ZDMN EDT#6 | 21/10 WU pg 143 - Page 50

Created

Last reply

Replies

1.1k

Views

34.7k

Users

45

Likes

2.4k

Frequent Posters

Bodhianveshika thumbnail
Republic Rhythms Aazadi Quest Volunteer Thumbnail Visit Streak 500 Thumbnail + 6
Posted: 4 years ago

Sorry if this is not popular opinion. Just wanted to share feedback.

The treatment of the organ trafficking case was lukewarm and overtly simplified. It was like elements in the checkbox, ticked!

1. Show some action -- Done

2. Make the cadets realise the importance of training and apply it -- Done

3. Save victims -- Done

4. Show corruption -- Done

Furthermore, as mentioned many times over, screenplay and editing is the weakpoint of the show and patchy.

(This further reiterates the earlier assumption of a drama writer penning an army story🤦🏻‍♀️.)


Ofcourse the sheer screen presence of the actors and their personalities makes up for much of the shortcomings.


May be it is unfair to compare, but look at the treatment of cases in LRL or (may be a bit biased😉) first 80 episodes of HYMAE-Arjun.

They were sleek, polished and wholesome.


High points:

1. Monami insisting on completing her duty to treat Gauri

2. Chirag the psycho bad guy.


Again,

1. Karan single-handedly saves the day, inspite of being shot. He is found hardly hurt in precap.

2. Siddhart is stabbed, has lost a LOT of blood and for sooooooo long and is found walking back, albeit with help.

3. Bala suspects the cops while seasoned special agents dont.

4. Koel's role as a nurse is not explored.


What am I keen on watching next?

1. Not sure what would be more dramatic.

(If the look of helplessness and guilt on Koel in the end was anything to go by)

  • Koel confessing to Faizi about the recording and how Rawat is blackmailing and Faizi insisting on her to clear evidences.
  • Faizi confronting Koel on reading the letter.

2. More training scenes. Arent they also getting basic medical training for ALL and more extensive for Dr.Monami and Koel.

Edited by Bodhianveshika - 4 years ago
Ayu_12 thumbnail
Visit Streak 90 Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 4 years ago

Originally posted by: Bodhianveshika

Sorry if this is not popular opinion. Just wanted to share feedback.

The treatment of the organ trafficking case was lukewarm and overtly simplified. It was like elements in the checkbox, ticked!

1. Show some action -- Done

2. Make the cadets realise the importance of training and apply it -- Done

3. Save victims -- Done

4. Show corruption -- Done

Furthermore, as mentioned many times over, screenplay and editing is the weakpoint of the show and patchy.

(This further reiterates the earlier assumption of a drama writer penning an army story🤦🏻‍♀️.)


Ofcourse the sheer screen presence of the actors and their personalities makes up for much of the shortcomings.


May be it is unfair to compare, but look at the treatment of cases in LRL or (may be a bit biased😉) first 80 episodes of HYMAE-Arjun.

They were sleek, polished and wholesome.


High points:

1. Monami insisting on completing her duty to treat Gauri

2. Chirag the psycho bad guy.


Again,

1. Karan single-handedly saves the day, inspite of being shot. He is found hardly hurt in precap.

2. Siddhart is stabbed, has lost a LOT of blood and for sooooooo long and is found walking back, albeit with help.

3. Bala suspects the cops while seasoned special agents dont.

4. Koel's role as a nurse is not explored.


What am I keen on watching next?

1. Not sure what would be more dramatic.

(If the look of helplessness and guilt on Koel in the end was anything to go by)

  • Koel confessing to Faizi about the recording and how Rawat is blackmailing and Faizi insisting on her to clear evidences.
  • Faizi confronting Koel on reading the letter.

2. More training scenes. Arent they also getting basic medical training for ALL and more extensive for Dr.Monami and Koel.

Good observation. Actually I feel all cadets will be trained for specially fields ... I wanted Monami to get medical training and others to train ...

Let see what happens.

Minionite thumbnail
Posted: 4 years ago

Originally posted by: -Preetz-


Rawat truth won't come out this easily.

I don't know why but I have this thought going on. what if Rawat was the one who killed param?? like in the name of those terroists who attacked school, Rawat took a chance and shot param? kisi ko pata hi nai chala hoga cause they might have thought its those terrorists. what say??


Cliched, but quite possible. Jealousy mein maar giraya aapne "competition" ko. Quite possible.

