Spineless Bollywood? - Page 6

Originally posted by: ~*sindhu*~

What if most of those foreigners turn out to be non muslims like in the case of Assam NRC? Tab toh yehi rahenge taking our jobs and spreading poverty.

Govt will decide if they can be granted citizenship..then they will perform their duties and get their rights just like every citizen.. including paying taxes

Originally posted by: niyati13

When government makes rules there r campaigns against them..when they don't make rules they r prosecuted.. everything is govt. fault..aam janta se to common sense expect kiya hi nahi jaa sakta

Lmao.

And yes,everything is the government's fault. Our economy,lack of safety of women, the rate of unemployment,illegal immigration,poverty. Everything is the government's fault. Because do you know who runs this country? News Flash! The government does!

Originally posted by: Billi_Bangalan

assam me jinka nrc me naam nahi nikla wo abhi bhi hain to yahi. koi productive output nahi. this entire exercise has been a waste of energy, money and time. this will only lead to more strikes, riots and damage to public property paid by taxpayers .

the govt should think more about escalating vegetables price and unemployment honestly.

They are in detention camps .....now with the help of this bill major chunks of those so called illegal immigrants who are hindus will get citizen ship while muslims will be left in detention camps to rot . Someone who has lived whole life in india hasn't been able to produce any paper ( which is going to be many cases among poors and tribal areas ) which country do govt plan to deport them to ?

Originally posted by: Mahisa22

Bold: Are you serious??!! When has ANY attempt at population control ever worked in India? Its simply not possible in a country so big and populated like India. India has been trying to control its population since the time of Indira Gandhi, with jackshit results. And no, you cannot make a separate bill regulating the lives of immigrants, that would also attract huge criticism from sections of the society.

That suggestion is exceptionally naive and outrageous, sorry.

Oh so wait.. just because the government can't get population control right,its gonna blatantly curb the Muslim population?! That suggestion should be outrageous.

And ohhh,you cannot make a separate bill regulating the lives of immigrants and that will attract huge criticism from all sections of society BUT you can make a separate bill discriminating against Muslim immigrants and giving everybody else citizenship except them and that's completely fine and won't be criticised by all sections of society?! WOW. That's incredibly insightful! What does this 'all sections of society' entail? Hindus?! Just WOW.

Originally posted by: niyati13

Govt will decide if they can be granted citizenship..then they will perform their duties and get their rights just like every citizen.. including paying taxes

Government already decided they will be granted citizenship. And there is a very few percentage of citizens in this country who pay their taxes, maybe somewhere 10 crore people out of a 1,3 billion population who pays income taxes, rest of them are either too poor to come in any tax bracket or exempted from paying any. Indirect tax toh even illegal citizens pay while purchasing commodities.

Originally posted by: anjs

aise thodi citizen ko bedakhal karenge......... kuch toh upaay hoga, have patience........ this is same a demonitization......... nobody can remove the citizen from their own country.........

This is what gets said all the time ...arey aise thoda na hota hai and then things happen and no one opposes it . In assam nrc those muslims who served their while life in army were put in detention centre because they couldn't produce any paper.

Originally posted by: AllThatCritique

Lmao. Yeah only Bhakts have common sense and nobody else.

And yes,everything is the government's fault. Our economy,lack of safety of women, the rate of unemployment,illegal immigration,poverty. Everything is the government's fault. Because do you know who runs this country? News Flash! The government does!

U talked about laws on population control.. awareness create karne ki koshish ko itne saal se hol rahi hai..now it cannot go inside people's personal space ya? Isme govt kya control karegi jab insaan ka khud par control na ho

Originally posted by: niyati13

Govt will decide if they can be granted citizenship..then they will perform their duties and get their rights just like every citizen.. including paying taxes

Well as per this bill govt will give citizenship to those 14 lakhs hindus and 4-5 lakhs Muslims will be in detention center forever , it's that simple and out in the open .

When nationwide NRC will be done same thing will happen everywhere .

Originally posted by: Twinklingmoon

Completely sehmat to nahi Hoon me isase but yaar woh log yahan aake mostly labour work hi karte hai, ab mumbai me logonko labour work nahi karna hai to kisiko to karna padega na aur kaafi Kam payment pe kaam karte hai toh log hire bhi easily karte hai...

Yeh sab mess hai waise to, par as a country humko employment kaisi badhe yeh sochna chaiye naki usako hatake hum job karlenge

sorry but who said mumbai locals ko labor job nahi karna hai ? they will absolutely do it, if they have no other option, par job rahe toh.......... nowadays there is a serious politics happening in Railways job.....railway jobs whose base is in mumbai get advertised only in UP n Bihar local newspaper, those youths apply and come here for exams and mumbai local youths dont even know that there is an vacancy......... forget about marathi and non-marathi, but even a muslim / sikh / bihari who has lived in mumbai since their birth are mumbai locals and they deserve to know about the job vacancy in their locality, dont you think so ?

@red : yahi toh problem hai.........pura job market ulat pulat ho jata hai.....isse behtar hai woh apne state me khush rahe with decent job with good pay, with their families......and metro's ke local apne yaha, apne family ke saath.....

@blue : mai bhi toh wahi keh rahi hu......... they need to create more job opportunity in their own state, so if they want they can live with their family...... and only those migrate who want to migrate, can migrate.......

Originally posted by: niyati13

It's about immigrants from three countries who call themselves islamic nations..the religions given exemption are minorities there whose population has decreased considerably in last few years in their own countries..so when they seek help from India they can stay but not get all the rights of citizens ..and government is aware of their stay..but muslims who have come here to earn livelihood can always go back coz they r welcome in their own countries.

Edit: This in case of refugees..case will be different when they get citizenship

why just choose 3 countries and why just chose specific religions ? There are other neighbouring countries too where minorities are persecuted and there are other minorities too who are being persecuted in the similar way india is going to do now .