Alia vs. Deepika : Your opinions

So, everyone is pitting them against each other though I believe Deepika is far ahead in stardom and acting both. Alia acc. to me is an overrated actress. She is a one-note actor and tends to overdo. Deepika is subtle and restrained in most of her roles. Also, the kind of acting Deepika did in Piku/Tamasha I don't think Alia can do.

Alia's only major achievement is Udta Punjab. She was fab there.

Opinions please.