Jhanak Written Update And Episode Discussion Thread #113 - Page 5

Originally posted by: Shalinim153

Wahh...kal tk ye stage 1 cancer ho jayega🤣🤣🤣🤣

Aur parso chronic constipation bhi ho sakta hain!! 😀

Originally posted by: ninaMAXWELL08

So there were no forced hugs where he actually pushed her away saying no I can't do it? No manipulation in his drunk state where she is saying imagine roshnai in me? So I guess they just made it "his" drunken mistake in that show after the backlash of Hindi audiences calling arshi a rapist. Lol still it will always be wrong to sleep with him when he was not even in his senses.

But Bengali version mai already there are so many changes

Yhn toh explicitly dikhaya hai Arshi ko Ani ka rape karte hue with malign intent of her. Glad they put the difference in Bengali version

It itself shows their Arshi didi kitni neech level ki ghatiya aurat banai hai inhone

Or ITV mai inhe ye difference toh create karna impt hi tha yar...they can't show Ani willingly gave in to Arshi in drunk state also. ITV ka ML hai toh use Jhanak ke liye hi dikhana hoga...by showing Arshi raping Ani, no one hated Ani and majority of viewers are at Ani's side

By this way Leena fulfilled her purpose of bringing Anishit baby also meanwhile no one hated her ML also

Originally posted by: Brishali

The idea of rape disgusted me so much that I couldn't see the hindi version when the scene played out. I had seen certain clippings but not the scene in its entirety. But here the actor enacting the role of arshi didnt have have to force the ML to sleep with her. She also didnt stoop low enough to ask him to imagine the FL in her. The person collapsed on the bed and she was like the FL is also already dead, she will not return so I love you a lot and I want you to love only me. She was likeable in her approach. She said all of these genuinely without any malice or evil intent. She embraces him and then the ML also willingly embraces her back. Although he was not in his sound mind, never for once was it even shown that he imagined roshnai instead Of Garima. The entire scene has thus been changed. There was no non consensual element present in the entire scene. After watching it one can never bring oneself to hate the character of Garima in this series. This is the extent to which the character has been whitewashed.

They tried to be extra smart in Jhanak and still heavily paying for it...so they twisted the narrative in Roshnai so that they can actually make Aranyak guilty of his drunken mistake...and Garima can be put between leads with lesser hatred, for as long as possible..

Originally posted by: Brishali

The idea of rape disgusted me so much that I couldn't see the hindi version when the scene played out. I had seen certain clippings but not the scene in its entirety. But here the actor enacting the role of arshi didnt have have to force the ML to sleep with her. She also didnt stoop low enough to ask him to imagine the FL in her. The person collapsed on the bed and she was like the FL is also already dead, she will not return so I love you a lot and I want you to love only me. She was likeable in her approach. She said all of these genuinely without any malice or evil intent. She embraces him and then the ML also willingly embraces her back. Although he was not in his sound mind, never for once was it even shown that he imagined roshnai instead Of Garima. The entire scene has thus been changed. There was no non consensual element present in the entire scene. After watching it one can never bring oneself to hate the character of Garima in this series. This is the extent to which the character has been whitewashed.

Oh toh they ruined the ML character in Bengali version

Originally posted by: Shalinim153

But Bengali version mai already there are so many changes

Yhn toh explicitly dikhaya hai Arshi ko Ani ka rape karte hue with malign intent of her. Glad they put the difference in Bengali version

It itself shows their Arshi didi kitni neech level ki ghatiya aurat banai hai inhone

Or ITV mai inhe ye difference toh create karna impt hi tha yar...they can't show Ani willingly gave in to Arshi in drunk state also. ITV ka ML hai toh use Jhanak ke liye hi dikhana hoga...by showing Arshi raping Ani, no one hated Ani and majority of viewers are at Ani's side

By this way Leena fulfilled her purpose of bringing Anishit baby also meanwhile no one hated her ML also

But look at the cheap mindset of this PH yaar. They know they can't get away with making ML willingly sleeping with PL on itv, channel hi inko latt mar deta .....but they fulfilled their disgusting fantasy in Bengali version. Ani ko hamesha se hi 2 timer dikhana chahti thi ghatiya aurat but itv didnt let her toh Bengali version main dikha diya. Thank God this shit is ending soon. Vaise bhi next gen ki casting chal rahi hai according to some yt channels jaldi krushi ko chutkara milega in perverts se. So looks like seedha generation leap hi hoga isliye 4 year leap cancel Kar diya.

And I'm already feeling bad for the ML of next generation. Pata nahi kitne ghatiya kaam karvayegi usse yeh ghatiya aurat.

Originally posted by: Brishali

The idea of rape disgusted me so much that I couldn't see the hindi version when the scene played out. I had seen certain clippings but not the scene in its entirety. But here the actor enacting the role of arshi didnt have have to force the ML to sleep with her. She also didnt stoop low enough to ask him to imagine the FL in her. The person collapsed on the bed and she was like the FL is also already dead, she will not return so I love you a lot and I want you to love only me. She was likeable in her approach. She said all of these genuinely without any malice or evil intent. She embraces him and then the ML also willingly embraces her back. Although he was not in his sound mind, never for once was it even shown that he imagined roshnai instead Of Garima. The entire scene has thus been changed. There was no non consensual element present in the entire scene. After watching it one can never bring oneself to hate the character of Garima in this series. This is the extent to which the character has been whitewashed.

Am pretty sure Leena intended to do the same with the Jhanak version too but her fear of the itv audience in respect of how they are pristinely protective of the lead romance stopped her from trying this stunt…For Leena to sell an aberration of the man isn’t difficult in the regional set up as the specific audience is more amenable to accepting that men move on or that physical needs triumph emotional ones but Leena estimated that it would be difficult to sell it in the itv context…We had seen this similar thing at the wedding ceremony when the sindoor and saptapadi wasn’t completed for Anishit during Aag… again it was intentional as there was just no chance the audience would have stayed on

It is the hope that Runak exists in sone form that a part of the audience stays on for….but am firmly of the opinion Leena has no intention to fulfill that given her perversion and she will kill any feeble hopes in the times to come if nothing out of spite when the axing call comes

Originally posted by: Shalinim153

Oh toh they ruined the ML character in Bengali version

Yes they did......that was their real intension with krushal too but darr gayi hindi audiences se toh Bengali audiences ka dimaag kharab kar rahi hai batameez aurat .

Ok...I just saw the r*pe scene in Roshnai...honestly...I still felt it to be disgusting...it may be due to Jhanak experience...the scene was played down and as I mentioned yesterday, they tried to keep Garima less active in this scene compared to Arshi...she was also having monologues that you cannot leave me, you are tied to me now...In Jhanak, Ani was at least able to talk...here its worse! ML could not even talk when Garima initiated the act! Garima put his hand around her, lied on his chest and had the above monologue...and to make the act as a drunken mistake of ML, they showed that ML returned the embrace...still...THIS IS NON CONSENSUAL S*X as ML is not even being able to speak! Leena will be able to avoid the massive backlash for this scene in case of Roshnai unlike Jhanak, mainly due to removal of Arshi's filthy dialogues and hand gestures shown in Jhanak...but once you have seen the scene in Jhanak, you wont be able to unsee the perspective, no matter how diluted it seems..