Mannat Har Khushi Paane Ki: Episode Discussion Thread - 8 - Page 111

Finally watched the episode and it was heartbreaking in so many ways.

Because of Harneet Mannat agreed to go to Delhi.

TBH I really loved this scene because it was really heartbreaking to see ManVik at this stage.

They both are right at their places neither is wrong but circumstances are not in favour.

Vikrant is in delusion that his family is right because of that other chain presented by Raveena. Even Shalini is also not helping in this matter by maintaining her stance that she doesn’t remember anything when he asked her.

Vikrant was damn sure that Mannat will fight but she chose to leave. Such a sweetheart he is! He wanted her to stay but wants her to leave also and he can’t see her in jail. It was damn evident that Shruti is just an excuse he is using against Mannat in fact he can’t see her suffering.

He returned that anklet to her. I just loved their conversation here it was really heart wrenching.

Vikrant told her to take care of herself because he will be far from her. Mannat said that when he told her that he is not her BDB anymore,she felt sad but now she can see his true face behind the mask💔

Seriously this scene made me cry yaar! Both are suffering without any of their fault. They are paying price for someone else’s crime. Mannat girl he is not like this. He is still your BDB it’s just right now he is blinded by his family values and love for them.

Why can’t this Gagan stay sober all the time? He always speaks correct things and today I loved him for saying ARS was wrong to send Mannat jail because it will look bad on their part.

Malla,Neetu, Ronny and other clowns no comments. They are making me sick.

Seriously what was the use of kidnapping Adi when Shalini was doing exactly what they wanted?

Shalini came to Mannat for help.

ARS told Shalini to come to press conference and tell that Derek is the actual culprit and she will talk with Bobby and nothing will happen to her brother. God! They are literally dragging this.

Vikrant was so sad with all the happenings. His face was worth watching when Neetu said that good Mannat is leaving. Poor kiddo! Neetu liked that how he stood for his family and he told her that he is doing his duty being a son of this Family. Only you should’ve known the truth Kiddo! This gonna shatter you into pieces when you will find the truth. The Same family where you don’t belong and you are fighting for all the wrong people and for wrong reasons 💔

Everybody was trying to cheer up Vikrant because he was sad. They all danced and having celebration. TBH this scene made me sick. No offence to my kiddo but other people are really disgusting. Knowing truth but still supporting a culprit is really sad.

There was a new person looks like she is Punnu and Vikrant’s sister. Let’s see what this new entry brings to this drama.

Today for me star of the episodes are Adnan and Ayesha. They both were brilliant throughout the episode. I loved their police station scenes. It was really heart wrenching to see ManVik like this. Kudos to Adnan and Ayesha for bringing that angst so beautifully ❤️🧿

P.S. This is completely my POV about this track and Vikrant’s stance regarding this and the effect of it on ManVik. No offence to anyone.

For me Vikrant is completely right at his place so is Mannat. They both are on the opposite sides fighting for the right reasons like they believe. For Vikrant his family is right because that chain doesn’t belong to Bobby unless and until truth comes out regarding it which I highly doubt that Neetu will say ,for obvious reasons.

For Mannat why he is not believing her when he himself said that I will be with you always? He is not her BDB anymore.

Like I said in one of post ManVik they do have respect,trust in their relationship but not love. For Vikrant yes he likes her but what next? Every relationship has its ups and downs and that’s the beauty of it because that way your relationship strengthens over time and it survives the storm which life throws at random time. Right now both of their trust on each other is shaken. It will take time to regain that trust specially Mannat. When Bobby’s truth comes out it gonna break Vikrant because he believed his family over Mannat when he clearly told her that he will always believe her. He have to earn her trust again and prove that he is indeed BDB of her. I think this track is heading that way only. For Mannat to see him beyond that BDB image and Vikrant’s journey of unwavering trust on Mannat and to become BDB of her life. Like it was established earlier that he is her saviour against ARS/Sonia.

Originally posted by: Rdigest

Bold, mujhe yeh police station Mein aur dance Mein , dono scene Mein laga.

celebrating and dancing if he thinks Bobby is innocent was way too insensitive considering a girl was raped in their restaurant and he, his family just threatened another girl into silence

There is PC insults coming up since obviously Shalini and her brother will back stab 'the FL'

Somehow I don't mind the police station scene... it was fine...

In all honesty don't we all want Mannat to move away... she is adamant and is not ready to listen... he can't help as believes in his version of truth... all he can do is keep her away from jail but I feel he also understands that his family won't leave Mannat so easily if she keeps on getting into trouble with them...

That's the crux of the proposal... Keep away but be safe!!!

I liked it for another aspect...

he doesn't even have to bail her... but he does coz he can't see her in jail (his words) and is tired of this to and from between his family and her (again... his words)

So he is throwing her out of Mezbani... but also offering another opportunity...

