Amit Sana deserved a 30 today - Page 2

ok so Amit deserved a 30 even after messing the starting...??

then wat did himani deserve after singng a flawless saanwre??? a 32 on 30????
nt possible to gv her 32 na???

thn how wud it be fair to gv amit 30 n himani also 30??

so wsnt it fair to gv himani 30 n amit 28?

amit was fab today..loved his performnce 👏 ..though i wont say he deserved a 30.. it wasnt perfect imo!

it was almost a 30 performance i m sure judges wud give him 30 if he were in their good book as they overlook mistakes of some contestans like vineet and ishmeet. cant blv they gave vineet 29 when he completely messed up in the middle of laagan laagi and 30 yesterday while he atleast lost his breath twice in tht song and was pretty harsh in the entry notes!

If u think that Amit deserved 30, then how would u rate Amanat Ali's performance on the same song in SRGMP. Check it out on youtube...a must watch !!!

Originally posted by: Atlee99

If u think that Amit deserved 30, then how would u rate Amanat Ali's performance on the same song in SRGMP. Check it out on youtube...a must watch !!!

i am talking only about relative grading...only in comparison to other singers on the show...I have heard Amanat's rendition and it is much superior..😊

Originally posted by: amsjms

it was almost a 30 performance i m sure judges wud give him 30 if he were in their good book as they overlook mistakes of some contestans like vineet and ishmeet. cant blv they gave vineet 29 when he completely messed up in the middle of laagan laagi and 30 yesterday while he atleast lost his breath twice in tht song and was pretty harsh in the entry notes!

👏
vinit has been always over marked by judges if singsss bad or average ..only his last performance was upto da mark

Originally posted by: ~Indian Doll~

im sori but i dont think amit sana ever deserved a 30 before i hope he iz capable of in the futuree which i dont think he can he is a weak singer

u dont even know wat u r talkin bout.the last thing on earth amit sana is, a weak singer. i agree he isnt doin well in the show but its also true tht he is hardly 1/4th the amit sana at all in the show so far (albela ko chhod kar). but form dosent always refer to a singer's capability. i m not sayin he shud stay much longer while he is this way but he never is a weak singer and he never will be.