Originally posted by: Neha_S
I read through all your comments pro and against Meerab but I won’t comment. I made myself promise that I won’t get into this and I won’t…
Just remember - the reason many of Meeru’s actions don’t make sense and Murtasim’s does is because the writer gives you his POV and his rationalisations. His thoughts and dialogues are well thought out and well written.
Meerab- we don’t know what she is thinking. We never do and her dialogues are really badly written. Like they are written to confuse the audience. When she talks to Rohail, for eg, it’s written to give her plausible deniability not clarity.
They could have easily made her say I am not interested in you, R and still have R chase her as he is a psycho. But the writer chose to ensure that R thinks Meeru is being forced to stay with Murtu and has feelings for R- they chose to give R some clarity but not Meeru. In order to make R’s character real motivation they chose to take away Meeru’s clarity.
I wish along with watching ITV, Nooran watched Diyar e Dil. Pretty similar situation between Farah and Meerab - Farah is also a dheet but you feel for her as you are with her in her journeys- her fears, her misconceptions and her realizations are shown to the audience. Meerab is a closed book and when given some scenes her character graph jumps from one point to another without any consistency
742