Jhanak Written Update And Episode Discussion thread No 94. - Page 125

Originally posted by: Dibya_C

I think the amar prem thing was true for J until Ani convinced her that he doesn't have rishta with Arshi...uske baad se, no matter what she told (as she is a dogli!), she started developing certain expectations from her love...so amar prem ceases to exist from that point..

.. .ab Ani boy ka situation change ho gaya hai! He is now in amar prem zone! 😄 Baas ye dekhna hai Vihaan ko Jhanno se pyar ho gaya hai ye pata chalne ke baad kitne dino tak pyaar ko amar category me rakh pata hai! 😜😜

Yeh pata chalne ke baad kuch change nahi hone wala. Once he'll know ki vihaan actually loves her .....toh bas aise hi 2 3 din royega phir writers will make him busy with didi ki gulami. Jab jhanno ki shadi accept kar li hai toh pyaar kyu nahi karega? He'll be jealous but will keep his jealousy to himself only .....like he did in the past with Rahul and AK lol. AK ke sath bhi accept kar hi liya tha jhanno ko ....until madam came at his door about her pregnancy/tumor reports. Only difference will be that this time jhanno will also say ki yeah I'm too falling for vihaan babu, u pls focus on your pregnant wife.

OMG WHAT A TWIST , HUM TOH BILKUL SHOCK HI HO GAYE. AISA KUCH PEHLE KABHI DEKHA HI NAHI. WOWWWWWW

Originally posted by: ninaMAXWELL08

Yeh pata chalne ke baad kuch change nahi hone wala. Once he'll know ki vihaan actually loves her .....toh bas aise hi 2 3 din royega phir writers will make him busy with didi ki gulami. Jab jhanno ki shadi accept kar li hai toh pyaar kyu nahi karega? He'll be jealous but will keep his jealousy to himself only .....like he did in the past with Rahul and AK lol. AK ke sath bhi accept kar hi liya tha jhanno ko ....until madam came at his door about her pregnancy/tumor reports. Only difference will be that this time jhanno will also say ki yeah I'm too falling for vihaan babu, u pls focus on your pregnant wife.

OMG WHAT A TWIST , HUM TOH BILKUL SHOCK HI HO GAYE. AISA KUCH PEHLE KABHI DEKHA HI NAHI. WOWWWWWW

If Jhanak married someone else his reaction would have had different......here vihan is his best friend..he has decent family.

foreign returned doctor. so he is like ok...and he will wish for Jhanak vihan ka Kushal jindagi.

Originally posted by: AreYaar

@bold: This actually jives more with how Leena always shows the ML-PL equation....ki it was a "long term relationship" toh under the guise of that, we must swallow this portrayal that ML will never question PL trying to cling to him even in a dead rishta or showing up with a pregnancy claim....cuz apparently ML is eternally weighed down by guilt of sharing a past with PL.....only for such situations, that is.....warna otherwise ML will also not stop asserting the fact that his truth is that he only loves the FL so that is why he will always keep worrying for her

Leena has made it extra dirty and uglier with the setup of this Anishi equation also ki she never showed Ani reflecting on what kind of "live in" he had going with Arshi ki itne saalon mein koi physical relationship bhi nahin hua and not even when they started living in the same room together without shaadi.....kis khushi mein bed share kar rahe the phir? .....Yeh kaisa ajeeb selective affection hai where otherwise he supposedly feels so much obligation to care for Arshi, is ok with doing casual touches like holding her hand or cupping her face....but usse aage kabhi kuch nahin karna tha? Whole life platonic bedmates banke jeena tha while always mooning after Jhanak mann se?

