How can you say that abhimanyu did nothing wrong to akshara - Page 7

Created

Last reply

Replies

122

Views

10.2k

Users

39

Likes

465

Frequent Posters

Posted: 2 years ago
#61

Originally posted by: reddit_toe

Forging birth certificate is wrong and she is and was wrong in abandoning Abhi from fatherly rights. You cannot punish a father for the crimes committed by the husband both relationships are different. And of course court also knows. End mein we also know Abhi will sacrifice his son.

She would have been wrong if she didn’t call him to inform as soon as she got to know that one of their kid is alive ! He didn’t even want to hear abt her or kid so it’s not her fault ! Once he got to know the truth he could have revealed too but he didn’t so he is equally wrong ! Who stopped him not to reveal the truth to Ruhi ? Everyone have their own reasons to keep the secrets !

Edited by DreamOfEndless - 2 years ago
DevilHere thumbnail

YRKKH Fans

Posted: 2 years ago
#62

Originally posted by: shahsb_26


Gen 2 was bad and it was shit after Kairav's custody case nonsense !

Yaar when did Mimi support her brother? I don't even know (or remember) any reference but didn't the whole family sent Puru Mama to jail for his behavior? That's what I remember from Mansi's wedding. Sex determination, Pallu pehna and Taane maarna were way forward but Mimi was still better than what Manjiri is today in my opinion.

Kartik and Naira dealt with lot of issues but had solid base for their actions. Just like wd is claimed, that whole Mihirs track was really stupid and out of place but for us to say that we know their relationship. WD or not from what I have read Abhimanyu was expected to do that, he never trusted Akshu and always criticized her for not being the kind of person he wanted her to be. She should only be doing what he tells her to, and this was from their base of relationship. But before this nonsense, Kartik and Naira were supporters ek dusre ke - it was little bad because all major issues in the show were made all about Kaira but that's different rant.

I mean it's totally ur choice if u feel Mimi was better..i would beg to differ

Ohh she did know what Puru Mama did but hid it from everyone nd that' just one of the really fc*ed up stuff she did

Again u've read it nd heard it here on IF not actually seen it....it may as very well be a very biased take on what was shown

cutepigs thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 180 Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 2 years ago
#63

Originally posted by: Chaitu.V

so by saying unbiased u r tagging others as biased who have a different opinion from u ?

Not interested these never ending useless debates to keep going !

She would have been wrong if she didn’t call him to inform as soon as she got to know that one of their kid is alive ! He didn’t even want to hear abt her or kid so it’s not her fault ! Once he got to know the truth he could have revealed too but he didn’t so he is equally wrong ! Who stopped him not to reveal the truth to Ruhi ? Everyone have their own reasons to keep the secrets !

I defend Abhimanyu for the custody case because he wanted co parenting and it was Akshara and Goenkas who wanted to wipe him out of Abhir's life. BUT I don't think Akshara was wrong in hiding Abhir from him when she did. These thoughts can exist at the same time. Miscommunication and misunderstanding led them to the point where when Akshara called, either Abhimanyu was trying to save his mother's life or Abhinav picked when he called and Abhimanyu was never shown someone ok with a third person commenting on his relationships. So her hiding Abhir was correct, even though the birth certificate thing was wrong and illegal.

But the fact remains that Akshara wanted all, Abhimanyu was ok with compromise. He never not called Abhinav the father since he himself was his Niel's and Ruhi's father, and if she knew her grandfather was wrong to say Abhir will never know the truth, she should have stopped it, or prepared Abhir for losing, which she didn't. So yes, currently, I do find her more wrong because she is playing the my way or highway rule, which isn't fair when multiple lives are involved. And if we say it is allowed because Abhimanyu did that too, then we have to acknowledge she is doing all this for revenge and isn't saintly, we can't say one was wrong in doing so and the other is correct.

PhoenixRising thumbnail
Voyager Thumbnail 2nd Anniversary Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 2 years ago
#64

I do support Abhimanyu but I do acknowledge that he wronged Akshara. Justice should be for both, not just one!

And if acknowledging the good and bad of both or calling a spade a spade, the world is better here ❤️

Also, I think Akshara has learnt to be a little selfish at times, but the self-respect - I don’t think she has it. She does have this twisted sense of self-righteousness though. She still doesn’t listen to others or have a discussion calmly - looks more egotistical than self-respect to me.

