Shouldn't Meghna be blamed for Chaapak failure?

Frequent Posters

return_to_hades

@return_to_hades

Stunner

+ 6

Posted: 6 years ago

#61

Blame and failure are both harsh words.

There are somethings that can be written off as failures and the makers can be blamed for it. But there are some things that are so exceptionally difficult that there is really no failure, even attempting somethings can be counted as a success.

In my opinion, Chhapaak falls in the latter category. Telling a meaningful story about acid attack victims that is both thought-provoking and entertaining is not easy. Even if it is not successful as a film, it deserves appreciation for getting the conversation started.

I know Uyyare was more acclaimed, but due to linguistic divides not many people saw or appreciated it. And I feel this is a subject where everything that broaches the subject deserves merit.

Quote

1165988

Suspended

Posted: 6 years ago

#62

Originally posted by: return_to_hades
Blame and failure are both harsh words.

There are somethings that can be written off as failures and the makers can be blamed for it. But there are some things that are so exceptionally difficult that there is really no failure, even attempting somethings can be counted as a success.

In my opinion, Chhapaak falls in the latter category. Telling a meaningful story about acid attack victims that is both thought-provoking and entertaining is not easy. Even if it is not successful as a film, it deserves appreciation for getting the conversation started.

I know Uyyare was more acclaimed, but due to linguistic divides not many people saw or appreciated it. And I feel this is a subject where everything that broaches the subject deserves merit.

Iss MAHA-NEGATIVE forum par aap ki well balanced & positive soch ki koi value nahi hai rts ji.

sadly.