This is the reason why they are probably not showing Ani reflecting on anything cuz he was anyways sharing a room with Arshi and they were being perceived as living like husband-wife....he feels the guilt of carrying on living with Arshi even till that point and probably presumes ki ek weak drunk moment mein Jhanak ko imagine kar raha tha but room mein Arshi thi toh sab ho gaya....he is willing to consider himself as the weaker one but never consider that Arshi could take advantage of him....lol cuz again, Leena ne setup hi aise rakha hai ki Ani is shown jumping to take Arshi ki zimmedaari always so Didi supposedly toh bas usi wajah se ruki rehti hai Ani ki life mein....lol

AY apne meri muh ki baat cheeni.. 😂😂

Exactly!! This nonsense of Shaadi hui par nahin hui.. Ek room main the bhi aur nahin bhi.. Lekin haan zimmedaari toh poori… itni ki aadmi dab jaaye uske tale!! And if indeed they were reaching out to each other for solace toh itni gatiya dialogues kyun Arshi ko…why the fear in showing that the act as one done by a person seeking solace in a weak moment? But now suddenly… the ML is all about drama about his wife’s needs… itni understanding th/hain dono main phir bhi PL had to ask ML to imagine the FL in her… kyun ki… Leena knew that under any other premise the serial will not sell similar to why they kept the live in of Arshi Ani as cloaked as Shaadi but Jo complete nahin hui.. Ghar main ek Lawyer tha , Shristi jaisi tedi buddhi thi, par unko itne mahine main Shaadi complete karni ki soch bhi nahin aayi Aur toh aur, jab Ani looked to start conjugal life, they showed Arshi rejecting it… and never pursuing the matter since then even when their relationship improved and she was livid with Ani’s actions Wow but that same woman needed to use coercion cos anything else couldn’t sell… So do what you want and say it like you want

Originally posted by: MMR2810

If Jhanak married someone else his reaction would have had different......here vihan his best friend...so he is like ok...and he will wish for Jhanak vihan ka Kushal jindagi.

Runak ki problem yehi hai...they do not find it weird that they want khushal zindagi for each other and still man hi man expect that the other one only loves him/her..

Originally posted by: sanfan

Waise is story deserves no discussion at the stage it is 😂😂 but since a lot of this vs that character discussion happened I just interjected in one of the posts to put forth my view about the expedient nature of where we are in this stupid tale

On to the point of Amar Prem… first of all Amar prem is devoid of romantic attachment… atleast that is what usually a platonic relationship is about… Jhanak is nowhere close to that stage of seeing her relationship as Amar Prem. even though she described it as such; Ani on the other hand never claimed he was looking for Amar Prem.. he wanted to be part of her life in every which way and he did his best imv and now he has done the next best thing in the circumstance is accept the inevitable ( even though it may have something to do with Vihaan in love with dead wife Avni) is to look out for her wellbeing… whether that changes ahead I have no idea…

See… I won’t hee haw over what is the exact thing that bothers Jhanak… Leena itni seedhi hoti toh Kya hi baat thi…If it was only the lie according to her that was bothering her and you guys all buy it good for you. For me, this is a Jhanak who is being confronted with her definition of Amar Prem which is turning hollow..that Ani shared a physical relationship with Arshi is beyond her belief and she recognises that Ani still wants her ( J) and which is the reason she was keen to make sure he didn’t know that she was not married… this is her attempt to put distance between the two as any purposeful relationship now has no meaning beck to the post Kashmir phase but with a big difference where she thinks that Ani has strong feelings for her but this mountain exists in the form of a baby that makes everything moot!! Leena does not want to show Jhanak’s disappointment at how this has all turned out by not focusing on her own actions in pushing away Ani… I don’t know if that phase will ever come or as is the trend of acting holier than thou will persist!!

Rekhaji, I think finally J has reached that stage where she doesn't believe that Ani loves her! Didi ki paapi pet has made her believe so...which we expected to happen in her operation track, is happening now...

Originally posted by: Dibya_C

Rekhaji, I think finally J has reached that stage where she doesn't believe that Ani loves her! Didi ki paapi pet has made her believe so...which we expected to happen in her operation track, is happening now...

Dibya… it doesn’t matter anymore…

For me this expediency in the tale has reached its nadir.

Keeping a character from exploring the feelings may work in this medium but it completely kills the beauty of a concept… whatever it be. I would definitely advise reading up about the philosophical aspect of platonic relationship ( drawing from Plato where the etymology stems from) No point in bandying words like Amar Prem when there is no intention to actually explore the concept and keep it rooted to 2 minute noodle meetings. The charm is lost and it won’t come back.

