Jhanak Written Update And Episode Discussion thread No 85. - Page 60

Originally posted by: MayaFruitbae

Thanks for the tag Sowmya.

I have no idea of the full discussion here, as I was following the notification from Sowmya.

And I had said it before too.... There is no point in discussing the stone age things of Aniruddh did this, he should have done this, that..

Because its all done and dusted.

And all these episodes were discussed with intense when it was aired.

So its very boring to write same stuffs again and again, When the breaking news is Shristi is Jhanak's maa.. 👏👏👏👏

Regarding aag series this is my part :

May be ....its left open for viewers ...some can believe he did trust her and other can think opposite.

In the bedroom monologue after she left , he had a part saying its so wrong to even think that Jhanak can do something like this...

Also last when Shristi was exposed they added agar ..... In his monologue

And with Bodomaa he said she could have trusted me and waited ....

The makers have also shown his anxiety , nervousness , etc when he knew police took her and that trio conversation muted at the police station is not exposed till now.

Until and unless they show it crystal clear viewers can think as per their assumption and interpretation..

I would love to believe he did trust her , but he was tied up due to Arshi aag and hospital drama

But some believe he didnt trust her ....

I may be wrong and others may be right , but until the makers show it to us it can vary with viewers decoding it.

And also Jhanak didn't try to understand his position. Why was she not thinking may be he is in a bad state due to family press as Arshi was serious.!!!

That is what makers have done and they can also anytime twist his character by disclosing the muted conversation if they need to show leads together....but since they are getting the desired trp with this seperation track....less expectations on them being together...

Back to modern age :

From mein tumse pyar nahi karti to mein kamzor pad jaunga , I can feel him. He is not faking it. He is being honest here. He is depressed, lonely, in a state of not wanting to live. I can understand his emotions so well. But his words had to be more clear.

Arshi, can u help me as a friend, I am losing it, I am feeling lonely .. That would have been more apt.

But the makers here also played it well... They can change the track and viewers can decode it either as friend or he being selfish and using her, same as his words...

Why Arshi ??? He has maa. She may be ignorant, but still she is his maa, go to her, tell her, I am broken, I need your support, warmth and affection as a maa..she is maa after alll ( this would hav ebeen a good redemption for Tanuja and writer could show us the maa - beta relation)

Ok forget Tanuja, he has Bodomaa, Choton , why not reach out to them. They know his pain and love for Jhanak, they have seen him broken too..

Why why Arshi???

This will continue whenever female lead or parallel needs to be uplifted Anirudh will be used in a bad way...

Tagging those in the loop.

Hey! I completely get your pov...

I was referring to Aag and Mumbai track again because so many people seem to think that's some GREAT CHARACTER DEGRADATION of Aniruddh's character, while I don't think so at all...

I very strongly feel he was completely justified during that time and his journey was quite meaningful up until his recent worst dialogues....

If I felt they are trying to portray Ani as a TWO-TIMER like everybody says since MUMBAI Track itself, I would've quit the show long back...

Now, people are comparing Mumbai track and his recent abrupt flip which has the worst dialogues ever by him in the show, which makes it even more unfathomable to me..

Kamzor pad raha hu? Like, he didn't spout ANYTHING like that during the WHOLE Mumbai track...

Baaki I still believe there's a reason behind his nonsense dialogues, and the makers will not degrade their own ML that abruptly...

Originally posted by: sowmya2407

Hey! I completely get your pov...

I was referring to Aag and Mumbai track again because so many people seem to think that's some GREAT CHARACTER DEGRADATION of Aniruddh's character, while I don't think so at all...

I very strongly feel he was completely justified during that time and his journey was quite meaningful up until his recent worst dialogues....

If I felt they are trying to portray Ani as a TWO-TIMER like everybody says since MUMBAI Track itself, I would've quit the show long back...

Now, people are comparing Mumbai track and his recent abrupt flip which has the worst dialogues ever by him in the show, which makes it even more unfathomable to me..

