Mannat other version discussion thread - Page 31

Created

Last reply

Replies

384

Views

23k

Users

29

Likes

1.1k

Frequent Posters

Bettyscar thumbnail
Visit Streak 180 Thumbnail Visit Streak 90 Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 22 days ago

I'm assuming Mannat is going to find out the Aman truth through her interaction with Varun. Is she likely to keep this info from Vikrant considering there is a whole brother in the picture? Or in her attempt to confront RoTu the informations will land in the wrong ears and create problems for her again?

The Malla angle of then disclosing that Mannat was aware to create distance between him and Mannat makes sense but that house also has a lot of loose cannons you can't quite predict which one will unleash

Edited by Bettyscar - 22 days ago
Moor278 thumbnail
Visit Streak 750 Thumbnail Visit Streak 500 Thumbnail + 9
Posted: 22 days ago

Originally posted by: Bettyscar

I'm assuming Mannat is going to find out the Aman truth through her interaction with Varun. Is she likely to keep this info from Vikrant considering there is a whole brother in the picture? Or in her attempt to confront RoTu the informations will land in the wrong ears and create problems for her again?

The Malla angle of then disclosing that Mannat was aware to create distance between him and Mannat makes sense but that house also has a lot of loose cannons you can't quite predict which one will unleash

This is totally possible... very much on lines of OG smiley20

Rdigest thumbnail
Hogwarts Championship 2025 Thumbnail Fashion Feud Participant Thumbnail + 7

Team Aishwarya

Posted: 22 days ago

Originally posted by: Moor278

Few more points

ManVik had a very easy going relationship till this fake proposal thing happened...

Mannat would have agreed easily and their issues regarding trust, faith and anger would have cropped up later...

Malla Neetu might have still played the same games and that would have led to ManVik separation...


This is the first time that they have conflict due to each other... thats why I love the fact that they communicate... had it been a married relationship the expectations would have been different and it would have been another run of mill story 😉

ManVik and AmaNat are different.. and we love them for that 😍

Vik made a statement about the fateful night... that he doesnt have proof that he didnt do it... and its for the first time he is going to experience what Mannat always did... Bina saboot ke bharosa...

I would love if Mannat doesnt tell him about Mallaa kaand but shows her trust in him 🥰 let him experience what she means about trust.

And someone should point out that had it been Mannat in Mallas place, they would have blamed her and not Vik. smiley28

Bold, he is not saying this naa to Mannat, did I miss this dialogue? Infact all I understood so far is I don't remember and I accept my mistake. This wouldn't bring in Trust factor naa, where is Mannat distrusting him, she is believing what he is saying 🤔

Rdigest thumbnail
Hogwarts Championship 2025 Thumbnail Fashion Feud Participant Thumbnail + 7

Team Aishwarya

Posted: 22 days ago

Originally posted by: Bettyscar

I'm assuming Mannat is going to find out the Aman truth through her interaction with Varun. Is she likely to keep this info from Vikrant considering there is a whole brother in the picture? Or in her attempt to confront RoTu the informations will land in the wrong ears and create problems for her again?

The Malla angle of then disclosing that Mannat was aware to create distance between him and Mannat makes sense but that house also has a lot of loose cannons you can't quite predict which one will unleash

This is worst scenario smiley37

Arye baba if this ticket also cuts for Mannat before Bobby reveal, when will this criminal get outed. With Mannat's rejection he got drunk and fake ONS happened , if this happens, Malla obviously won't leave the opportunity of getting into bed with her target. Then we can have pregnancy track for next few months smiley39

Moor278 thumbnail
Visit Streak 750 Thumbnail Visit Streak 500 Thumbnail + 9
Posted: 22 days ago

Originally posted by: Rdigest

Bold, he is not saying this naa to Mannat, did I miss this dialogue? Infact all I understood so far is I don't remember and I accept my mistake. This wouldn't bring in Trust factor naa, where is Mannat distrusting him, she is believing what he is saying 🤔

Now you confuse me... I will have to check again smiley36

Rdigest thumbnail
Hogwarts Championship 2025 Thumbnail Fashion Feud Participant Thumbnail + 7

Team Aishwarya

Posted: 22 days ago

Originally posted by: Moor278

Now you confuse me... I will have to check again smiley36

mission accomplished smiley36 no one who watches this show can be at peace smiley37

Shazia_h thumbnail
Visit Streak 90 Thumbnail Visit Streak 30 Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail

Team Vikrant

Posted: 22 days ago

Originally posted by: Moor278

This post/theory/rant is more of an observation and prediction from the OG.

