SD4L 4- ALL SPOILER RELATED NEWS HERE ONLY - Page 10

Created

Last reply

Replies

316

Views

20.4k

Users

21

Likes

767

Frequent Posters

Realityshow thumbnail
Visit Streak 750 Thumbnail Visit Streak 500 Thumbnail + 6
Posted: 3 years ago
#91

Originally posted by: MommaDarling

One positive thing though I've noted on comments after Pratiti and Arshiya's news is that there is a lot of anger among people. Literally fans and non fans, even fans of popular contestants like Florina, etc are trashing the show. Everybody is of the same opinion that Esha and Soumit should've been out than these two

Those 2 may be difficult to dislodge. Especially as you rightly point out that only core voters are mainly active now. Soumit's support base is not visible on usual SM. But it is large and completely dedicated. To outvote such contestants you need unbiased general public voting in significant numbers.

robedward thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 90 Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 3 years ago
#92

Originally posted by: Realityshow


Things may have been different if the show had managed to hold on to its initial high TRP's. But it dragged, and lost momentum. Now the makers will take no chances and hold on to crowd favourites at any cost.

I feel there are not enough viewers who vote on performance alone. That can happen when the viewership shrinks. The final shortlist may have 3 TRP draws and 2 heavily supported contestants whose skill levels are unimportant to the voters.

Very true 😭 now its all about fan favorite. I know the winners are based on fans support but when u see talented and deserving contestants in the bottom and go home, do feel resentment towards the Channel.


In previous seasons though the finalists were neck to neck talent wise but to me, except Rupsa, the other 2 seasons winners were not winner level, some of the other finalists were robbed from the title. But this season, i think the Final 3 were already decided by audiences and channel, lets see who wins the battle of the favorite.

Realityshow thumbnail
Visit Streak 750 Thumbnail Visit Streak 500 Thumbnail + 6
Posted: 3 years ago
#93

Originally posted by: robedward

In previous seasons though the finalists were neck to neck talent wise but to me, except Rupsa, the other 2 seasons winners were not winner level, some of the other finalists were robbed from the title. But this season, i think the Final 3 were already decided by audiences and channel, lets see who wins the battle of the favorite.


I have watched a few Dance Reality Shows in the past 2-3 years (not that I am any wiser about the art form 😃) and I have found that winners are not very often even the judges choice. There it differs from music reality shows where judges usually get who they want.
Vartika herself is a great example.
Many winners receive bulk block votes. It is hard to fight that unless the judges figure out what is happening and terminate such contestants early. That is harder when voting starts very late because by then the damage may be done. Or the makers can take the IBD route which essentially protects one or two preferred dancers. But I think who wins in kids shows is not the key driver of the competition to the judges and makers. It is more like an extended audition for them. I may be wrong. So, the serious viewers should relax and watch it casually. They can always figure out who to watch for in future years.

Edited by Realityshow - 3 years ago
felixfelilah thumbnail
Dazzler Thumbnail 4th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 30 Thumbnail
Posted: 3 years ago
#94

Originally posted by: robedward

In previous seasons though the finalists were neck to neck talent wise but to me, except Rupsa, the other 2 seasons winners were not winner level, some of the other finalists were robbed from the title. But this season, i think the Final 3 were already decided by audiences and channel, lets see who wins the battle of the favorite.


Right now what I miss the most from previous seasons is the eliminations by judges 😭 That was fair. Dance in pairs, weaker ones do the Sunday act, the weakest is chosen by judges and eliminated.

This season, judgement is a joke. They are only there to bring in trp. What was even the point of having the judges on the show if they don't have any decision to make!! They say elimination is based half on judges scores but I'm 100% sure it's just based on votes. No other way the kids who've been on the bottom so far would be there if judges scored. And if they had eliminated Florina this way, I wouldn't even have complained because hum andhe nahi hai yaar, dikhta hai hame bhi.

If based on merit of the performances, my list for elimination would go like this in order - Esha, Soumit, Amit, Spriha, Arshiya, Sanchit, Florina, Aneesh, Prithvi, Pari, Neerja, Pratiti, with Anshika winning the show because she's the only contestant who's never really had a bad act. Sanchit and Florina get points for being unique contestants and okay, maybe I'm internally biased for Flo 🤪 But my point is, the elimination happening now is almost in the opposite direction


And to answer what Robz asked earlier, I pretty much had a hunch about the winner right after grand premier, but after Pawandeep won II, I think I know who will win SD 😆

Edited by felixfelilah - 3 years ago
felixfelilah thumbnail
Dazzler Thumbnail 4th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 30 Thumbnail
Posted: 3 years ago
#95

Also, like Momma said, very clearly, only fools like us are still following the show 🤣 Mostly the show fans and the contestant fans who keep fighting on SM. So vote bhi usi hisab se aayega. I wish they had the earlier season elimination format where judges choose Top 8 and voters did the rest. Anyways, like @RealityShow mentioned, we can just go with the flow now and enjoy the show. At least I can be happy that my favorite pair stands a chance

1191706 thumbnail
Posted: 3 years ago
#96

Agree I've hated the judgement this year. It looked like the judges were hell bent to prove they did a correct decision by selecting Esha over such talented contestants on the audition round. That was the first backlash they got right after auditions and they made sure they keep on proving that they did the right thing by selecting her. Honestly if you look at Esha's dancing videos on instagram a year ago and her last performance on the show, there's no difference at all, no growth at all and obviously it's the fault of the show since they concentrated on her eating more than the dance.

robedward thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 90 Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 3 years ago
#97

Originally posted by: felixfelilah

And to answer what Robz asked earlier, I pretty much had a hunch about the winner right after grand premier, but after Pawandeep won II, I think I know who will win SD 😆

Mithai kab bhenjoge??? 😌

Phir_Mohabbat thumbnail
Posted: 3 years ago
#98

Jon jeetega show?


I hope at this point sanchit wins show if pratiti leaves

felixfelilah thumbnail
Dazzler Thumbnail 4th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 30 Thumbnail
Posted: 3 years ago
#99

Originally posted by: MommaDarling

Agree I've hated the judgement this year. It looked like the judges were hell bent to prove they did a correct decision by selecting Esha over such talented contestants on the audition round. That was the first backlash they got right after auditions and they made sure they keep on proving that they did the right thing by selecting her. Honestly if you look at Esha's dancing videos on instagram a year ago and her last performance on the show, there's no difference at all, no growth at all and obviously it's the fault of the show since they concentrated on her eating more than the dance.


To think I was ready to believe Esha would be the next Rupsa sometime during the middle of the season 🤣🤣

Can't say their strategy didn't work 🤪 I mean, look at her fanbase mahn, I'm appalled at the comments under Esha's posts

felixfelilah thumbnail
Dazzler Thumbnail 4th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 30 Thumbnail
Posted: 3 years ago

Originally posted by: robedward

Mithai kab bhenjoge??? 😌


Koi mithai withai nai, bas ham sab yaha aake show ko roast karenge 🤣

Edited by felixfelilah - 3 years ago

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".