nancy56 thumbnail
9th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 30 Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 4 years ago
#1

After today's episode, I know most of the people, will lean or literally stand on Shravan's side.

They will think of Suman as some git/rude/cold-hearted girl, who can't feel.

They will think Shravan to be the ultimate sufferer.


But, I just want to pull out a neutral point of view, on which I want all of you to give a thought about. This show isn't about the Male lead or the Female Lead, it's about the situations and the two-way problems they have faced till now.

Understanding Shravan's side isn't difficult.
He saw the whole society pulling out a mockery of his family, calling them deshdrohi. He saw his family break, relations sour. He saw his father serve 3 years of the sentence.
But he decided that Suman was some nonchalant sh*t, for whom he was a small chapter. So he Knowingly didn't answer her calls and messages.

People need to understand that if Suman's father has died because of Devraj's negligence, Shravan needs to get this in his gut too. If he had genuinely got this in his gut, then he would have tried calling Suman, the same way she had done it for him.

Understanding Suman is a bit complicated.
She admits that she realized her mistake of slapping him and being impulsive. She wanted to reach out to him, but he didn't allow. Fine.
And then she got bitter. Maybe, her thoughts could have redirected into thinking that Shravan's father is some real culprit, because Shravan wasn't answering her.

In short, they could have mended their ways. They could have talked early.
They didn't, because for each of them, their individual family - was just too right and important. That's right for most people, right?
So why only blame one?

Suman filling the case again is a bit too much. She clearly says that it isn't about you and Devraj. She doesn't want Shravan to beg. So now we all should be thinking that she is some mad creature existing in the throes of this world?

No.
It isn't the case.

According to me, the pain of losing her father is like a nail dug in her skin. It hurts every single minute, which she wants to take out but couldn't. Shravan's indifference to her small/ or whatever amount of effort it takes to initiate the mending of broken relations - triggered that soft point. She doesn't consider her father martyred, she thinks he was murdered. She can't think forward. She is stuck. She wants to make Shravan feel her pain, of course by not losing his own father, but by making him realize that he shouldn't have left her or disowned her for her sudden impulsiveness. Of course, this is the ego which is making her think like that, but Suman Tiwari wants validation. She wants him to come to her and tell her that "I think it was my father's negligence. He is wrong somewhere, he shouldn't have done that."

And Shravan wants Suman to look through his pain as well. To look at her father, the way he looks at him. That how disturbed he is. But Suman, is such a tough nut, that the soft layering of his behaviour is now replaced with some maddening character - the Sanki Captain Malhotra.

Just like Suman can't apologize to Devraj, can't see him completely innocent (even if she doesn't want to hurt him- silly girl you know! ), Shravan too doesn't want to fall in her shoes. He doesn't want to completely understand how lonely she got, how difficult and different was her emotional trauma and seclusion. (Shravan too had his share of psychological disturbance, but he wasn't completely alone, I can see his friends for the good, let's not fight and compare. he at least had the hope of his father getting justice and victory, that he will find himself with his family in flesh and blood. I request you to at least give a bit leeway to Suman in this point.)


I made this post so that we can pull off a sane point of view for both the characters and not ruin our viewing experience. Please, try not to bash any of the leads, they have their own set of MU's, their own set of traumas. Let's respect it. I have written stories on post-leap scenarios, and it's always a heavy task to justify who suffered more.

Let's get it straight that Devraj had his set of faults, (the bribing, the hiding of details from Vijay), which might have come across Suman, and finally, she isn't able to get this out of her gut and of course, Shravan is a bit oblivious.

PS- Mohit and Kanikka nailed it in the episode today. Loads of love to the CVs for such a script!

Created

Last reply

Replies

13

Views

2.5k

Users

6

Likes

61

Frequent Posters

Veenapai thumbnail
Screen Detective Participant Thumbnail Visit Streak 1000 Thumbnail + 9
Posted: 4 years ago
#2

Loved your analysis. Completely agree. Apt title

zeal11 thumbnail
8th Anniversary Thumbnail Explorer Thumbnail
Posted: 4 years ago
#3

Holy cow !!! Such a beautiful sane post and completely agreed.

Nailah_EjFian thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail
Posted: 4 years ago
#4

Amazing though I wouldnt call it ego.. as she has proved it before.. she always admitted to her mistake..


would you mind if we share this on twitter for may be ppl would be able to see it from a neutral pt of view?

Edited by Nailah_EjFian - 4 years ago
raahiyaan thumbnail
7th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 4 years ago
#5

I think this piece of writing was really needed. Thank you. It's not that tough to understand both POVs especially after watching the episode. I would say this was the best episode since post leap started.


Things I was happy at —

1) Shravan made Suman see that she being lonely , all alone must have suffered but we Malhotras weren't doing some party.


2) Suman calling out Devraj's negligence which cost her father's life. She even admitted that she doesn't think D is fully innocent.


3) Shravan literally vent out about his part of trauma living as a being tagged traitor wasn't easy.


4) When Suman said "She doesn't feel 3 years in jail was enough as a punishment for showing such Negligence, Shravan's response was "so my Dad should be hanged till death?" But then Suman goes like "No. I don't want that but I feel his punishment was not that big in the cost of my Father's death"



The thing is I don't want things to get pile up and burdened on Suman only after the high court verdict. Shravan is very much delusioned regarding his dad. Suman called out Devraj's negligence but he thinks that isn't something a big crime.



