Originally posted by: mango.falooda
to be honest, I disliked this scene -- why?
because the only person doing the talking is viaan and we have no idea what she feels about this fictional viaan. does she have any reaction to those thoughts? zero, except a blank stare. is she repulsed? is she mad? does she agree with him? does she feel sorry for him? nothing, nada!
all we get is deep internal thoughts from viaan always -- he is the multifaceted charcter. katha has not grown and continues to be rather one dimensional FL and we don't even know what she thinks half the time on key moments.
Yeah I get your point completely- but in this case I thought it was just Viaan telling Katha what he feels, he still doesnt know how/what she is feeling so her having reactions/dialogues would make it weird right?
Plus I was thinking what if it had been made in a way that it was actually Katha imagining the scene (which isnt how they did it ofc!) but then that would technically indicate what she wants Viaan to say. That would be her version of Viaan speaking, it would have brought out her dilemma so well.
So she wouldnt have needed dialogues/reactions in either perspective but I think showing it as primarily Katha's imagination would have made the scene connect with us more by showing her side for a change!
What do you think?