Shekhar's Judgment?

Page

Next Last

SCS

@jimhawkins

Sparkler

+ 4

Posted: 17 years ago

Shekhar's judgment seems to have its own rules/criterion😕 Why did he give a 10 to Vinit when he had got stuck in between and also his lower notes were no where near the mark?😕 Last week him and Vishal did the same with Prajakta... They are not doing justice to their job there... This way they will just be making a mockery of the new elimination format that they have brought in... Whenever a challenger with reputation falters, they just need to give him 10 and save him... Grossly unfair this new pattern will be going by wat VS have been doing these two weeks...

Quote

Frequent Posters

Bugger

@Bugger

Stunner

+ 2

Posted: 17 years ago

i agree here .......vineet forgot in between ..but he picked it up well and sang well inspite of the dissapointment he had after forgetting in between ......
i was impressed he continued ......seeing prajakta failing considerably there ....
but still i think 8 or 9 was ok .....giving 10 inspite of forgetting ..........is juss not done!! they shud understand tht its a compettion and favors can lead to controversies and injustice to sum extent too!
I think farah is more practical and genuine judge than them

Quote

Looks like you are new here. Register for free, learn and contribute.

Who-I-Used-2-Be

@Who-I-Used-2-Be

Rocker

+ 2

Posted: 17 years ago

I agree with you on both accounts – be it prajakta or vineet..

I think farah has improved by leaps and bound as a judge since her Indian idol days. Then, her judgment seemed biased and she either overrated or underrated people but on this show, she's proved to be a more balanced judge so far. Vishal and Shekhar need to reconsider their judging pattern

Quote

Anisha

@Cuhrazy.Anisha

Dazzler

+ 2

Posted: 17 years ago

they r loosing their good reputation they built in srgmp .....still all is nt lost they shud retrieve to der normal srgmp self or they'll be standing in level wid other judges hated fr der partial decisions...!!

Quote

msti

@msti

Inactive

Posted: 17 years ago

I agree. If he liked the rendition so much, he should have given Vineet 8 maximum; as 10 was rarely given anyways no matter how well, without forgetting the singer had sung the song and 9 is the mark singers mostly get max. 10 is way too much; and its unfair to everyone else.

Quote

Simply.confused

@Simply.confused

Rocker

Posted: 17 years ago

For me Vineet would have been top three... if he didnt have a bit mess up in the start... he picked up really well... however if from now on a challenger is being eliminated on the basis of score then yes a 10 is not fair... Because for me a 10 would be Harshit or Himani's performance...8 or 9 would have been fair... 😊

Quote

Raghuraj

@Raghuraj

Navigator

Posted: 17 years ago

They cant get Vineet out soon.Show has to go on.

All things are commercial on reality shows now a days.

Quote

SCS

@jimhawkins

Sparkler

+ 4

Posted: 17 years ago

Originally posted by: Raghuraj
They cant get Vineet out soon.Show has to go on.

All things are commercial on reality shows now a days.

I dont think the show is running because of Vinit😕😆😆 It was more of a personal choice than being commercially viable for the show...

Quote

Ritz

@glamritz

Voyager

Posted: 17 years ago

😆 vishal n shekhar are very emotional ppl .. 😳

but in a competition, judges have to be fair and not let their subjective views come in between their decision. Shekhar perhaps didnt' intend to show partiallity or watsover...but ya, 10 was too much. 8 wudve been good.

Shekhar ji, Vishali ji... pls kindly watch ur judgement!