BPKH: Chit Chat Club 2 - Page 38

Created

Last reply

Replies

490

Views

17.7k

Users

18

Likes

614

Frequent Posters

950842 thumbnail
Posted: 2 years ago

Originally posted by: Utkarsha999

Compared to other typical itv serials this show is perfect entertainment package 👍🏼

channel, writers, makers, actors all are doing brilliant job 👍🏼 execution is best so far, most of the scenes are visual treat like a movie scenes dialogues are awesome required some basic urdu knowledge for better understanding 😆

I like all characters, no one is pure negative all are behaving like a normal people

But on social media everyone bashing ML called him rapist

I am not going to pass any judgment on Katha for sleeping with a guy for money. it is OK she has her own reasons. My problem is more with the fact that all the blame is falling on the guy and the woman is refusing to take responsibility of her actions and decisions AND it is being justified because she was doing this to save her son. He made an offer and she accepted it. They are equal partners in this transaction. Why should she get a moral high ground? The feminist in me cringes when women want equal rights/authority but not equal responsibility.

Viaan is not a playboy like OG ML, he's totally anti women but attracted towards Katha unknowingly, for a ons we can't blame him because last time also he gives her choice "If you are not comfortable then you are free to backout I'm not forcing you" now after knowing the truth he is guilty for his misjudgements towards women and using this guilt as a weapon for changing himself as a better person this is called a character progression and I really like it❤️


@Bold: Okay, this is extreme. It was a two-way transaction.


Is she shirking responsibility or freeing herself from any guilt because she feels she had a valid reasoning to go forward with it? The clips I saw all indicate that he feels he was wrong in the situation, while she is of the opinion she did no wrong. In all honesty, she could have chosen to reveal she needs the money for her ill child and avoided this mess completely.


Viaan does not have to be playboy. But there are also many men whose unconscious bias and upbringing leads them to see women as being a certain way, and they do not realise they are crossing their line when they do. I still stick with my stance on the fact that as a dignified gentleman, he could have also chosen to get some papers signed and left the venue.


Both could have just handled the issue in a better manner. But then it would not make for this tale.


Thank you for the informed opinion post watch. I was basing my opinion on what was shared with me. But you cleared my doubts about the characterisation, and I am in a better place to make a decision.

Edited by nautankitadka - 2 years ago
Utkarsha999 thumbnail
Visit Streak 30 Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail 3rd Anniversary Thumbnail
Posted: 2 years ago

Originally posted by: nautankitadka


@Bold: Okay, this is extreme. It was a two-way transaction.


Is she shirking responsibility or freeing herself from any guilt because she feels she had a valid reasoning to go forward with it? The clips I saw all indicate that he feels he was wrong in the situation, while she is of the opinion she did no wrong. In all honesty, she could have chosen to reveal she needs the money for her ill child and avoided this mess completely.


Viaan does not have to be playboy. But there are also many men whose unconscious bias and upbringing leads them to see women as being a certain way, and they do not realise they are crossing their line when they do. I still stick with my stance on the fact that as a dignified gentleman, he could have also chosen to get some papers signed and left the venue.


Both could have just handled the issue in a better manner. But then it would not make for this tale.


Thank you for the informed opinion post watch. I was basing my opinion on what was shared with me. But you cleared my doubts about the characterisation, and I am in a better place to make a decision.

One thing I want to say is when she asked Viaan for 1cr loan, he clearly asked her why she thought the company would give her such a big loan. I don't understand why she just didn't tell him the truth then. Those saying Viaan should have asked, well I really think he did. It's not his fault if Katha didn't answer and I don't think he is going to go on inquiring more about her if she herself doesn't want to say the truth because he probably doesn't have that time. Now because she didn't tell him anything and asked him to forget about it he got curious and just made that offer to test her on the spot even though he shouldn't have. But the moment he made that offer she accepted it? Like first she doesn't tell the true reason for asking for the loan and when Viaan makes that indecent offer she accepts? Those are two contradictory actions from her end right there. Which I feel made Viaan even more confused. Like I've said previously, to me both are equally responsible for what happened that night but Viaan just gets the worse end of the stick for initiating it.