Kamzor pad raha hu? Like, he didn't spout ANYTHING like that during the WHOLE Mumbai track...

Baaki I still believe there's a reason behind his nonsense dialogues, and the makers will not degrade their own ML that abruptly...

There will always be two camps on the aag track and I understand the perspectives of both camps…😃

My only grouse in the aag track was the intentional alienation of Jhanak by Ani… which was unAni like…I understood that the track had one aim to separate the two but I wish they had been more careful in its execution. The only way Jhanak would have left BH was if Ani Arshi married or something drastic like a loss of trust occured, the latter happened.. I wish it had been circumstantially achieved rather than as an intentional thing. Maya said he was tied up… I think fair enough as one can’t be in two places. I just wish the execution showed him as that and not purposefully mouthing those agar dialogues 😂😂 Jhanak would have been equally upset at his absence so his presence wasn’t required to alienate Jhanak from Ani… She would have still left BH disheartened that Ani chose Arshi over her in her bad time signalling what his priorities are..

As a writer, I would have created a situation where his guilt at how his actions meant collateral damage for Arshi and as a cascading effect on Jhanak made him resolve to stay true to one path, which is what he actually did. He has always been particular that he wants Jhanak safe not necessarily under his care…So those stupid dialogues for who should be punished weren’t necessary at all…His simple preoccupation would have done the trick… Jhanak hoping to meet Ani and Ani unavailable…his monologue doubt about her involvement however silly was still justified ( your mind may not have a filter 😂) but his anger wasn’t justified and then the regret after she left seemed pointless which was again unAnilike

Originally posted by: sowmya2407

Baaki I still believe there's a reason behind his nonsense dialogues, and the makers will not degrade their own ML that abruptly...

I agree these flips are not like something that happened during aag track. There was a lot of build up behind Ani's behavior with j brutally rejecting him telling him that night was not even worth remembering . There was a strong reason behind his u turns.

Now these flips do not make any sense lol arshi don't go mujhe akele dar lagta hai ...total bs . So I hope u r right that there is a strong reason behind anis flips this time

Originally posted by: sowmya2407

Hey! I completely get your pov...

I was referring to Aag and Mumbai track again because so many people seem to think that's some GREAT CHARACTER DEGRADATION of Aniruddh's character, while I don't think so at all...

I very strongly feel he was completely justified during that time and his journey was quite meaningful up until his recent worst dialogues....

If I felt they are trying to portray Ani as a TWO-TIMER like everybody says since MUMBAI Track itself, I would've quit the show long back...

Now, people are comparing Mumbai track and his recent abrupt flip which has the worst dialogues ever by him in the show, which makes it even more unfathomable to me..

Kamzor pad raha hu? Like, he didn't spout ANYTHING like that during the WHOLE Mumbai track...

Baaki I still believe there's a reason behind his nonsense dialogues, and the makers will not degrade their own ML that abruptly...

I get u darling, 🥰

And when we discuss a show its always connects to the previous episodes .

Being the lazy girl to type, and discussing same old track is boring for me.Blame it on me.

And like you said, I always find his actions justified not simply because I love him, because he has always had the reasons behind it , which was convincing for me .

I have stood by him in the haq ki laadai track. I loved him there more, as he stood for his self respect and dignity. A man has the right to stand for him. Specially when he doesn't remember an intimacy, why would he not chose to defend himself. Love is in tact for her, but his self respect and dignity as its own place.

Even today inspite of him saying I may sound selfish, I still feel pity for him and I love him the same. The depressed broken man who needs some one to support him. Had his maa been good to him, things would have been different long before.

There is a lot of difference between Mumbai track and now.

There he was confused of his love for Jhanak. He couldn't differentiate between like and love. Does he love Arshi or like her? Then what is the feeling he has for love . He was questioning himself, but couldn't reach a conclusion.His monologue always gave the clear image of his confused state... And all this confusion had a string reason as Arshi was there and Jhanak kept on pushing him and saying you should not cheat my didi and rejected him or cut him from speaking his mind.

