FG-reality,II-music

nothing more can b said,II is just music,n FG a lot more,fights,friendship,love,romance,n much more,nd ITA endorsed this

yeah thats true.... Indian Idol contestants used to get prepared by themselves where in GK they had dance, music teacher....

I wud like to say tht FG too had music but most of it was just drama and sensational news which influenced voting a great deal and it was as if the value of talent was almost lost..Ppl(judges,faculty,students and janta) began to vote on the wrong basis and there was too much controversy.. and sumhow it seemed more lyk a daily soap of ekta kapoor then a proper musical talent hunt.

In comaparison II focused on talent a great deal and ppl( only janta.. cos no one else had voting power vested in em) did vote 4 talent mostly(except Ravinder) and it also had reality in the correct quantity... with ppl losing and having the expected emotions and winning and having the natural emotions.. and negative comments.. and wat more of a reality can they show with the rags to riches story of abhijeet.. II had a perfect ratio of both

whereas--
In FG drama was blown too much outta proportion

I hereby conclude tht II is much better in comparison to FG

Originally posted by: thhikana

yeah thats true.... Indian Idol contestants used to get prepared by themselves where in GK they had dance, music teacher....

i am sure tht helped them quite a lot..

but even then i think(having seen both the shows) tht the singers in ii was better..

fg contestants were better performers though.. in II not much imp was given to performance farahs pleas withstanding

Ok.. after reading all the posts we can say that Raghav hypothesis is proved 👏 👏

lemme say this!!!
The wrst thing i felt abt fg was that all the contestants had to decide the final vote out! n it cud have been on the basis of nething!! jo hatred hoti thi that used 2 b their main crux! i hated that bat fg!
And ii they used to luk like they were more civilized.. Thats all i can say!

Originally posted by: luving_gal_neha

lemme say this!!!
The wrst thing i felt abt fg was that all the contestants had to decide the final vote out! n it cud have been on the basis of nething!! jo hatred hoti thi that used 2 b their main crux! i hated that bat fg!
And ii they used to luk like they were more civilized.. Thats all i can say!

very well sed neha 😉👏

Originally posted by: thhikana

Ok.. after reading all the posts we can say that Raghav hypothesis is proved 👏 👏

so can we say it raghav's theory of fg nd ii now?