Arnav Doesn't Tell Anjali The Full Truth
Hello everyone,
I had such a great time reading all the responses about the previous analysis regarding Arnav, Khushi, Shyam and the 'terrace' sequence. Now I'm here posting another analysis that (hopefully) analyzes why Arnav never tells Anjali the full truth of the night of what he saw on the terrace to her.
Once again, this is in response to an ask on Tumblr:
- I was reading your analysis to the question on Anjali, and I totally agree with you that nobody sharing information with her was the biggest mistake. But, I have never understood why Arnav never told her about what he witnessed Shyam telling khushi on the terrace. Instead, he made it sound like he married khushi for his sister and then fell in love with her. Is he not putting khushi in a bad light here ? Doesn’t this make Anjali believe that khushi could have been chasing her husband and Arnav stopped it by marrying her? Thank you so much.
In my opinion Anjali is the most misunderstood character and even her treatment was not best done - her grief and trauma was immense.
Why Arnav never told her about what he witnessed Shyam telling khushi on the terrace
I don’t think at the time of the revelation or even after that Anjali was in that space to understand/listen/trust what Arnav had to say. Every thing has a time to be said. Khushi missed hers multiple times. So did Arnav. And they paid the price for it.
Also after getting to know everything it was a messy situation and anything Arnav would’ve said about Shyam post that situation would be under the bias that he’s saying this because he’s speaking from Khushi’s perspective. Nani was perhaps one of the few people who was the most unbiased so she was also the best person Arnav could’ve approached and he did. I have no idea why Arnav framed his and Khushi’s marriage like that to Anjali. Honestly I don’t.
I think Arnav wanted Anjali to feel connected to his and Khushi’s relationship? Or tell her that he too misunderstood Khushi hence he couldn’t love her until he made a judgement and understood Khushi? Or that he wasn’t blind in love and didn’t have his love story handed to him?
And I think at times you gain trust from people by sharing secrets with them. There was a breach of trust when Arnav refused to tell his sister why he suddenly married Khushi thus sharing this might lead to more trust between the siblings.
Arnav shares a few secrets - he’s in love with Khushi, he believes what his sister tried to convince him a long time ago, and as she had previously suspected - his marriage to Khushi wasn’t based on love/happiness.
So by sharing these he might be reestablishing the trust that Arnav and Anjali shared. Anjali warms up and is even emotional seeing her brother see love the way she described it and makes an attempt to talk to Khushi, just enough for balance and harmony to prevail.
Now my thoughts, should’ve and could’ve.
I also feel with this new window Arnav should’ve had many MORE conversations but instead Anjali quickly became alone again and Shyam took thorough advantage of Anjali’s newfound semblance by positioning himself in front of her with rationale, answers and constant company.
Shyam never badmouths Arnav in front of Anjali. He is so damn smart because he knows Anjali loves Arnav beyond everything else. So he reenforces that Arnav is under a misunderstanding. Because if he ever told Anjali that Arnav is a weak/devious man - Anjali’s love for Shyam would’ve fallen through and she would’ve become incredibly protective of Arnav, thus trusting Shyam incredibly less.
One of my theories during the final reveal is that Shyam accepting he had plans to murder Arnav broke Anjali. Yes, she hates him that he killed their child but she also hates him because he tried to murder her brother, who in all way is like her first child. It fueled her rage and you can see she constantly hugs, reassures and even apologies to Arnav - telling him that he’s amazing and he did the best he could to protect her.
Coming back to scenario, Anjali is a woman who remembers so it would’ve been interesting if Arnav, gently, told Anjali that he did want to tell her something on the night he learned she was pregnant. She would remember that Arnav had something to say… and that Arnav disappeared in the middle of the celebration. I feel Anjali could’ve understood if she learned Arnav chose to preserve/support her marriage as much as he could. That her brother, too, struggled between seeing the monster and the man he respected so much.
If Arnav shared his heartbreak over what Shyam was - I do think Anjali could begin to see through Shyam.
Is he not putting khushi in a bad light here ? Doesn’t this make Anjali believe that khushi could have been chasing her husband and Arnav stopped it by marrying her?
No, he clearly states it was a misunderstanding. But yeah, Anjali still has her reservations against Khushi.
Also can we appreciate Shyam? The minute he realised Anjali grew soft for Khushi, again, because Arnav said he truly loves her - he quickly shifted his narrative of 'Khushi being a crazed woman who’s behind him' to Khushi being a 'lovely woman who probably got stuck in this mess because of several misunderstandings'.
Hope you all liked reading this!
Love,
S
Edited by IPodcastKKND - 4 years ago
31