Sorry in advance. smiley18


The story is back on track with OG now...

The key hint is Ronnie.

Except for getting ViMal actually married and not engaged... there is very less diversion in ManVik story.

I was skeptical when they got ARSs truth out earlier than in OG... but it was to give Mannat an advantage and to make her struggle relevant to the proceedings.

Mannat wont be revealing the truth as of yet.. she is worried for Shruti. At most it will be for Malla (per spoilers) but no Vikrant wont know its Aish who is liver donor.

Gagan knows and I seriously worry his fate if Aish gets to know he made the papers smiley19


So as per OG, ManVik had broken up due to Amans truth... here it is Shruti's operation and Aish being donor. Like OG, this wont come out soon either. Mannat is hiding it from Vik like Cennet was doing and planning to leave the city.

Malla is firmly in his life... here as his wife... she will continue her kaands and would be openly vile... Malla Mannat confrontation which is expected next week is also in OG...

Vik will be clueless but his anger will subside to some degree and his affection for Mannat will show once in a while enough to rile up Malla and plan her next move. Will he get upset at Malla like Selim used to do? I sincerely hope so.

By this logic, there should be a financial fraud angle in near future with Mannat getting arrested. This is where bio dad may plug in. But it could be Aish and not Malla doing this.


Why Ronnie is a clue is because as per OG, he is initially in favour of Cennet (as a employee and even as potential love interest for Selim) but later turns against her when Neetu tells her the truth about Ali/Selim and he worries their secret may come out. Selim questions his changed attitude towards Cennet and he doesnt answer. Ronnie asking Vik to give attention to Malla and not Mannat was on those lines.

Hopefully if they follow OG, Neetu will be the one to change.... Mannat helped her patch up with Vik... But Neetu right now is too blind to see it. Malla over time will isolate Vik from Neetu, like she threw Neetu under the bus for the reception kaand and let Vik be angry at Neetu ... which Neetu is not foreseeing right now... In OG, when Melisa reveals the truth about Ali to Selim, thats when Neetu changes for the first time... till then she is in support of Melisa as her bahu.

Here too... it might happen... how I cant say ... but Neetu has to realize Mannat wont be separating her from Vik rather that would Malla. Her biggest worry is this... that Vik will go away.... he wont.. not when Mannat is around.

When this happens, RoTu end up going to Cennet and asking her to protect Vik by hiding his secret.


The question here is when will Malla be exposed... and why did ViMal take place.... my firm belief as the episodes progress is... that this is linked to Amans truth... Malla doesnt care about Vik.. all she wants is money.... unlike Melisa who wanted Selim and not his money... I have always believed Malla is the one who would be revealing the truth to everyone...

Had Malla been just a friend... she would have had an upper hand and connection with Vik (like certain someone from Mannats past life) ... we now know she is smart enough to know how to manipulate her family members... like I said in the previous post... nobody knows Mannat broke Viks heart and thats why he got drunk... all they know is he got drunk and had s*x with Malla.... they are not blaming Malla because as a man Vik should have had control over himself and she is their own... a happy girl they have seen growing up... why would she do something despicable is beyond their understanding... like how everyone was with Bobby... that he would do such a thing...

Malla is nicely playing victim and by engaging in the rituals, she is indirectly showing Vik is still interested in Mannat.. so anything she is doing is justified in protecting her suhaag. smiley6

For ViMal to end formally and officially, this truth about Aman has to come out in some way... or even the fact that he is adopted illegally. There can be no property transferred to him legally. Some element of truth if not the entirety.... maybe this Varun guy is introduced here for that... if he knows Vik is his brother that is or Vik starts having flashbacks because of him.

Only when Amans truth and Viks finances crop up would Malla show her true colors and RoTu will see what she has put their son through. Mallas interest in holding on to this marriage is more to do with defeating and demeaning Mannat than anything else... and Viks money... his feelings dont matter to her. All she wants is to trap him somehow so that he cant leave her. This is what she is counting on and knows the family will support her.

Worst case scenario is I expect this to run another month... smiley19 ViMal is not going to end so soon... and not without something for Aman.