Minionite thumbnail
Posted: 4 years ago

Originally posted by: Bodhianveshika

Sorry if this is not popular opinion. Just wanted to share feedback.

The treatment of the organ trafficking case was lukewarm and overtly simplified. It was like elements in the checkbox, ticked!

1. Show some action -- Done

2. Make the cadets realise the importance of training and apply it -- Done

3. Save victims -- Done

4. Show corruption -- Done

Furthermore, as mentioned many times over, screenplay and editing is the weakpoint of the show and patchy.

(This further reiterates the earlier assumption of a drama writer penning an army story🤦🏻‍♀️.)


Ofcourse the sheer screen presence of the actors and their personalities makes up for much of the shortcomings.


May be it is unfair to compare, but look at the treatment of cases in LRL or (may be a bit biased😉) first 80 episodes of HYMAE-Arjun.

They were sleek, polished and wholesome.


High points:

1. Monami insisting on completing her duty to treat Gauri

2. Chirag the psycho bad guy.


Again,

1. Karan single-handedly saves the day, inspite of being shot. He is found hardly hurt in precap.

2. Siddhart is stabbed, has lost a LOT of blood and for sooooooo long and is found walking back, albeit with help.

3. Bala suspects the cops while seasoned special agents dont.

4. Koel's role as a nurse is not explored.


What am I keen on watching next?

1. Not sure what would be more dramatic.

(If the look of helplessness and guilt on Koel in the end was anything to go by)

  • Koel confessing to Faizi about the recording and how Rawat is blackmailing and Faizi insisting on her to clear evidences.
  • Faizi confronting Koel on reading the letter.

2. More training scenes. Arent they also getting basic medical training for ALL and more extensive for Dr.Monami and Koel.


Not an unpopular opinion at all. I agree with you. They did oversimplify it, but at least it's better than the drama of Baby and cheating and Rawat and what not.


In your what to see next, why can't we have both? Faizi reads the letter and confronts Koel. She comes clean and explains everything, even introducing Nikhil to Faizi.


Well we haven't seen any training yet, but somehow the cadets knew what to do in this organ trafficking situation and Faizi was all proud of them. And whatever happened to 21 days ki training. And 21 days mein aisi kaunsi training milegi inhe logon ko aakhir???

Sofna thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Trailblazer Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 4 years ago

Originally posted by: -Preetz-


Rawat truth won't come out this easily.

I don't know why but I have this thought going on. what if Rawat was the one who killed param?? like in the name of those terroists who attacked school, Rawat took a chance and shot param? kisi ko pata hi nai chala hoga cause they might have thought its those terrorists. what say??

I feel the same.

It's an obv storyline.

Let's see if cv's go the tried snd tested...or test a different route

Namita-M thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 5
Posted: 4 years ago

Originally posted by: Sofna

I feel the same.

It's an obv storyline.

Let's see if cv's go the tried snd tested...or test a different route


Obvious and I’m okay with it. It’s going to take solid evidence to believe that Rawat is bad. We all saw he trusts him because he was Param’s batch mate.


Namita-M thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 5
Posted: 4 years ago

Originally posted by: Sofna

Me after Monami to Karan - "Take Care"

😆

Me after Karan finds Monami the first time - the look they shared😳 smiley42smiley42smiley42smiley42smiley42smiley42smiley42smiley42smiley42smiley42smiley42

Chirags brain was doused in revenge otherwise he would've seen what the entire audience (ie me 🤣) saw pass in that look ☺️😆smiley42smiley42smiley42smiley42smiley42smiley42smiley42smiley42smiley42smiley42smiley42


Me after Karan opens his eyes after Monami thinks he's been shot 😆smiley42smiley42smiley42smiley42smiley42smiley42smiley42smiley42smiley42smiley42smiley42


Chirag was an amazing villain👍🏼 - he reminded me of the villain in Kings two hearts.

What's with everyone walking off and Monami who's suffered the most helping Sid 🤔😒


You made my day. I’m so excited to watch the episode. Going to watch now.


Namita-M thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 5
Posted: 4 years ago

So, Karan gets a bravery award. I hope Monami gets recognition as well. That girl went to hell and back to save those girls. Absolutely kick a$$ woman!!


Namita-M thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 5
Posted: 4 years ago

Rawat nahi sudhrega!! 🤦🏽‍♀️🤦🏽‍♀️🤦🏽‍♀️

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".