Golden chair AGAIN (biased?)

Every time Gashmeer wins the golden chair, he posts a cryptic story right after the shoot ends like #1, #2

And now well, Lo and Behold, the #3 story has also been posted, lol 😂

Now the repetitiveness of a certain behaviour by Jhalak makers will obviously be subjected to speculation, like the inconsistent scoring, one person getting immunity again and again and again. 👀

Like no hate for Gashmeer, he dances really well, and my points aren’t directed to him, but to the makers, give the other contestants a chance too? Giving immunity to the same person makes me think that the one time he wasn’t given immunity may have resulted in a percentage of votes that they weren’t or maybe were expecting, who knows 👀

Nonetheless, this definitely points a finger at the makers for promoting him way more than the other contestants. But I mean, Jhalak stopped playing fair in the previous few seasons only, be it regarding scores, contestants, judges etc.

And before any fans of his come at me, I’ll say it again, this post is not directed to Gashmeer. That man can dance really well and most of the times deserves the high scores. All I am saying is other contestants who also score high should also be given a chance at immunity.

The Golden Chair process is not transparent and is very arbitrary just like whatever that random "sahi hai" coin the judges are also giving to some contestants.

But whatever I could gather from the times the Golden Chair has been awarded so far is the following.....

The first time Gashmeer won the GC was for his jazz act....that was as near as you can get to a flawless performance and it had heavier dancing in it than the other contestants who got same scores as him that week, that is likely why he won it.

Next week Nia won the GC because her act had more challenging elements like an aerial portion etc, and the judges openly said to Gashmeer that his act wasn't up to the mark per what they were expecting. He scored lower than the other people who were in the running for the GC that week....lol

Next week after that was the Khatra elements week and the three people who got 30 were Gashmeer, Rubina and Amruta. Rubina had a fumble with her blindfold falling off in the act so that probably factored in her not being in the running for GC. Amruta literally did the same bollywood/folk stuff she's been doing nearly every week without any khatra elements. So that left Gashmeer as the 30 scoring contestant to win the GC again. Simple😆

And now we have to wait to see what he scored for this week's act and whether he actually won the GC😆. Gashmeer's posts can be very cryptic and it's not always what people are imagining it to be😆

Idhar golden chair logo ko apne talent ke basis pe milte hain not on basis of biasness

like class mein bohot accha strudent n baki average ab keya teacher dusroke dil rakhne ke liye non deserving ko first bana de?

aur by the way Gashmeer aeise cryptic story hamesha dalte hain .. everything is not about golden chair.

PS.- dont worry GM ko nehi mila, so chill

Originally posted by: AreYaar

The Golden Chair process is not transparent and is very arbitrary just like whatever that random "sahi hai" coin the judges are also giving to some contestants.

But whatever I could gather from the times the Golden Chair has been awarded so far is the following.....

The first time Gashmeer won the GC was for his jazz act....that was as near as you can get to a flawless performance and it had heavier dancing in it than the other contestants who got same scores as him that week, that is likely why he won it.

Next week Nia won the GC because her act had more challenging elements like an aerial portion etc, and the judges openly said to Gashmeer that his act wasn't up to the mark per what they were expecting. He scored lower than the other people who were in the running for the GC that week....lol

Next week after that was the Khatra elements week and the three people who got 30 were Gashmeer, Rubina and Amruta. Rubina had a fumble with her blindfold falling off in the act so that probably factored in her not being in the running for GC. Amruta literally did the same bollywood/folk stuff she's been doing nearly every week without any khatra elements. So that left Gashmeer as the 30 scoring contestant to win the GC again. Simple😆

And now we have to wait to see what he scored for this week's act and whether he actually won the GC😆. Gashmeer's posts can be very cryptic and it's not always what people are imagining it to be😆

I didn’t really state anywhere that he did not deserve the immunity or the high scores. He is a fantastic dancer. And as for the golden chair, I think that the whole point of that passport stamp is that whoever gets it becomes a contender for immunity, which is why I feel that a 30 doesn’t or maybe shouldn’t matter. for example; Niti’s performance showed a massive improvement from her previous ones and also got a golden stamp. My point was why not give the golden chair to her this time for such a massive improvement and an overall great performance? Sure Gashmeer deserved his high scores in his place, but it is obvious that the audience will start speculating when the show does something that is repetitive or odd. Another example can be how in the previous weeks the judges gave scores that did not match their comments, like calling an act very structured yet giving it a low score like 6-7.
My post was just a speculation, and i very clearly stated that it was directed to the makers of jhalak and not Gashmeer himself.
And again, it was just a guess from my side considering what I had been seeing in the past few weeks, his story may have meant something completely different, which is why I again state that my post and this comment is just a speculation.

