Mannat Har Khushi Paane Ki: Episode Discussion Thread - 18 - Page 36

Originally posted by: Jyotsna09

They're not focusing on that angle not at all,koi farak nahi, lacking in expressions of jealousy or pain in losing him ..is it purposefully done or actress unable to express it properly?

Till the point of that reading of the vows scene, Mannat was crying and showing her feelings. In fact, even when Vikrant did his vows with her, she resisted till the end when she told him 'Apki har kushi mera sukoon hai".

But after that, Malla cried to her and said that she and Vikrant were standing too close. And Mannat promises her she will never come in between them. After that, Mannat has been more business like, whether in the bathroom during the cocktail party or in the kitchen scene. In fact, after the buttons stitching scene, as she walks out she tells herself to keep her feelings aside, and focus on ARS.

As far as I can see, that's what Mannat has been doing.

She, as it is gets taunts galore on trying to trap Vikrant. She is genuinely fond of Malla, and now she will not hurt her. Didn't she tell Gagan that she didn't want to spoil Malla's mehndi? Why and how can she show jealousy at this point? They are almost at the wedding day.

They are not showing monologues for her, maybe.

Vikrant is underestimating her love for Malla (and overestimating malla's love for Mannat, I have to add).

Originally posted by: scarlett22

Till the point of that reading of the vows scene, Mannat was crying and showing her feelings. In fact, even when Vikrant did his vows with her, she resisted till the end when she told him 'Apki har kushi mera sukoon hai".

But after that, Malla cried to her and said that she and Vikrant were standing too close. And Mannat promises her she will never come in between them. After that, Mannat has been more business like, whether in the bathroom during the cocktail party or in the kitchen scene. In fact, after the buttons stitching scene, as she walks out she tells herself to keep her feelings aside, and focus on ARS.

As far as I can see, that's what Mannat has been doing.

She, as it is gets taunts galore on trying to trap Vikrant. She is genuinely fond of Malla, and now she will not hurt her. Didn't she tell Gagan that she didn't want to spoil Malla's mehndi? Why and how can she show jealousy at this point? They are almost at the wedding day.

They are not showing monologues for her, maybe.

Vikrant is underestimating her love for Malla (and overestimating malla's love for Mannat, I have to add).

I agree 👍🏻 but that pain of losing her love and him should be seen in her eyes if not in actions..longing and yearning eyes ,I'm missing and it gives only farak nahi padta vibe only without her monos🤪😝not much...

Originally posted by: Jyotsna09

They're not focusing on that angle not at all,koi farak nahi, lacking in expressions of jealousy or pain in losing him ..is it purposefully done?

Ayesha is not an actor who will fail at this... she has tremendous range of emotions... it is being done purposefully so that it looks like use farak nahi padta...

she has accepted that Vikrant is going to marry Malla....

even in all her IVs ayesha is saying the same thing... how will she express if Vikrant is marrying her best friend...

Originally posted by: Jyotsna09

I agree 👍🏻 but that pain of losing her love and him should be seen in her eyes if not in actions..longing and yearning eyes ,I'm missing and it gives only farak nahi padta vibe only without her monos🤪😝not much...

Itna toh samjha rahi hai but Vikku ke bheje mei jaa nai rha so she is emotionally withdrawn. Yes occasional triggers hota hai, she feels the pain but then ARS case makes her proceed with her day to day activities

Originally posted by: scarlett22

Till the point of that reading of the vows scene, Mannat was crying and showing her feelings. In fact, even when Vikrant did his vows with her, she resisted till the end when she told him 'Apki har kushi mera sukoon hai".

But after that, Malla cried to her and said that she and Vikrant were standing too close. And Mannat promises her she will never come in between them. After that, Mannat has been more business like, whether in the bathroom during the cocktail party or in the kitchen scene. In fact, after the buttons stitching scene, as she walks out she tells herself to keep her feelings aside, and focus on ARS.

As far as I can see, that's what Mannat has been doing.

She, as it is gets taunts galore on trying to trap Vikrant. She is genuinely fond of Malla, and now she will not hurt her. Didn't she tell Gagan that she didn't want to spoil Malla's mehndi? Why and how can she show jealousy at this point? They are almost at the wedding day.

They are not showing monologues for her, maybe.

Vikrant is underestimating her love for Malla (and overestimating malla's love for Mannat, I have to add).

Even I don't want her to cry infront of him or show jealousy infront of him... But some monologue of her kind kitna hurting hai would have been better.... See we have to agree hum kitna bhi strong ho , at the point where we are losing our loved ones we will feel bad which can be covered up... Atleast showing mannath opening up to her self in her room would have made sence....

She is being strong for malla and promise given to her but is her love for vikranth is less than what she had for malla.... Tomorrow even if she gets married to Vikranth,it looks like because of ars but not for vikranth...

I am exited to see he married to Vikranth because of ars but vikranth also should be the reason

Just saw the promo. At this point, even if Mannat knows ARS being her mom, doesn't look like she will get married to Vikrant at least to me. Why will she? She has completely distanced herself from Vikrant. She is shutting off emotionally. Focusing on her revenge with ARS to leave behind all the taunts, insults and pain. At this point Vikrant is just Malla's fiance. She will step in definitely to protect him, because of her feelings. Where she was at the point of confessing and where Vikrant's actions have brought her now? Such a fool Vikrant has been.

Originally posted by: Shemer

And the main thing...this story was always about Mannat and ARS...the conflict between a mother and daughter...ManVik is just a part of the story ..the main part is Mannu ARS

So now we will see the open war between them ..and also mannu getting to know about Sonia Khanna ka past..

@bold - So now, Mannat might start searching for her biological father just to bring ARS down.

Once Mannat gets to know that ARS is her birth mom, I want Mannat to give a piece of her mind to Harneet Paaji for keeping her in the darkness for so long. Can't do anything to Shruti as she's in coma.

Originally posted by: Moor278

Ayesha is not an actor who will fail at this... she has tremendous range of emotions... it is being done purposefully so that it looks like use farak nahi padta...

she has accepted that Vikrant is going to marry Malla....

even in all her IVs ayesha is saying the same thing... how will she express if Vikrant is marrying her best friend...

I agree ,she can't confess nor express her love to him now in these circumstances but atleast that pain in eyes should be shown...failure of the director...bindass making arrangements, even in alone time she isn't contemplating ..this is weird for me .

Originally posted by: Jyotsna09

I agree ,she can't confess nor express her love to him now in these circumstances but atleast that pain in eyes should be shown...failure of the director...bindass making arrangements, even in alone time she isn't contemplating ..this is weird for me .

How I see is Mannat has too much on her plate to focus on her unrequited feelings which she has not admitted even to herself. The only time she can't get hold of her emotions is when Vikrant gets close to her and she looses herself. That is why she is being shown to keep her distance. Not letting him speak, not staying even when he gets close, finding excuses to leave the room. Because she knows if he gets close, she cannot control herself and loose focus and she cannot afford that. I see her pain clearly when Neetu taunts her and shows off Malla as Vikrant's fiance but she is not letting herself get carried away, because at this point she cannot afford it.

Originally posted by: Jyotsna09

I agree ,she can't confess nor express her love to him now in these circumstances but atleast that pain in eyes should be shown...failure of the director...bindass making arrangements, even in alone time she isn't contemplating ..this is weird for me .

Which is the same thing they are doing to Vikrant...

Not giving him any dialgues and solo scenes to show that he realises it is affecting Mannat badly... or even a remote thought on how stupid this entire idea is...

Mannat was pretty clear on what she expects out of him...

Its a writer/directors fault.... not the actors IMO.