Debojit or Atif singing Pehli Nazar!

Im reopening Rashi's post for discussion purpose only as Bhaskar closed the post and said it can be reopened for discussion!

We have had some members saying that Debo did a better job on this song then Atif Aslam, I respect the members opinions, but lets discuss, is that really tru!

Lets not call anyone names here, please....discuss peacefully!

In my opinion Atif sang the song perfect, his voice and style is just perfect...kya ada hai! 😃

Yeah his voice is mesmerizing Rashi! 😳

We can feel each and every word ... the way he sang it is amazing... I dont think der shud b any comparison b/w debojeeth and asif...

^^ You are absolutely right my dear, no comparison at all! 😃

I think Atif sang it wayyyyyy better. I don't know but some people think that atif aslam is besura (including some of the singers like suniti and abhijeet), but i don't agree with it. When i sit and listen to a song I don't judge the song based on it's surs and taals. I see if I can feel the emotion the song is trying to potray or not. Atif might not have the best surs and perfect playback singing voice, but his voice texture is unique and full of emotions. There is something special about his songs. I think so many people around the world like his singing and listen to his song so it doesn't matter whether he's besura or not. People like him and that's why they listen to him and for that he deserves some respect.

Originally posted by: pari03

I think Atif sang it wayyyyyy better. I don't know but some people think that atif aslam is besura (including some of the singers like suniti and abhijeet), but i don't agree with it. When i sit and listen to a song I don't judge the song based on it's surs and taals. I see if I can feel the emotion the song is trying to potray or not. Atif might not have the best surs and perfect playback singing voice, but his voice texture is unique and full of emotions. There is something special about his songs. I think so many people around the world like his singing and listen to his song so it doesn't matter whether he's besura or not. People like him and that's why they listen to him and for that he deserves some respect.

very very well said pari!!👏👏

there is def somethin bt atif's voice...be it woh lamhe or aadat or doorie or pehli nazar what ever....u cn feel the song😳😳😳

Originally posted by: pari03

I think Atif sang it wayyyyyy better. I don't know but some people think that atif aslam is besura (including some of the singers like suniti and abhijeet), but i don't agree with it. When i sit and listen to a song I don't judge the song based on it's surs and taals. I see if I can feel the emotion the song is trying to potray or not. Atif might not have the best surs and perfect playback singing voice, but his voice texture is unique and full of emotions. There is something special about his songs. I think so many people around the world like his singing and listen to his song so it doesn't matter whether he's besura or not. People like him and that's why they listen to him and for that he deserves some respect.

If u were near me I would give u a big hug, very well said my dear!👏
Sending u a virtual hug from me! 😳

very well said pari .... 👏 and iagree ...we r no musicians here ..to understand sur or taal ....
the osng tht touch us ...or the song which we can feel it ....which sounds gud is gud for us ..and teh same is wit atif ....
amazing voice ...with feel..and when it touch ur ears ..u flow wit it ..and thts wat is needed when u hear a song ........
atif has done wonders in the song ...maula mere maula ..and pehli nazar was juss icing on teh cake 👏