Should Pakistani singers be given chance again in indian films?

I guess everyone be it atif or be it rahat , shafqat they just lost somewhere since the day bollywood banned the artists...Discuss? as before they were banned many musical reality shows artist used to complan that why they are being given chances while we the reality shows singers can sing better than them

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=xlDw70tGRag

Why should a nation of above 1 billion bring singers from a country where mostly fighting with? Pak singers make money here and pay it to ISI through tax. I don't like 🤢

I don't understand why artists would even need permission to collaborate. I find the entire thing so stupid. I wish indian and Pakistani artists could come together and the possibilities of wonderful masterpieces would be endless!

No. They should not be given chances in India. We are a nation of 1 billion plus and we do have good singers and our music traditions are varied. We don't need them. Same thing goes for actors too.

I'm not against collaboration with foreign artistes but Pakistani artistes don't bring anything extra to the table.

They are the ones who wanted a separate Islamic nation for themselves when there are million other things they had in common with the rest of the subcontinent while religion is the only thing that was different.

Don't see why we Indians should collaborate with them.

Banning singers/actors is just optics

... We have a steady trade going on with Pakistan in all sectors... This is just an attempt to appear that yes we are doing something while actually not doing anything substantial at all.

Its simple - Either you ban all interactions and businesses or none...

Seeing relations between both countries there is no need of Pakistani artists in India. Also there is no dearth of talent in India its just opportunities r limited.

Indians too r working outside n doing well in every field if Pakistan would not been enemy to India than there would not have been an issue.

We can listen to Pakistani artists on coke studios n there show's OST also r very nice.

But will they all be as good as Sonu?

Originally posted by: bips

Banning singers/actors is just optics

... We have a steady trade going on with Pakistan in all sectors... This is just an attempt to appear that yes we are doing something while actually not doing anything substantial at all.

Its simple - Either you ban all interactions and businesses or none...

You do realise that it is not Government of India or BJP who banned Pakistani artists but film and television industry associations themselves who did it. It wasn't a political decision. They aren't banned by law.

Mods need to close this thread. It’s already gone into hate rhetoric, and peddling nonsensical nationalist propaganda.

I can see it getting out of control.