Only good thing is Malla's plans will not succeed... There's Mannat protecting Vik and Malla, disoriented with both set of parents is leaning towards Neetu who is not a master criminal like Aish.


Mannat meanwhile may decide to leave or transfer the shares to Vik and Gagan if things get heated up (I predict this would the malfunction video which Malla made and might leak to the media smiley7)


Aish's truth will be protected even if bio dad is revealed... Mannat, Shruti and Shalinis collective worry would keep them silent on this matter. No expectations from any of them that they would reveal to Vik. Harneet might... but dont think so either.


In all, I would say lets brace ourselves.... Malla is not going anywhere as of yet... smiley44

Earliest could be Ronnie's bday if Mukta wants to end this quickly smiley40


But sorry for spoiling the weekend with this smiley14

Moor you’ve paralleled details of OG storyline with Hindi version brilliantly!

I didn’t connect the sudden change in Ronnie we saw last night to OG, well done. And Mannat helping reconcile Neetu and her son (even Ronnie noticing) I hope indicates that Neetu will change in the future (and recall this incident).

Totally agree with you, let’s brace ourselves as we are going to be subjected to ViMal for a while yet, Vikrant isn’t going to find out about Malla’s kaand, nor ARSs secret any time soon and will continue to ignore obvious hints around him. In her desperation to win Vikrant’s affection and separate ManVik, Malla will subject Mannat to more malicious deeds 😖 and wouldn’t surprise me if there’s a kidnap/fire plot as Malla gets more unhinged.

The Aman truth is going to be messy too I image, it may well be as @Bettyscar suggested that Mannat finds out but doesn’t disclose to Vik, but Malla does and tells him, this all leading to not only alienating him from RoTu but Mannat too……..

your theory in bold on how Malla is going to react once Vik’s wealth is under question will be the deciding factor on ViMal’s future….. can’t wait to seeing this unravels

Also looking forward to Varun’s entrance, whether he is indeed Vik’s brother which is diverging from OG , or just bio-dad’s right-hand man……and when BD makes an entrance (perhaps compete with BB launch). I hope they don’t go as far as having allegations of financial fraud/jail for Mannat to link her to her bio dad. Could be Varun who bails her instead opening up for a love rival?

Cennet also moves in with her BD, so perhaps here Mannat may move out of SM 👏🏼

Rdigest thumbnail
Hogwarts Championship 2025 Thumbnail Fashion Feud Participant Thumbnail + 7

Team Aishwarya

Posted: 22 days ago

Originally posted by: Shazia_h

Moor you’ve paralleled details of OG storyline with Hindi version brilliantly!

I didn’t connect the sudden change in Ronnie we saw last night to OG, well done. And Mannat helping reconcile Neetu and her son (even Ronnie noticing) I hope indicates that Neetu will change in the future (and recall this incident).

Totally agree with you, let’s brace ourselves as we are going to be subjected to ViMal for a while yet, Vikrant isn’t going to find out about Malla’s kaand, nor ARSs secret any time soon and will continue to ignore obvious hints around him. In her desperation to win Vikrant’s affection and separate ManVik, Malla will subject Mannat to more malicious deeds 😖 and wouldn’t surprise me if there’s a kidnap/fire plot as Malla gets more unhinged.

The Aman truth is going to be messy too I image, it may well be as @Bettyscar suggested that Mannat finds out but doesn’t disclose to Vik, but Malla does and tells him, this all leading to not only alienating him from RoTu but Mannat too……..

your theory in bold on how Malla is going to react once Vik’s wealth is under question will be the deciding factor on ViMal’s future….. can’t wait to seeing this unravels

Also looking forward to Varun’s entrance, whether he is indeed Vik’s brother which is diverging from OG , or just bio-dad’s right-hand man……and when BD makes an entrance (perhaps compete with BB launch). I hope they don’t go as far as having allegations of financial fraud/jail for Mannat to link her to her bio dad. Could be Varun who bails her instead opening up for a love rival?