Edited by DreamOfEndless - 2 years ago
kuchnaakahoo thumbnail
Visit Streak 500 Thumbnail 13th Anniversary Thumbnail + 7
Posted: 2 years ago
#65

As far as I remember, both Akshara and Abhinav tried to contact Abhimanyu to tell him about one of the babies being alive ,but he was not ready to listen. So how did anyone try to abandon him of his fatherly rights. It was he who abandoned Akshara during a very critical point of time. Miscarriage weakens a woman both emotionally and physically. But he just threw her out of his life.

Posted: 2 years ago
#66

Originally posted by: cutepigs

I defend Abhimanyu for the custody case because he wanted co parenting and it was Akshara and Goenkas who wanted to wipe him out of Abhir's life. BUT I don't think Akshara was wrong in hiding Abhir from him when she did. These thoughts can exist at the same time. Miscommunication and misunderstanding led them to the point where when Akshara called, either Abhimanyu was trying to save his mother's life or Abhinav picked when he called and Abhimanyu was never shown someone ok with a third person commenting on his relationships. So her hiding Abhir was correct, even though the birth certificate thing was wrong and illegal.

But the fact remains that Akshara wanted all, Abhimanyu was ok with compromise. He never not called Abhinav the father since he himself was his Niel's and Ruhi's father, and if she knew her grandfather was wrong to say Abhir will never know the truth, she should have stopped it, or prepared Abhir for losing, which she didn't. So yes, currently, I do find her more wrong because she is playing the my way or highway rule, which isn't fair when multiple lives are involved. And if we say it is allowed because Abhimanyu did that too, then we have to acknowledge she is doing all this for revenge and isn't saintly, we can't say one was wrong in doing so and the other is correct.

yeah, that’s his problem he can’t really handle the relationships, he can only handle one at a time and the rest he fails ! That’s exactly what he did on that day too!
She already tried to inform also waited for him for 7mnths but to get disappointed! So Ak was not wrong hiding Abhirs truth from Birla’s as she knows how selfish and impulsive ma beta can be and snatch her kid, and they proved her right by doing that! Even I expected her to reveal the truth to Abhir and give rights to AbM but the situations were not in their favour so everyone including AbM decided to hide the truth !

But he always failed assuring her that he only wants to co parent n not snatch the kid! He was always rude and challenging with her for his HAQ! She have her past fears too where she have to lose everything just because of him because of his impulsive nature!Once he went to kasuali and stayed in Sharma’s house ,the equation changed ,she started believing him ,been nice ,friendly and also want to reveal the truth! Also said he is a good father !Abhinav was about to reveal unless this BP n Mj entered n ruined everything! Abhinav did ask BP to stop right ,that but even shown in today’s episode ! But AbM never stopped or stops his mom from doing all the wrong things in his life! Why didn’t he stop Mj from challenging BP? He is equally wrong too!

Abhir don’t need anyone’s permission to call Abhinav his papa! Their bond is beautiful !Abhinav will always remain Abhir’s papa as AbM will remain poppy to Ruhi! Of course he is not constant with any of his relationships so is with Ruhi!

reddit_toe thumbnail
Visit Streak 90 Thumbnail Visit Streak 30 Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 2 years ago
#67

Originally posted by: Chaitu.V

She would have been wrong if she didn’t call him to inform as soon as she got to know that one of their kid is alive ! He didn’t even want to hear abt her or kid so it’s not her fault ! Once he got to know the truth he could have revealed too but he didn’t so he is equally wrong ! Who stopped him not to reveal the truth to Ruhi ? Everyone have their own reasons to keep the secrets !

Where is Ruhi coming in this debate whether AK is wrong or not.

Edited by DreamOfEndless - 2 years ago
cutepigs thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 180 Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 2 years ago
#68

Originally posted by: Chaitu.V

yeah, that’s his problem he can’t really handle the relationships, he can only handle one at a time and the rest he fails ! That’s exactly what he did on that day too!
She already tried to inform also waited for him for 7mnths but to get disappointed! So Ak was not wrong hiding Abhirs truth from Birla’s as she knows how selfish and impulsive ma beta can be and snatch her kid, and they proved her right by doing that! Even I expected her to reveal the truth to Abhir and give rights to AbM but the situations were not in their favour so everyone including AbM decided to hide the truth !