I agree viaan is definitely wrong by putting that indecent proposal but why in the world Katha did not disclose the reason is beyond my understanding 👎🏼and no ways I mean to say viaan is great or nullify his mistakes but I mind a sentence like "viaan is horrible and katha is great and inspiring" as a mom I respect her👍🏼

But I feel more connected with viaan 😉

950842 thumbnail
Posted: 2 years ago

I cannot really answer beyond what I did interpret from all the valid points and experiences you all shared, since I legit have no more knowledge of the show. Maybe Chinu or Nishu might be able to better discuss this 👍🏼

Chinmayi18 thumbnail
Visit Streak 180 Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 2 years ago

Muze to ye story pride and prejudice ka example lagti hai

V completely wrong person nahi hai and K bhi itv FL's ki tarah perfect nahi hai mere liye dono equal hai 😌

Muze aur Nishu ko K and V ki love story me koi interest nahi hai at this point atleast 👎🏼mai to Ehsan - Viaan friendship , Katha -Aarav realistic Maa beta cute scenes and Viaan -Aarav ki bonding me interested hu (after all indirectly hi sahi V ne apne friend Adi ke bete ki life save ki hai👍🏼 ek different type of connection hai Aarav -viaan me )

I hope KA show finite hi ho like OG series 🤞

120360 thumbnail
Posted: 2 years ago

Originally posted by: Nichuss


im silent in the forum.... and i started aftr 25 epsd..... tats y u didnt come to knw...


btwn TTs only gud clips or clips tat can hv argument is posted i guess... cant judge by that


i judged it as my friend told me abt original turkish story.... as story didnt lukd convincing... with emotions n expressionss...


but in ITV version they are clearing original loop holes n making it interesting to watch,,,

Aditi is already a gud performer... Adnan im first time...


they are competiting each other to show who performed best... hence its touching viewers more

Agree.... I cant judge the story by the clips shared. But based on the clips I can say that the makers are putting effort to make the story relatable. Most of the scenes I saw were well done and dialogues too 👍🏼. And I think I can safely assume that all the key characters have good enough space to showcase their character.

120360 thumbnail
Posted: 2 years ago

Originally posted by: nautankitadka


I'm also of the same opinion. I checked out the forum too, they are promoting it as being 'different' and 'refreshing', but I want to know for sure. And I need to know if what the FL did was an active choice or she was really exhausted of all the options that she succumbed to this. Because whatever he was asking for is disgusting. Also, while Twitter is more than happy to announce them as a couple making their way towards love, I cannot ship these two characters together if the premise of their so-called story was also so morally questionable.

I think that ons is the one and only incident around which there are so many controversies and doubts and I think thats where the makers probably didnt clarify much or at least I didnt see any such clip with their thought processes. So basically, each viewer will choose what they want to think....

But I am of the opinion that it is indeed different after seeing few of the scenes.... and execution seems to have a flow generally which is good. Abhi tak jo serials dekhe meine, sab suddenly ek tangent pe chala jaata hai... there its track based execution. Here maybe there is no such thing as a track.... but too soon to say.

120360 thumbnail
Posted: 2 years ago

Originally posted by: nautankitadka


Since it is a Sony show, does it not come on YouTube after 72 hours? Yes, I am also majorly confused on what is the premise in the show and clip. Why did they not take on different paths after that dreaded night?!

Ohh yeah! I forgot its on Sony. Now I remember Arpi had mentioned. I kept thinking its on Star only... confused it with that Bahu Hamari Rajnikant S2 that was to be aired.

Phir tho dekh sakti hoon... but let it progress to 100 epis then perhaps will start.... hope it is a finite show.

120360 thumbnail
Posted: 2 years ago

Thanks so much Nishu. You put so much effort ❤️....

I didnt know about a lot of the things in this story.

120360 thumbnail
Posted: 2 years ago

Originally posted by: Chinmayi18

Sorry Tannu Di, aap muze miss kar rahe the aur mai gayab thi but now I'm back🤗

Coming to the KA, mai khud totally confused thi ONS jaisa bold concept plus Alpha ml it's not my cup of tea but pata nahi kyu maine dekhna start kiya and now I'm glad ki mai dekh rahi hu ye show

Ye show sach me achha hai and most importantly itv ki regular nonsense stuff se different hai 👍🏼

40 episodes complete ho gaye abtak koi skipworthy epi nahi mila sare epi interesting hai, screen play fast no dragging 1 and half month me bohot kuch ho gaya story progression specialy ml ki character growth redeemtion track ke though achhe se dikha rahe hai abtak to muze koi complaints nahi hai is show se mai aur Nishu achhe se enjoy kar rahe hai KA with full of funny discussions daily 🤣

And we love Katha -Aarav mom son bonding very much ❤

Anju, Tannu must watch KA you won't regret love it or hate it but don't ignore it 👍🏼

Oh so you both have joined the KA forum? 😆... okay abhi abhi realise kiya hai that its on youtube, thanks to Tanu.... might give it a try... hope it still goes good at 100 epis

Chinmayi18 thumbnail
Visit Streak 180 Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 2 years ago

Not really, hum KA forum par silent readers hai mostly 😆hamare discussions insta par chalte hai

Yes you tube par KA ke episodes available hai but kuch episodes se major scenes cut kar diye hai waha

Abhi to every epi become more interesting with each passing day so I guess 100 episodes to definitely achhe se nikal hi jayenge let's see...

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".