Cennet also moves in with her BD, so perhaps here Mannat may move out of SM 👏🏼

Mein aap teeno ko confuse karoongee ab since I am confused smiley36

If we assume Malla will only leave Vikrant when Aman's truth comes out why would she care to tell Vikrant, Mannat knew about this 🤔 . Mannat and Vikrant are already not on good terms with all the misunderstandings, ONS aftermath, what more can Vikrant get alienated from Mannat 🫣

Shazia_h thumbnail
Visit Streak 90 Thumbnail Visit Streak 30 Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail

Team Vikrant

Posted: 22 days ago

Originally posted by: Rdigest

Mein aap teeno ko confuse karoongee ab since I am confused smiley36

If we assume Malla will only leave Vikrant when Aman's truth comes out why would she care to tell Vikrant, Mannat knew about this 🤔 . Mannat and Vikrant are already not on good terms with all the misunderstandings, ONS aftermath, what more can Vikrant get alienated from Mannat 🫣

Even with misunderstands Vikrant will not completely distance from Mannat - after all they are business partners too. Mannat by this time knows of Malla’s ONS lie so probably softened and trying to protect him/get justice for him……

Probably Vikrant not being heir to Saluja wealth will not be connected immediately on the Aman revelation…… so Malla tells Vik to show how much she cares for him and doesn’t hold any secrets from him, unlike Mannat who knew but didn’t’ tell you….

On hearing this, Vikrant will feel a huge betrayal of trust again from Mannat.

The heir issue and loss of wealth may follow, at which point Malla will loose interest in Vik. But in the OG the wealth wasn’t part of the story, so Melissa was outed by being caught by Selim’s friend recording her confession to the kaand while drunk. I’m not sure which plot they’ll follow to finally separate ViMal.

Edited by Shazia_h - 22 days ago
Rdigest thumbnail
Hogwarts Championship 2025 Thumbnail Fashion Feud Participant Thumbnail + 7

Team Aishwarya

Posted: 22 days ago

Originally posted by: Shazia_h

Even with misunderstands Vikrant will not completely distance from Mannat - after all they are business partners too. Mannat by this time knows of Malla’s ONS lie so probably softened and trying to protect him/get justice for him……

Probably Vikrant not being heir to Saluja wealth will not be connected immediately on the Aman revelation…… so Malla tells Vik to show how much she cares for him and doesn’t hold any secrets from him, unlike Mannat who knew but didn’t’ tell you….

Vikrant will feel a huge betrayal of trust again from Mannat.

The heir issue and loss of wealth may follow, at which point Malla will loose interest in Vik. But in the OG the wealth wasn’t part of the story, so Melissa was only outed by being caught a friend recording her confession to the kaand while drunk. I’m not sure which plot they’ll follow to finally separate ViMal.

Basically this version tells us , Vikrant kaa dimaag waapas nahee ayegaasmiley36 and he will continue to only react to situations and move on to next Kaand

Mera dream of him getting flashbacks of Shruti and freaking out are slowly going down the drain 😭

Related Topics

Mannat Har Khushi Paane Ki Thumbnail

Posted by: nutmeg7

23 days ago

Mannat Har Khushi Paane Ki: Episode Discussion Thread - 21

WRITTEN UPDATES AND DAILY DISCUSSION THREAD NO 21 Welcome to Mannat - Har Khushi Paane Ki EDT Permission by Leprecheun

Expand ▼
Mannat Har Khushi Paane Ki Thumbnail

Posted by: Shemer

24 days ago

BTS Thread #2: Mannat Har Khushi Paane ki

Welcome to BTS Thread of MHKPK...

Expand ▼
Mannat Har Khushi Paane Ki Thumbnail

Posted by: nutmeg7

1 months ago

Mannat Har Khushi Paane Ki: Episode Discussion Thread - 20

WRITTEN UPDATES AND DAILY DISCUSSION THREAD NO 20 Welcome to Mannat - Har Khushi Paane Ki EDT Permission by Leprecheun Also, Welcome to Malla -...

Expand ▼
Mannat Har Khushi Paane Ki Thumbnail

Posted by: purplegirl7

6 months ago

Ayesha Singh AT : World ki best Chef Mannat

Welcome to Ayesha Singh AT Lets share our love and appreciation for Ayesha / Mannat here

Expand ▼
Mannat Har Khushi Paane Ki Thumbnail

Posted by: Shemer

6 months ago

ManVik AT ❤️: Mannat and Babaji ka banda Vikrant😜

RULES OF AT Appreciation threads are to be used to praise and appreciate particular favorite characters. All discussions related to actor's...

Expand ▼
Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".