It's not like he has disowned her... there's some BKB element lurking around.

I for one don't want Mannat to take up his offer.... rather not even go to Delhi... but ofcourse stay away from these horrible people... and that includes Malla.

Hopefully Mannat will now be wary of Malla too.

Wanted to write this yesterday...

Among all the people who are lying... only Ronnie Neetu are somewhat justified.... for them it's their son... who they love so much...

For Raveena it's absolutely despicable to hide a criminal who pounces upon other girls of his daughters age.... but she might be more worried about her social status and name in the society...

For ARS it's not mezbani anymore... though she pretends it is... it's more of an ego issue of Mannat confronting her. And she ofcourse neither bothers about Derek or Shalini.

In ranking the evilness... Raveena is the lowest followed by ARS.

Originally posted by: SunflowerField

I think vikrant has an immature side to him, like he seems blinded by the fact the you have to stand up for your family and keep blood ties intact in all tough situations. Fair enough that he wanted to call police during the chain incident but was very quickly satisfied with raveena's production of the second chain. Now come on, don't we all have more than one similar items of jewellery? He was looking at the blood stained chain very carefully through the plastic bag when others were fighting but then quickly dropped the idea of further investigation. His security measures at mezbani are non existant and still no change in policy after a serious incident apart from cab service. He needs to grow up a little if he is going to sustain a business safely and survive in such a toxic family.

Agree with above - Bold At that point it would have still been very valid for Vikrant (and Mannat ) to have the blood stained chain forensically analysed by the Police to rule out Bobby/Derek depending on whose side you’re on and to close the story! Chain as evidence is now redundant……

Chehra and mukhota apply even for Malla.

I am so disappointed with the way she is using all Mannat's vulnerabilities she got to know as her best friend, to manipulate around Mannat.

Enough of Malla.

I want Mannat to call her 'Ms Mallika Raisingh'. Just like Vikrant got a mild shock at Mannat's strong words, because it is the first time she has been so assertive towards him. Till the time he walked into he PS, she thought he will definitely come, because he trusts her.

I want Malla to get a shock when Mannat disowns her as her best friend or soul sister.

Originally posted by: scarlett22

Chehra and mukhota apply even for Malla.

I am so disappointed with the way she is using all Mannat's vulnerabilities she got to know as her best friend, to manipulate around Mannat.

Enough of Malla.

I want Mannat to call her 'Ms Mallika Raisingh'. Just like Vikrant got a mild shock at Mannat's strong words, because it is the first time she has been so assertive towards him. Till the time he walked into he PS, she thought he will definitely come, because he trusts her.

I want Malla to get a shock when Mannat disowns her as her best friend or soul sister.

I don't think malla cares, she is a very different person now. Their friendship initially is such an eyewash. Girl is not even sympathetic to the fact that her best friends mom is in coma

Originally posted by: WittyKittyVixxy

I finally believe that the pen is stronger than the sword. Thank you 🙏🏻.

I watched the episode as usual taking screenshots and fuming at Vikrant and Ronnie today.

It took your post to make me truly feel differently.

I came here to write my thoughts just now, but now I can’t think straight.

Mera weekend gaya now. You watch Lost to cope, I’ll go see CID to see some justice being served. Alvida.

I am so busy with the stock markets going haywire.. that my mind cannot focus on any show thankfully ..
Mannat is not a light show .. and we are mostly worried about Mannat’s safety

Today Harneet did the right thing , mature thing by making Vikrant bail Mannat out . Otherwise Mannat would have come out like Shalini or Derek in this .,

I hope vikrant heard this . If Harneet had said it loudly . We can’t risk what happened to Shalini to happen with you . These are big and powerful people. It’s better to be safe than sorry .
if Shalini is not keen to pursue the matter let us let it be abd escape

Originally posted by: nutmeg7

Yep. I am not sure why people feel this was supposed to be a different show. But to be honest, the treatment of the show is very outdated.

Originally posted by: Uma85

Just watched the episode.. It was very disturbing to watch them dance and celebrate while Mannat , Shalini , Derek are broken and suffering in silence. It sends a very problematic message. Even worse, Viks' speech to Shalini in the hospital about being like her "big brother" came off as hollow with these scenes 😔. It felt like the writers want to score emotional points in the moment, only to shock the audience later with a betrayal—but at the cost of authenticity and empathy. If the writers are planning to tamper Viks , they shouldn’t be giving him such lofty, protective dialogues. It undermines the gravity of the trauma the show is portraying and insults the viewer’s intelligence. Emotional consistency needs to be balanced atleast in sensitive tracks like this 😪

Exactly Vikrant is coming across as the weakest loser .. a bad employer who has failed Shalini , Derek and Mannat .. and right now enjoying the party .. it is better if Mezbaani closes down for good after the scandal