Originally posted by: opsora2090

Idhar golden chair logo ko apne talent ke basis pe milte hain not on basis of biasness

like class mein bohot accha strudent n baki average ab keya teacher dusroke dil rakhne ke liye non deserving ko first bana de?

aur by the way Gashmeer aeise cryptic story hamesha dalte hain .. everything is not about golden chair.

PS.- dont worry GM ko nehi mila, so chill

As I said in the comment above, I DID NOT state that Gashmeer was undeserving of the golden chair or his high scores, he clearly deserved them because it’s a fact he’s a great dancer.
another thing I DID NOT say is that undeserving ko first bana diya jaye. Gashmeer wasn’t the only high scorer, also he wasn’t the only one to get a golden stamp. The whole point of that passport is whoever gets a stamp becomes a contender. So in that case, contestants like Gunjan, Niti, Amruta and few more also could’ve gotten immunity.
And as I clearly stated in my post, it was not directed to Gashmeer. It was directed at the makers because you see, we as audience are bound to speculate when we see something repetitive or odd. The marks of the judges not matching their comments was also something odd that resulted in speculation.

And again, if it wasn’t obvious enough, my post was just a guess. He may not have gotten the golden chair, but I found it interesting which is why I made the post in the first place. This forum is a healthy platform to discuss the shows I guess.

Anyway, peace ✌️

Originally posted by: bee3bee

I didn’t really state anywhere that he did not deserve the immunity or the high scores. He is a fantastic dancer. And as for the golden chair, I think that the whole point of that passport stamp is that whoever gets it becomes a contender for immunity, which is why I feel that a 30 doesn’t or maybe shouldn’t matter. for example; Niti’s performance showed a massive improvement from her previous ones and also got a golden stamp. My point was why not give the golden chair to her this time for such a massive improvement and an overall great performance? Sure Gashmeer deserved his high scores in his place, but it is obvious that the audience will start speculating when the show does something that is repetitive or odd. Another example can be how in the previous weeks the judges gave scores that did not match their comments, like calling an act very structured yet giving it a low score like 6-7.
My post was just a speculation, and i very clearly stated that it was directed to the makers of jhalak and not Gashmeer himself.
And again, it was just a guess from my side considering what I had been seeing in the past few weeks, his story may have meant something completely different, which is why I again state that my post and this comment is just a speculation.

I didn't state anywhere in my post that you said he didn't deserve immunity 😆.....I simply explained how I observed the GC selection process to be. Not sure why you are justifying again and again that your post is speculation. 😆

I simply responded to your speculatory question only, no? 😆.....as I said, the judges have not clarified whether the passport stamp makes shortlists people to be in the running for GC. So far they've given GC to those getting the highest scores in the epis which usually happens to be 2 or 3 people being given the same scores and atleast 5 or more get the stamp each week too😆 so not sure the stamp is supposed to put them in the running for GC.

I don't think they are giving the GC for massive improvement....they are giving it for whoever manages to be technically superior given the theme for the week. Gashmeer happened to get it for those two weeks because his performances were in that top tier and others had minor goof-ups or some other issue.

Originally posted by: AreYaar

I didn't state anywhere in my post that you said he didn't deserve immunity 😆.....I simply explained how I observed the GC selection process to be. Not sure why you are justifying again and again that your post is speculation. 😆

I simply responded to your speculatory question only, no? 😆.....as I said, the judges have not clarified whether the passport stamp makes shortlists people to be in the running for GC. So far they've given GC to those getting the highest scores in the epis which usually happens to be 2 or 3 people being given the same scores and atleast 5 or more get the stamp each week too😆 so not sure the stamp is supposed to put them in the running for GC.

I don't think they are giving the GC for massive improvement....they are giving it for whoever manages to be technically superior given the theme for the week. Gashmeer happened to get it for those two weeks because his performances were in that top tier and others had minor goof-ups or some other issue.

you are right. I agree with your points.

Topic is based on speculation. Once any supporting article is available, we shall reopen the topic.

Topic closed.

JDJ 10 DT