But now he is clear of his feelings, he has declared to the people around him to the girl herself I dont love you, I am giving you freedom.... So his sudden change in telling the same girl, dont leave me is way too much. He didnt tell her to stay as wife or partner or friend , its left open . Let's hope and wait there is a reason behind his words and actions. 🤞🤞

Being the writer Leena aunty is, how she made that beautiful Kashmir night of acceptance to a dirty haaq ki ladai, I dont trust her. And if she is following the Jhol Nupur, then we are doomed.

Thank you for tagging me, Sowmya .

I had forgotten the forum which once I used to live and breath. Thankyou for bringing me back home 💞🥰

Originally posted by: sanfan

I didn’t say the actors should quit.. I was mentioning the barriers in this medium. First of all there are contracts… it’s not easy to quit either and why should they if they are getting a buzz for their work.

I just hope Krushal gets a break in the OTT medium cos let’s accept the tv medium is not fair to male leads at all… tv is for the female actors primarily imv..

Every once in a while a decent male character is written and an actor comes along to do justice but the medium has no intention to do justice to the character…

True, but our show is change in this pattern too. We are part of huge revolution in ITV, which we didnt know when we signed up for this show.. 😄😄🤦‍♀️

Here the female lead is the worst inspite of being the titular character....

But yes, you are right , Rekha . Its a female oriented space, and our being written for our beloved Arshi didi. 😁😁😁😁😁

Originally posted by: sanfan

There will always be two camps on the aag track and I understand the perspectives of both camps…😃

My only grouse in the aag track was the intentional alienation of Jhanak by Ani… which was unAni like…I understood that the track had one aim to separate the two but I wish they had been more careful in its execution. The only way Jhanak would have left BH was if Ani Arshi married or something drastic like a loss of trust occured, the latter happened.. I wish it had been circumstantially achieved rather than as an intentional thing. Maya said he was tied up… I think fair enough as one can’t be in two places. I just wish the execution showed him as that and not purposefully mouthing those agar dialogues 😂😂 Jhanak would have been equally upset at his absence so his presence wasn’t required to alienate Jhanak from Ani… She would have still left BH disheartened that Ani chose Arshi over her in her bad time signalling what his priorities are..

As a writer, I would have created a situation where his guilt at how his actions meant collateral damage for Arshi and as a cascading effect on Jhanak made him resolve to stay true to one path, which is what he actually did. He has always been particular that he wants Jhanak safe not necessarily under his care…So those stupid dialogues for who should be punished weren’t necessary at all…His simple preoccupation would have done the trick… Jhanak hoping to meet Ani and Ani unavailable…his monologue doubt about her involvement however silly was still justified ( your mind may not have a filter 😂) but his anger wasn’t justified and then the regret after she left seemed pointless which was again unAnilike

I completely agree with you... Anirudh always priorities zimmedari...at that point Arshi was the immediate zimmedari...he chose Arshi...he chose the one who till that point was closer and longer existing in his life..but deliberately giving a dead ear to J's situation, in fact to some extent aggravate her difficulties by instigating the police for giving her some punishment was completely unjustified ..more than that, unnecessary..

...Coming to yesterday's Anishit convo...if makers do not give justification for him asking for Arshi's saath, atp it's completely unrealistic...just to use hatred or disgust for Anirudh to generate buzz..which is such a lame way of garnering attention..

Originally posted by: MayaFruitbae

I get u darling, 🥰

And when we discuss a show its always connects to the previous episodes .

Being the lazy girl to type, and discussing same old track is boring for me.Blame it on me.

And like you said, I always find his actions justified not simply because I love him, because has always had the reasons behind it , which was convincing for me .

I have stood by him in the haq ki laadai track. I loved him there more, as he stood for his self respect and dignity. A man has the right to stand for him. Specially when he doesn't remember an intimacy, why would he not chose to defend himself. Love is in tact for her, but his self respect and dignity as its own place.