But he always failed assuring her that he only wants to co parent n not snatch the kid! He was always rude and challenging with her for his HAQ! She have her past fears too where she have to lose everything just because of him because of his impulsive nature!Once he went to kasuali and stayed in Sharma’s house ,the equation changed ,she started believing him ,been nice ,friendly and also want to reveal the truth! Also said he is a good father !Abhinav was about to reveal unless this BP n Mj entered n ruined everything! Abhinav did ask BP to stop right ,that but even shown in today’s episode ! But AbM never stopped or stops his mom from doing all the wrong things in his life! Why didn’t he stop Mj from challenging BP? He is equally wrong too!

Abhir don’t need anyone’s permission to call Abhinav his papa! Their bond is beautiful !Abhinav will always remain Abhir’s papa as AbM will remain poppy to Ruhi! Of course he is not constant with any of his relationships so is with Ruhi!

I think we have had these fights too many times so I don't want to overdo anymore. And just FYI, Abhimanyu has always called Abhinav Abhir's father, he has always asked for him to be one too. Akshara and Kairav also has always done the same, put one relationship on pedestal and not care about any else, she put Arohi up and moved away from family or Kairav asked her to and she left, she put Abhinav up and moved away from acknowledging or checking any sadness Abhir might be having with the whole father's issue, she put Abhimanyu up and moved away from him only during Khera issue, and in all these cases, she never stopped to think how it affects others and didn't try to come clean in any of them

Flaws in both characters is why everyone is asking for growth, something gradual being shown in Abhimanyu but not Akshara and hence, people are angry on her. This has nothing to do with liking or hating characters, it is about the growth with time, which as individuals, we are supposed to have.

Posted: 2 years ago
#69

Originally posted by: reddit_toe

Where is Ruhi coming in this debate whether AK is wrong or not. Matlab to support argument kuch bhi likh dena hai.

Is Ruhi not in the show? Why r being rude and getting personal ? When u can talk about Akshara I can talk about AbM and his wrong deeds too!if u have a logical argument u can reply or stop quoting me
Posted: 2 years ago
#70

Originally posted by: cutepigs

I think we have had these fights too many times so I don't want to overdo anymore. And just FYI, Abhimanyu has always called Abhinav Abhir's father, he has always asked for him to be one too. Akshara and Kairav also has always done the same, put one relationship on pedestal and not care about any else, she put Arohi up and moved away from family or Kairav asked her to and she left, she put Abhinav up and moved away from acknowledging or checking any sadness Abhir might be having with the whole father's issue, she put Abhimanyu up and moved away from him only during Khera issue, and in all these cases, she never stopped to think how it affects others and didn't try to come clean in any of them

Flaws in both characters is why everyone is asking for growth, something gradual being shown in Abhimanyu but not Akshara and hence, people are angry on her. This has nothing to do with liking or hating characters, it is about the growth with time, which as individuals, we are supposed to have.

@ sure, u started quoting me and replied and now after saying that u wrote a long post! Ok I rest my case as I won’t agree anything u wrote and don’t want any more discussions on the same topic again !


FYI : As already said Abhinav don’t need anyone’s permission or assurance or acknowledgement to Abhir call him papa!

Related Topics

Yeh Rishta Kya Kehlata Hai thumbnail

Posted by: Shinning_AD · 4 months ago

https://www.instagram.com/reel/DGLFTPpvJls/?igsh=djRzZmNrOWtmZGtl https://www.instagram.com/reel/DGPmJ5dPAVd/?igsh=MW4zb2tsdHB6NGFmdA== I guess...

Expand ▼
Yeh Rishta Kya Kehlata Hai thumbnail

Posted by: ABirla · 4 months ago

Title: The Bond of Blood and Trust Inspired by DKP and Rajan Shahi's show Yeh Rishta Kya Kehlata Hai. As the brilliant daughter of Dr. Abhimanyu...

Expand ▼
Yeh Rishta Kya Kehlata Hai thumbnail

Posted by: Lostin90s · 5 months ago

Since lot of members believe Ak was a bigamist since she left Trash’ house after signing divorce paper ( expecting too much logic from ITV) and...

Expand ▼
Yeh Rishta Kya Kehlata Hai thumbnail

Posted by: Aleyamma47 · 6 months ago

Abhir is doing an EMA out of his free will. It's not because he is Abhimanyu's blood nor because he was raised by Akshnav. He is having an...

Expand ▼
Yeh Rishta Kya Kehlata Hai thumbnail

Posted by: Firefly_shines · 1 months ago

After watching today’s ep, I just have one thing to say, I wanted Abheera’s fate for Akshara. Akshara’s impulsiveness and miscalculations killed...

Expand ▼
Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".