General Discussion thread #1 - Page 7

Yaar i feel so stupid now to write such a big post on types of sons

Originally posted by: BeingBlunt

LOL. Mis communication destroyed one of the shows i watched , only to repair it and destroy it again. But i get this thing. This is why i said few days ago that only IPKKND was one show which i think wasnt destroyed or butchered according to my expectations

Nowadays they just show miscommunication only😆 Smone hid smthing nd that other person got to know by some other source.. misunderstanding nd separation🤣 (whole show in one line😆)

Originally posted by: FlauntPessimism

Yaar i feel so stupid now to write such a big post on types of sons

Why? What happened?

Originally posted by: Pete15rogmourey

Why? What happened?

Nhi Matlab itne detail me likha and no even responded, I think no one read

Originally posted by: SoniRita

The whole beauty pageant thing wasnt needed in the end for IPKKND. Everything else was good. Its still and always be my fav show. No show has came even close to IPKKND.

Originally posted by: FlauntPessimism

Nhi Matlab itne detail me likha and no even responded, I think no one read

😱 I read and reacted with a heart* emoji , not hear....typo hogaya

Originally posted by: BeingBlunt

It wasn't needed but it wasn't like it destroyed the show or completely changed its vibe. 😆 I guess it needed a quick closure when BS decided to leave so they stitched something real fast.

True a closure was needed and I hoped for a better closure then this but oh well you are right they had to come up with something quickly so they came up with that track.

Originally posted by: FlauntPessimism

OK so for anyone who is interested. As per inheritance laws in our scriptures, children are segregated into following 12 categories in decreasing order of rights

1) Aurasa-- Own biological son, he is the most important and has highest rights on the property of father. In his presence children of no other type will have any rights

2) Putri ka Putra-- In case a man only has daughters, he is advised to make an agreement with one of his son in laws that the son of his daughter would be given to him as a son and he would be inheritor of everything. He will be practically equal to own son both religiously and legally. In Mahabharat, Manipur naresh did the same, his successor was the son of his daughter and Arjun (Babhrubahan)

3) In case one has no child of own, the third option is Kshetraj santan, that is to get a child by Niyoga. This option is taken when husband either dies without any child or is infertile. In this case husband (or in laws in husband is dead) advise wife to reach out to some other man for child bearing, it is generally a Sapinda of husband and most commonly a brother (Manusmriti only suggests husband's younger brother but practically the went with any kind of brother or even an outsider like some great Kshatriya Brahmana). The children born out of such union would be taken as the children of husband, since wife was considered a piece of land under the possession of husband so any tree growing out there belongs to husband irrespective of who sows the seeds, hence the term Kshetraj santan meaning santan got from Kshrtra (land). Dhritrashtra and Pandu were Kshetraj santaan of Vichitraveer while Pandavas were Kshetraj santaan of Pandu

4) Gūḍhaja- This is similar to Kshetraja the only difference is that while the Kshetraj is conceived with permission and knowledge of husband and everyone, even their biological fathers are known, in Gūḍhaja, the wife mates secretly and no one knows the actual father (In normal words he is the result of an EMA of wife), he is treated below above three but still considered the child of husband due to the same Kshetra logic explained above

5) Dattak Putra-- One can adopt a child, this adoption is done by following the rituals, this adoption will be with permssion of biological parents of the child. Like Kunti was adopted by Kuntibhoj with permission of her biological parents, and he will in next in line of succession. He like above can perform last rites of the parents.

The children below this stage are considered bad and dont have the right to perform last rites of parents

6) Kanina-- This is the child of a maiden women conceived before the marriage by someone else. Karna will fall in this category for Pandu's child

7) Paunarbhava-- This is child of a remarried woman. If a woman remarries and has a child from second husband, this child will still be considered the child of first husband but would be below ones mentioned

8)Krita -- If a child is sold by parents to someone of same Varna and the other purchases it with an intention to treat as child, he will come under Krita(here the intent should be to make own's child and not a Dasa)

9) Kritma- A man adopts the child himself (he isnt gifted by parents like in case of Dattaka).

10) Dattamma-- A child himself reaches out to someone and presents himself as his child

11) Sahodhaja: Similar to Kaneen, only difference that he was still in womb when his mother married her husband (that is if a man marries a pregnant woman the child will be taken as that of husband in this category)

12) Apavidhha-- A child is deserted by his parents and is adopted by someone else. Karna's adoption by Adirath will come under this category.

So as we see Pandavas being Kshetraj were much ahead in line of succession to Karna who was a Kaneen. Yes Krishna did offer Karna to join Pandavas so that he will be made the king, but that offer isnt scripturally supported, so I personally feel he was just fooling Karna to switch sides, all the more since Krishna also offered Draupadi to Karna which we all know he had absolutely no rights for. The wife of younger brother is like a daughter so Draupadi also becoming his made no real sense.

I didn't reply to it because i couldn't get over the shock from the blue paragraph...Krishna did WHAT?

Originally posted by: RainOfDew

Its one of my fav show till date..but they ruined it😔

Originally posted by: FlauntPessimism

Yaar i feel so stupid now to write such a big post on types of sons