I was laughing the entire Moment knowing Suman has again re-opened the case and has taken it to High court. Some might think she is taking revenge. She is egoistic but She Clarified she isn't doing it to take revenge but She is doing what she feels is right. If this extreme behavior of Suman is going to make Shravan see beyond his Dad's innocence, then be it.

nancy56 thumbnail
9th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 30 Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 4 years ago
#6

Originally posted by: Nailah_EjFian

Amazing though I wouldnt call it ego.. as she has proved it before.. she always admitted to her mistake..


would you mind if we share this on twitter for may be ppl would be able to see it from a neutral pt of view?

Of course, you can go ahead. I don't have a Twitter account ☺


Yeah more than ego its hurt. People have the habit of seeing fl's being meek and melting like an ice cream, but i am glad that Suman wasn't all water with his one confession because she suffered too, which Shravan kinda overlooked.

I am absolutely with the writer, this is something we needed, now it will be fun to see what happens!

You can't plaster somebody's negligence when it has cost lives. ( maybe, other soldiers could have died too)

Edited by nancy56 - 4 years ago
nancy56 thumbnail
9th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 30 Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 4 years ago
#7

Originally posted by: raahiyaan

I think this piece of writing was really needed. Thank you. It's not that tough to understand both POVs especially after watching the episode. I would say this was the best episode since post leap started.


Things I was happy at —

1) Shravan made Suman see that she being lonely , all alone must have suffered but we Malhotras weren't doing some party.


2) Suman calling out Devraj's negligence which cost her father's life. She even admitted that she doesn't think D is fully innocent.


3) Shravan literally vent out about his part of trauma living as a being tagged traitor wasn't easy.


4) When Suman said "She doesn't feel 3 years in jail was enough as a punishment for showing such Negligence, Shravan's response was "so my Dad should be hanged till death?" But then Suman goes like "No. I don't want that but I feel his punishment was not that big in the cost of my Father's death"



The thing is I don't want things to get pile up and burdened on Suman only after the high court verdict. Shravan is very much delusioned regarding his dad. Suman called out Devraj's negligence but he thinks that isn't something a big crime.



I was laughing the entire Moment knowing Suman has again re-opened the case and has taken it to High court. Some might think she is taking revenge. She is egoistic but She Clarified she isn't doing it to take revenge but She is doing what she feels is right. If this extreme behavior of Suman is going to make Shravan see beyond his Dad's innocence, then be it.


@bold: when Suman said that she doesnt want to punish Devraj and Shravan ( on the call), I so think that their is more to it. Maybe she has got some lead in the case.

We need to.understand that this story had a base mystery of vest deal and I still think that their is more to it. It can't be an open and shut case. Their is something which is gonna come out which we were not able to see!


I agree that Shravan needs to see that his father's negligence made Suman suffer the worst of fate.


Both of them have ego, we can't blame one.

Plus, shouldn't we credit Sumo for Sanki Malhotra's entry,LOL!!

taya2217 thumbnail
Explorer Thumbnail
Posted: 4 years ago
#8

A very balance post bc we r ignoring one thing which is revealed in this epi and is Suman actually tried to contact shravan but it was shravan who didn’t reply so one can’t blame Suman over all .....but the way things moving I wonder how the love and passion for each other will Gina rekindle again firstly I just can’t stand this lawyer character he takes so much of screen time but love to see shravan moving on with new girl ......it will be worth watching sanki Malhotra and after this mess and gathered will their love story start I want to see their preleap romance again but I think cvs r more interested in making vikram more Imp know the show .....I wish to se him fading away.

raahiyaan thumbnail
7th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 4 years ago
#9

Originally posted by: nancy56


@bold: when Suman said that she doesnt want to punish Devraj and Shravan ( on the call), I so think that their is more to it. Maybe she has got some lead in the case.

We need to.understand that this story had a base mystery of vest deal and I still think that their is more to it. It can't be an open and shut case. Their is something which is gonna come out which we were not able to see!


I agree that Shravan needs to see that his father's negligence made Suman suffer the worst of fate.


Both of them have ego, we can't blame one.

Plus, shouldn't we credit Sumo for Sanki Malhotra's entry,LOL!!


@Italics : I'd always felt that they can't just shut the case matter where neither Suman realized where she went wrong nor Shravan acknowledged where his father went wrong. And now Suman has re-opened it, there must be something that she had come to a conclusion to take the matter in HC. If she wanted to take sadistic pleasure (which even Shravan thinks) , she wouldn't have clarified him and say "I don't want you to plead people". That was very purani Sumo and Shravan for a moment calmed down.

Vijay's death and Case on Devraj is playing a catalyst.

raahiyaan thumbnail
7th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 4 years ago
#10

Originally posted by: nancy56


@bold: when Suman said that she doesnt want to punish Devraj and Shravan ( on the call), I so think that their is more to it. Maybe she has got some lead in the case.

We need to.understand that this story had a base mystery of vest deal and I still think that their is more to it. It can't be an open and shut case. Their is something which is gonna come out which we were not able to see!


I agree that Shravan needs to see that his father's negligence made Suman suffer the worst of fate.


Both of them have ego, we can't blame one.

Plus, shouldn't we credit Sumo for Sanki Malhotra's entry,LOL!!


@Bold : Yes. Suman has been the reason behind all of his transformations. Be it love sick puppy, Be it the Shravan to see the reality of life (the accusations on his dad), Be it the Shravan joining army to prove himself, Be it the Shravan who has turned into Sanki Malhotra 😆

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".