Even today inspite of him saying I may sound selfish, I still feel pity for him and I love him the same. The depressed broken man who needs some one to support him. Had his maa been good to him, things would have been different long before.

There is a lot of difference between Mumbai track and now.

There he was confused of his love for Jhanak. He couldn't differentiate between like and love. Does he love Arshi or like her? Then what is the feeling he has for love . He was questioning himself, but couldn't reach a conclusion.His monologue always gave the clear image of his confused state... And all this confusion had a string reason as Arshi was there and Jhanak kept on pushing him and saying you should not cheat my didi and rejected him or cut him from speaking his mind.

But now he is clear of his feelings, he has declared to the people around him to the girl herself I dont love you, I am giving you freedom.... So his sudden change in telling the same girl, dont leave me is way too much. He didnt tell her to stay as wife or partner or friend , its left open . Let's hope and wait there is a reason behind his words and actions. 🤞🤞

Being the writer Leena aunty is, how she made that beautiful Kashmir night of acceptance to a dirty haaq ki ladai, I dont trust her. And if she is following the Jhol Nupur, then we are doomed.

Thank you for tagging me, Sowmya .

I had forgotten the forum which once I used to live and breath. Thankyou for bringing me back home 💞🥰

Beautifully penned Maya💓

Yes...then and now are two completely different situations...atp Leena without any valid justification, making Anirudh mouth creepy dialogues is unacceptable..it simply shows her sick mindset about men! Nothing else...

Originally posted by: ninaMAXWELL08

I agree these flips are not like something that happened during aag track. There was a lot of build up behind Ani's behavior with j brutally rejecting him telling him that night was not even worth remembering . There was a strong reason behind his u turns.

Now these flips do not make any sense lol arshi don't go mujhe akele dar lagta hai ...total bs . So I hope u r right that there is a strong reason behind anis flips this time

Akele Darr lagta hai ko main fir bhi masoom dil ka rona samajh k maaf kar sakti hun...but tumhare liye weak ho jata hu!!! No...not happening...no means no...BIG NO🤣🤣

Originally posted by: Dibya_C

Like any other job, actors also look for job satisfaction...and there are many cases where actors quit due to creative differences...

...and Krushal was not at all a famous actor in Bengal...he was mediocre in terms of popularity as a hero in Bengali shows...His major breakthrough is obviously Jhanak...and he owned Anirudh Bose...but the amount of positive recognition due to complexity of the character and Krushal's able portrayal has been already generated...now if makers keep on deteriorating his arc, then it will not add to his popularity...

...at the end of the day, it is upto the individuals working in the sector...if they feel they are not satisfied and have better opportunity at hand, they may switch...or else they may decide to stay....holds true across all sectors..

Ofcourse it depends upon individuals.

Some cant take it so they quit, others take it as their professional . Like how often do we quit our job simply because we are not happy with it. Its a huge risk to gind another for our living!!!

Krushal I find him., very grounded he might stay till the show ends.. If it doesn't show him as father of big kids...

And I feel the character being degraded or butchered doesn't effect an actors career.. In that case actors playing grey characters are bashed and attacked, that doesn't end their career.

And if Krushal was to quit the show, then he should have left it long before with the amount Of X attack he faced both personally and for his character from the start amd which continues even today..

Originally posted by: MayaFruitbae

True, but our show is change in this pattern too. We are part of huge revolution in ITV, which we didnt know when we signed up for this show.. 😄😄🤦‍♀️

Here the female lead is the worst inspite of being the titular character....

But yes, you are right , Rekha . Its a female oriented space, and our being written dir oie beloved Arshi didi. 😁😁😁😁😁

Actually the writer has spent least time in writing the FL character it seems…

Bas do naav pe bola baith jao 😂😂😂 and get going. The so called titular character is flirting from one naav to another from that day to this day and now she got two names apart from Naav 😂😂