Commonsense and Amar

How can Amar gush over Sindura when

1] It was she who accused him of theft , and had him beaten by goons , and he knew that he had not done the theft and that the bracelet had not flown in his pocket with wings ?

2] He almost got shot while delivering a file for her ?

3] He was found buried alive in the yard of her bungalow where she had met him ?

4] When she had agreed to pay him a ridiculously large sum.....10 000 rupees for a small errand and her men had fed him like a guest on a table ? Which job is like this ?

So Amar cannot figure this out coz he is a simple Banaras guy .....that is the explanation ?? Meaning , all rustic Banarasi people lack commonsense ? What does education have to do with simple common sense ? An uneducated person can be very practical in simple common sense matters ......why dont the creatives look at the bhaiyyas sitting with wicker baskets and selling vegetables and fruits in a market and calculating sharply their accounts in their minds and conning educated housewives by being excellent businessmen ?

Look at all the Banarasi panwallahs and vegetable vendors.....will they like having such little common sense projected as a Banarasi trait ?

I don't think he will believe it without some explanation. He doesn't understand why Sin would want to kill him yet.

Honestly I have never found Amar particularly bright. Vidya had common sense despite being uneducated, but this Amar has nothing. He's sweet, brave, and loving and has a lot of good qualities, but he's dumb as rocks to be perfectly blunt.

This doesnt even require brains rainabow....any simpleton wud get an uneasy feeling about a woman like Sindura and such a chain of events !

i bet a monkey is smarter than amar 😆

yes u have made a really good point! I mean he never forgave Divz for calling him a thief straight away!
AND Sindoora had the nerve to beat him up as well- yet vo aakhon mein patti band kar ghoom raha hai
when it comes to Sindoori JI! 😛 It does frustrate me to say the least!

👏 👏 Very well said Roshan..to the point 👏
This is the fault of lousy script, the creatives doesnt knw wat to do..they cannot create any good character in this serial...a real strong one...all these charaters keeps on changing their stances, their views, their principals..kahin bhi kuch bhi kaise bhi kya kya se dikhaa dete hain...
Amar's friend kartar is gone now..he told Amar tht why Sindoora wants to kill him..and our banarasi bhaiyaa Amar babua was in tension..and today he is blindly supporting her killer...wat a crap..?..ganwaar insaan..
I think all the characters and the creatives team need psychatrist.. 😆

Originally posted by: koolsadhu1000

How can Amar gush over Sindura when

1] It was she who accused him of theft , and had him beaten by goons , and he knew that he had not done the theft and that the bracelet had not flown in his pocket with wings ?

2] He almost got shot while delivering a file for her ?

3] He was found buried alive in the yard of her bungalow where she had met him ?

4] When she had agreed to pay him a ridiculously large sum.....10 000 rupees for a small errand and her men had fed him like a guest on a table ? Which job is like this ?

So Amar cannot figure this out coz he is a simple Banaras guy .....that is the explanation ?? Meaning , all rustic Banarasi people lack commonsense ? What does education have to do with simple common sense ? An uneducated person can be very practical in simple common sense matters ......why dont the creatives look at the bhaiyyas sitting with wicker baskets and selling vegetables and fruits in a market and calculating sharply their accounts in their minds and conning educated housewives by being excellent businessmen ?

Look at all the Banarasi panwallahs and vegetable vendors.....will they like having such little common sense projected as a Banarasi trait ?

yup!! actually u know what, all the sense and intelligence is ONLY in one and only Sindoora, rest all are the dumbest people around. it seems even the audience for this serial is assumed to be dumb !!

And this supposed to be our hero ??? Someone lacking common sense is supposed to be a hero ?

I am disappointed with the turn this show seems to be taking. Basically we are right back at square one: Amar worshipping Sin like a goddess for no apparent reason, and not believing Divya. Divya doesn't even believe herself. How could it have been a nightmare? Sin tried to remove her oxygen mask. Wasn't she awake at that point?

They basically started this story all over again. It is almost exactly as it was a year ago when Vidya first found out that Sin was trying to kill Sagar. What was the point of the leap and changing the characters if the story is just going to be the same? What a waste of time. I was hoping that this time around, Divya and Amar would come together against Sin. At least I hope that is what happens.

So far, the only character in the show who has proven to have any intelligence is Sindoora. Just like every other serial, it's always the villain who has the brains. The rest of the family is composed of a bunch of morons who only ever win due to a combination of threatening god and blind luck. Enough! I want to see Divya the way she was in the beginning of the show...not the little pipsqueak she has become. And as for Amar, he better get his memory back fast. I can't tolerate all that SINDOORA IS GOD nonsense again.

Can't agree more rainabow . In fact today only , in another post i said that they r showing us the same old wine in a new bottle bas .
Just look at it . The hero ....forget being brainy or intelligent , doesn't seem to have even basic common sense or the ability to put two and two together . Why , even his sidekick sardar friend had more brains than him.
The heroine ....with all her abroad education and law degree has to this point shown no brains whatsoever in trying to solve some intricate mysterious instincts she feels ....or guiding her simpleton boyfriend on the rite path . Besides the childish squabbles in Banaras that supposedly denoted her spunk , nothing ! She remained silent when Sindura fired her so much asking her wat haq she had , she went in shock when Amar was falsely accused , she believes Amar readily when he tells her Sindura is good and doesnt think independently , or try to ask Rajeev what prompted him to do it.....Rajeev , who tried to constantly stop her marraige to Samrat .
Is BMTD about two goats being slaughtered at the altar in each birth ? How many episodes have they shown Sindura winning ? And will they wrap up the win in two weeks only ? Last time it was ....just two weeks Sagar fites and dies !