For a smart guy......

Aryan is shown as this sharp shrewd guy who reads through people and reads between the lines.... Foresee any hanky panky behaviour and action from just about anyone.... Family or dushman or any random person

Then

How does he not see through blue aunty and her schemes???

She gives around fake jewellery an fake affection and quite on the face abuses to anyone then how does he not see their planning and plotting and put them in place or atleast watch over them

Keeping an eye would have saved his random almost marriage with doll chick ... Even save his mother and sister from insult for a situation where it is not their fault.

There have been moments when he and even Arpita have wanted to blast her and Baby Doll but Narmada has reined them in with a spoken word or a shake of the head. Narmada is too soft and too understanding for her own good.

He is too invested in Imlie and her plans hence didn't think a third factor for problems can arrive. At most he would have expected Adi to mess up his marriage but two women who came from outside, don't have much influence, being an elder and also a very close relative whom he had seen from childhood. It was very out of zone that they would commit crimes in other's domain.

And yeah I will say you are wrong about 1 thing, you are expecting too much from Rathore. Remember when he took Imlie to Hotel Rajmehel and the consequences was her divorce. It was a call from Anu, and yes he didn't do a background search for the call. So Rathore is good with plans but not long visioned for external factors affecting his plans or unconsciously becoming a pawn for others never comes in his mind😊

.. it took time for him to see through malini as well ...after almost the mirchi kaand.. as potential first harmers to imlie...n malini was more open than these two newbies n maybe his total attentionon imlie is the reason..no logic .. he can see through the aditya 2.0 too kyunki endgame jo chal raha hain inke...

Well he sees through most of the Bull shit of Badi maa. But he's stopped by his mom from calling her out.

But today i loved how naramada didn't stop him.

It not only established contrast between adi and aryan but

Narmada and aparna as well.