Originally posted by: Dibya_C

Rekhaji, I think finally J has reached that stage where she doesn't believe that Ani loves her! Didi ki paapi pet has made her believe so...which we expected to happen in her operation track, is happening now...

Yes i am also thinking so that in this time Jhanak will not forgive or beleive of his love.like in Jhanak tumar operation track

cleared misunderstanding of ani something like this can happens,if arshi miscarriage will happen still then jhank will not believe. this time makers have to clean chit of ani character i think so but everything depends on makers.

Originally posted by: Dibya_C

Runak ki problem yehi hai...they do not find it weird that they want khushal zindagi for each other and still man hi man expect that the other one only loves him/her..

According to Ani 's logic his heart divided into two parts....one psrt belongs to J and other one belongs to arshi, his family and friends.

Originally posted by: sanfan

AY apne meri muh ki baat cheeni.. 😂😂

Exactly!! This nonsense of Shaadi hui par nahin hui.. Ek room main the bhi aur nahin bhi.. Lekin haan zimmedaari toh poori… itni ki aadmi dab jaaye uske tale!! And if indeed they were reaching out to each other for solace toh itni gatiya dialogues kyun Arshi ko…why the fear in showing that the act as one done by a person seeking solace in a weak moment? But now suddenly… the ML is all about drama about his wife’s needs… itni understanding th/hain dono main phir bhi PL had to ask ML to imagine the FL in her… kyun ki… Leena knew that under any other premise the serial will not sell similar to why they kept the live in of Arshi Ani as cloaked as Shaadi but Jo complete nahin hui.. Ghar main ek Lawyer tha , Shristi jaisi tedi buddhi thi, par unko itne mahine main Shaadi complete karni ki soch bhi nahin aayi Aur toh aur, jab Ani looked to start conjugal life, they showed Arshi rejecting it… and never pursuing the matter since then even when their relationship improved and she was livid with Ani’s actions Wow but that same woman needed to use coercion cos anything else couldn’t sell… So do what you want and say it like you want

Rekha ji, Leena ne jo waahiyaat khichdi banaayi hai is Anishi ke bina shaadi waale live-in ki, anyone can see this was all about Leena being too cowardly to tell it like it is and hiding behind cheap semantics and technicalities....lol

She has never shown Anishi equation with any depth that anyone will buy this "seeking solace in weak moment" funda....lol Arshi has only been screaming at Ani constantly since the story started....she has always been more consumed by her insecurity of Jhanak than any so called love for Ani....we are just constantly shown her mouthing big dialogues about how she keeps hanging on to Ani cuz she loves him but it never manifests in the story....all sounds empty and unconvincing....especially when everything has unfolded in front of her eyes and she very well knows Ani has never even shown her even 0.1% of the passion and intensity he openly shows for Jhanak....uske baad bhi her hanging around claiming ki she wants Ani ka thoda sa pyar kaise bhi blah blah while also simultaneously taunting him that he loves Jhanak, he loves both women......lol it's just an exercise in cheap gaslighting cuz yehi Leena ka standard hai.

She refuses to let there be any consistent clarification about Anishi ka equation cuz she just wants to keep pulling levers to portray Ani as some kind of two-timer for the sake of "drama.....even when Ani quite definitively clarified that he only loves Jhanak, Leena still makes him backtrack and keep giving these guilt-ridden obligatory fake ILUs to Arshi to pacify her.....lol.....that's how little she thinks of the man's integrity in this story....she fully expects people to be cool with an Ani who can say ILU to anyone weighed down in guilt ....this so called "guilt" is her all purpose card to portray any kind of nonsense

Originally posted by: sanfan

Dibya… it doesn’t matter anymore…

For me this expediency in the tale has reached its nadir.

Keeping a character from exploring the feelings may work in this medium but it completely kills the beauty of a concept… whatever it be. I would definitely advise reading up about the philosophical aspect of platonic relationship ( drawing from Plato where the etymology stems from) No point in bandying words like Amar Prem when there is no intention to actually explore the concept and keep it rooted to 2 minute noodle meetings. The charm is lost and it won’t come back.

I know...In fact I am giving all these gyaan-filled dialogues without watching the episodes!! 😜😜